TED2009
Nina Jablonski: Skin color is an illusion
Filmed:
Readability: 4.8
1,260,305 views
Nina Jablonski says that differing skin colors are simply our bodies' adaptation to varied climates and levels of UV exposure. Charles Darwin disagreed with this theory, but she explains, that's because he did not have access to NASA.
Nina Jablonski - Anthropologist
Nina Jablonski is author of Skin: A Natural History, a close look at human skin’s many remarkable traits: its colors, its sweatiness, the fact that we decorate it. Full bio
Nina Jablonski is author of Skin: A Natural History, a close look at human skin’s many remarkable traits: its colors, its sweatiness, the fact that we decorate it. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:18
Interestingly, Charles Darwin
0
0
4000
00:22
was born a very lightly pigmented man,
1
4000
4000
00:26
in a moderately-to-darkly pigmented world.
2
8000
4000
00:30
Over the course of his life,
3
12000
3000
00:33
Darwin had great privilege.
4
15000
2000
00:35
He lived in a fairly wealthy home.
5
17000
3000
00:38
He was raised by very supportive and interested parents.
6
20000
4000
00:42
And when he was in his 20s
7
24000
2000
00:44
he embarked upon a remarkable voyage on the ship the Beagle.
8
26000
4000
00:48
And during the course of that voyage,
9
30000
3000
00:51
he saw remarkable things:
10
33000
2000
00:53
tremendous diversity of plants and animals, and humans.
11
35000
4000
00:57
And the observations that he made
12
39000
2000
00:59
on that epic journey
13
41000
2000
01:01
were to be eventually distilled
14
43000
2000
01:03
into his wonderful book, "On the Origin of Species,"
15
45000
2000
01:05
published 150 years ago.
16
47000
4000
01:09
Now what is so interesting
17
51000
2000
01:11
and to some, the extent, what's a bit infamous
18
53000
4000
01:15
about "The Origin of Species,"
19
57000
2000
01:17
is that there is only one line in it
20
59000
2000
01:19
about human evolution.
21
61000
3000
01:22
"Light will be thrown on the origin of man
22
64000
3000
01:25
and his history."
23
67000
2000
01:27
It wasn't until much longer,
24
69000
2000
01:29
much later,
25
71000
2000
01:31
that Darwin actually spoke
26
73000
2000
01:33
and wrote about humans.
27
75000
3000
01:36
Now in his years of
28
78000
2000
01:38
traveling on the Beagle,
29
80000
2000
01:40
and from listening to the accounts
30
82000
2000
01:42
or explorers and naturalists,
31
84000
2000
01:44
he knew that skin color
32
86000
4000
01:48
was one of the most important ways
33
90000
2000
01:50
in which people varied.
34
92000
2000
01:52
And he was somewhat interested in the pattern of skin color.
35
94000
4000
01:56
He knew that darkly pigmented peoples
36
98000
2000
01:58
were found close to the equator;
37
100000
3000
02:01
lightly pigmented peoples, like himself,
38
103000
2000
02:03
were found closer to the poles.
39
105000
3000
02:06
So what did he make of all this?
40
108000
2000
02:08
Well he didn't write anything about it in The Origin of Species.
41
110000
3000
02:11
But much later, in 1871,
42
113000
3000
02:14
he did have something to say about it.
43
116000
2000
02:16
And it was quite curious. He said,
44
118000
2000
02:18
"Of all the differences between the races of men,
45
120000
3000
02:21
the color of the skin is the most conspicuous
46
123000
2000
02:23
and one of the best marked."
47
125000
2000
02:25
And he went on to say,
48
127000
2000
02:27
"These differences do not coincide
49
129000
3000
02:30
with corresponding differences in climate."
50
132000
3000
02:33
So he had traveled all around.
51
135000
2000
02:35
He had seen people of different colors
52
137000
3000
02:38
living in different places.
53
140000
2000
02:40
And yet he rejected the idea
54
142000
2000
02:42
that human skin pigmentation
55
144000
3000
02:45
was related to the climate.
56
147000
3000
02:48
If only Darwin lived today.
57
150000
3000
02:51
If only Darwin had NASA.
58
153000
3000
02:54
Now, one of the wonderful things that NASA does
59
156000
4000
02:58
is it puts up a variety of satellites
60
160000
2000
03:00
that detect all sort of interesting things about our environment.
61
162000
3000
03:03
And for many decades now
62
165000
3000
03:06
there have been a series of TOMS satellites
63
168000
3000
03:09
that have collected data about the radiation of the Earth's surface.
64
171000
3000
03:12
The TOMS 7 satellite data, shown here,
65
174000
4000
03:16
show the annual average
66
178000
2000
03:18
ultraviolet radiation at the Earth's surface.
67
180000
3000
03:21
Now the really hot pink and red areas
68
183000
3000
03:24
are those parts of the world that receive the highest amounts
69
186000
3000
03:27
of UV during the year.
70
189000
3000
03:30
The incrementally cooler colors --
71
192000
3000
03:33
blues, greens, yellows, and finally grays --
72
195000
3000
03:36
indicate areas of much lower ultraviolet radiation.
73
198000
3000
03:39
What's significant to the story of human skin pigmentation
74
201000
4000
03:43
is just how much of the Northern Hemisphere
75
205000
4000
03:47
is in these cool gray zones.
76
209000
3000
03:50
This has tremendous implications for our understanding
77
212000
3000
03:53
of the evolution of human skin pigmentation.
78
215000
3000
03:56
And what Darwin could not appreciate,
79
218000
3000
03:59
or didn't perhaps want to appreciate at the time,
80
221000
3000
04:02
is that there was a fundamental relationship
81
224000
3000
04:05
between the intensity of ultraviolet radiation
82
227000
3000
04:08
and skin pigmentation.
83
230000
2000
04:10
And that skin pigmentation itself
84
232000
3000
04:13
was a product of evolution.
85
235000
3000
04:16
And so when we look at a map of skin color,
86
238000
3000
04:19
and predicted skin color, as we know it today,
87
241000
3000
04:22
what we see is a beautiful gradient
88
244000
3000
04:25
from the darkest skin pigmentations toward the equator,
89
247000
3000
04:28
and the lightest ones toward the poles.
90
250000
3000
04:31
What's very, very important here
91
253000
4000
04:35
is that the earliest humans
92
257000
2000
04:37
evolved in high-UV environments,
93
259000
3000
04:40
in equatorial Africa.
94
262000
2000
04:42
The earliest members of our lineage,
95
264000
3000
04:45
the genus Homo, were darkly pigmented.
96
267000
3000
04:48
And we all share this incredible heritage
97
270000
4000
04:52
of having originally been
98
274000
2000
04:54
darkly pigmented,
99
276000
2000
04:56
two million to one and half million years ago.
100
278000
3000
04:59
Now what happened in our history?
101
281000
5000
05:04
Let's first look at the relationship
102
286000
2000
05:06
of ultraviolet radiation to the Earth's surface.
103
288000
3000
05:09
In those early days of our evolution,
104
291000
3000
05:12
looking at the equator,
105
294000
2000
05:14
we were bombarded by high levels of ultraviolet radiation.
106
296000
3000
05:17
The UVC, the most energetic type,
107
299000
3000
05:20
was occluded by the Earth's atmosphere.
108
302000
3000
05:23
But UVB and UVA
109
305000
2000
05:25
especially, came in unimpeded.
110
307000
2000
05:27
UVB turns out to be incredibly important.
111
309000
4000
05:31
It's very destructive,
112
313000
2000
05:33
but it also catalyzes the production of vitamin D in the skin,
113
315000
4000
05:37
vitamin D being a molecule that we very much need
114
319000
4000
05:41
for our strong bones, the health of our immune system,
115
323000
4000
05:45
and myriad other important functions in our bodies.
116
327000
3000
05:48
So, living at the equator, we got
117
330000
2000
05:50
lots and lots of ultraviolet radiation
118
332000
3000
05:53
and the melanin --
119
335000
3000
05:56
this wonderful, complex, ancient polymer
120
338000
4000
06:00
compound in our skin --
121
342000
2000
06:02
served as a superb natural sunscreen.
122
344000
4000
06:06
This polymer is amazing
123
348000
2000
06:08
because it's present in so many different organisms.
124
350000
3000
06:11
Melanin, in various forms, has probably been on the Earth
125
353000
2000
06:13
a billion years,
126
355000
3000
06:16
and has been recruited over and over again
127
358000
2000
06:18
by evolution, as often happens.
128
360000
4000
06:22
Why change it if it works?
129
364000
2000
06:24
So melanin was recruited, in our lineage,
130
366000
4000
06:28
and specifically in our earliest ancestors
131
370000
3000
06:31
evolving in Africa,
132
373000
2000
06:33
to be a natural sunscreen.
133
375000
2000
06:35
Where it protected the body
134
377000
2000
06:37
against the degradations of ultraviolet radiation,
135
379000
3000
06:40
the destruction, or damage to DNA,
136
382000
3000
06:43
and the breakdown of a very important molecule called folate,
137
385000
4000
06:47
which helps to fuel cell production,
138
389000
3000
06:50
and reproduction in the body.
139
392000
3000
06:53
So, it's wonderful. We evolved this very protective,
140
395000
3000
06:56
wonderful covering of melanin.
141
398000
3000
06:59
But then we moved.
142
401000
4000
07:03
And humans dispersed -- not once, but twice.
143
405000
4000
07:07
Major moves, outside of our equatorial homeland,
144
409000
4000
07:11
from Africa into other parts of the Old World,
145
413000
4000
07:15
and most recently, into the New World.
146
417000
2000
07:17
When humans dispersed into these latitudes,
147
419000
3000
07:20
what did they face?
148
422000
2000
07:22
Conditions were significantly colder,
149
424000
3000
07:25
but they were also less intense
150
427000
2000
07:27
with respect to the ultraviolet regime.
151
429000
2000
07:29
So if we're somewhere in the Northern Hemisphere,
152
431000
4000
07:33
look at what's happening to the ultraviolet radiation.
153
435000
3000
07:36
We're still getting a dose of UVA.
154
438000
3000
07:39
But all of the UVB,
155
441000
2000
07:41
or nearly all of it,
156
443000
2000
07:43
is dissipated through the thickness of the atmosphere.
157
445000
3000
07:46
In the winter, when you are skiing in the Alps,
158
448000
4000
07:50
you may experience ultraviolet radiation.
159
452000
3000
07:53
But it's all UVA,
160
455000
2000
07:55
and, significantly, that UVA
161
457000
2000
07:57
has no ability to make vitamin D in your skin.
162
459000
5000
08:02
So people inhabiting northern hemispheric environments
163
464000
5000
08:07
were bereft of the potential
164
469000
3000
08:10
to make vitamin D in their skin for most of the year.
165
472000
3000
08:13
This had tremendous consequences
166
475000
3000
08:16
for the evolution of human skin pigmentation.
167
478000
2000
08:18
Because what happened, in order to ensure health and well-being,
168
480000
5000
08:23
these lineages of people
169
485000
2000
08:25
dispersing into the Northern Hemisphere
170
487000
4000
08:29
lost their pigmentation.
171
491000
2000
08:31
There was natural selection
172
493000
2000
08:33
for the evolution of lightly pigmented skin.
173
495000
5000
08:38
Here we begin to see the evolution
174
500000
2000
08:40
of the beautiful sepia rainbow
175
502000
2000
08:42
that now characterizes all of humanity.
176
504000
3000
08:45
Lightly pigmented skin evolved not just once,
177
507000
4000
08:49
not just twice, but probably three times.
178
511000
3000
08:52
Not just in modern humans,
179
514000
2000
08:54
but in one of our distant unrelated ancestors,
180
516000
4000
08:58
the Neanderthals.
181
520000
2000
09:00
A remarkable, remarkable testament
182
522000
2000
09:02
to the power of evolution.
183
524000
2000
09:04
Humans have been on the move for a long time.
184
526000
3000
09:07
And just in the last 5,000 years,
185
529000
2000
09:09
in increasing rates, over increasing distances.
186
531000
3000
09:12
Here are just some of the biggest movements of people,
187
534000
4000
09:16
voluntary movements, in the last 5,000 years.
188
538000
3000
09:19
Look at some of the major latitudinal transgressions:
189
541000
3000
09:22
people from high UV areas
190
544000
2000
09:24
going to low UV and vice versa.
191
546000
3000
09:27
And not all these moves were voluntary.
192
549000
4000
09:31
Between 1520 and 1867,
193
553000
3000
09:34
12 million, 500 people
194
556000
4000
09:38
were moved from high UV
195
560000
2000
09:40
to low UV areas
196
562000
2000
09:42
in the transatlantic slave trade.
197
564000
3000
09:45
Now this had all sorts of invidious social consequences.
198
567000
4000
09:49
But it also had deleterious
199
571000
3000
09:52
health consequences to people.
200
574000
2000
09:54
So what? We've been on the move.
201
576000
3000
09:57
We're so clever we can overcome all of these
202
579000
3000
10:00
seeming biological impediments.
203
582000
3000
10:03
Well, often we're unaware
204
585000
2000
10:05
of the fact that we're living
205
587000
2000
10:07
in environments in which our skin
206
589000
2000
10:09
is inherently poorly adapted.
207
591000
3000
10:12
Some of us with lightly pigmented skin
208
594000
2000
10:14
live in high-UV areas.
209
596000
2000
10:16
Some of us with darkly pigmented skin
210
598000
2000
10:18
live in low-UV areas.
211
600000
3000
10:21
These have tremendous consequences for our health.
212
603000
4000
10:25
We have to, if we're lightly pigmented,
213
607000
3000
10:28
be careful about the problems of skin cancer,
214
610000
4000
10:32
and destruction of folate in our bodies,
215
614000
3000
10:35
by lots of sun.
216
617000
2000
10:37
Epidemiologists and doctors
217
619000
2000
10:39
have been very good about telling us
218
621000
2000
10:41
about protecting our skin.
219
623000
2000
10:43
What they haven't been so good about instructing people
220
625000
5000
10:48
is the problem of darkly pigmented people
221
630000
3000
10:51
living in high latitude areas,
222
633000
3000
10:54
or working inside all the time.
223
636000
2000
10:56
Because the problem there is just as severe,
224
638000
3000
10:59
but it is more sinister,
225
641000
2000
11:01
because vitamin D deficiency,
226
643000
2000
11:03
from a lack of ultraviolet B radiation,
227
645000
4000
11:07
is a major problem.
228
649000
2000
11:09
Vitamin D deficiency creeps up on people,
229
651000
2000
11:11
and causes all sorts of health problems to their bones,
230
653000
3000
11:14
to their gradual decay of their immune systems,
231
656000
4000
11:18
or loss of immune function,
232
660000
2000
11:20
and probably some problems
233
662000
2000
11:22
with their mood and health,
234
664000
3000
11:25
their mental health.
235
667000
2000
11:27
So we have, in skin pigmentation,
236
669000
3000
11:30
one of these wonderful products of evolution
237
672000
3000
11:33
that still has consequences for us today.
238
675000
2000
11:35
And the social consequences,
239
677000
2000
11:37
as we know, are incredibly profound.
240
679000
3000
11:40
We live in a world where we
241
682000
2000
11:42
have lightly and darkly pigmented people
242
684000
4000
11:46
living next to one another,
243
688000
2000
11:48
but often brought into proximity initially
244
690000
3000
11:51
as a result of very invidious social interactions.
245
693000
4000
11:55
So how can we overcome this?
246
697000
3000
11:58
How can we begin to understand it?
247
700000
2000
12:00
Evolution helps us.
248
702000
4000
12:04
200 years after Darwin's birthday,
249
706000
4000
12:08
we have the first moderately pigmented President of the United States.
250
710000
5000
12:13
(Applause)
251
715000
1000
12:14
How wonderful is that?
252
716000
2000
12:16
(Applause)
253
718000
2000
12:18
This man is significant for a whole host of reasons.
254
720000
4000
12:22
But we need to think about how he compares,
255
724000
3000
12:25
in terms of his pigmentation, to other people on Earth.
256
727000
2000
12:27
He, as one of many urban admixed populations,
257
729000
4000
12:31
is very emblematic
258
733000
2000
12:33
of a mixed parentage, of a mixed pigmentation.
259
735000
3000
12:36
And he resembles, very closely,
260
738000
2000
12:38
people with moderate levels of pigmentation
261
740000
3000
12:41
who live in southern Africa, or Southeast Asia.
262
743000
4000
12:45
These people have a tremendous potential
263
747000
2000
12:47
to tan, to develop more pigment in their skin,
264
749000
3000
12:50
as a result of exposure to sun.
265
752000
2000
12:52
They also run the risk of vitamin D deficiency,
266
754000
4000
12:56
if they have desk jobs, like that guy.
267
758000
4000
13:00
So lets all wish for his great health,
268
762000
4000
13:04
and his awareness of his own skin pigmentation.
269
766000
5000
13:09
Now what is wonderful
270
771000
3000
13:12
about the evolution of human skin pigmentation,
271
774000
4000
13:16
and the phenomenon of pigmentation,
272
778000
2000
13:18
is that it is the demonstration,
273
780000
3000
13:21
the evidence, of evolution
274
783000
3000
13:24
by natural selection,
275
786000
2000
13:26
right on your body.
276
788000
4000
13:30
When people ask you, "What is the evidence for evolution?"
277
792000
3000
13:33
You don't have to think about some exotic examples, or fossils.
278
795000
4000
13:37
You just have to look at your skin.
279
799000
3000
13:40
Darwin, I think, would have appreciated this,
280
802000
4000
13:44
even though he eschewed the importance
281
806000
3000
13:47
of climate on the evolution of pigmentation during his own life.
282
809000
4000
13:51
I think, were he able to look
283
813000
3000
13:54
at the evidence we have today, he would understand it.
284
816000
3000
13:57
He would appreciate it.
285
819000
2000
13:59
And most of all, he would teach it.
286
821000
4000
14:03
You, you can teach it.
287
825000
3000
14:06
You can touch it.
288
828000
2000
14:08
You can understand it.
289
830000
2000
14:10
Take it out of this room.
290
832000
3000
14:13
Take your skin color,
291
835000
2000
14:15
and celebrate it.
292
837000
2000
14:17
Spread the word.
293
839000
2000
14:19
You have the evolution
294
841000
2000
14:21
of the history of our species,
295
843000
4000
14:25
part of it, written in your skin.
296
847000
2000
14:27
Understand it. Appreciate it. Celebrate it.
297
849000
3000
14:30
Go out. Isn't it beautiful? Isn't it wonderful?
298
852000
4000
14:34
You are the products of evolution.
299
856000
3000
14:37
Thank you.
300
859000
2000
14:39
(Applause)
301
861000
4000
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Nina Jablonski - AnthropologistNina Jablonski is author of Skin: A Natural History, a close look at human skin’s many remarkable traits: its colors, its sweatiness, the fact that we decorate it.
Why you should listen
"Much of what we consider our humanity is imbued in our skin," Nina Jablonski tells us. This insight came to her in 1981, as she observed a jittery anatomy class warm to a cadaver only after cutting through its skin. As it turns out, marvels abound of this sweaty, hardwearing, social -- and underappreciated -- organ. Many are collected in her book, Skin: A Natural History, a look at what makes our skin unique and, perhaps, more important than we realize.
A fascination with the multicolored, multi-talented human hide fits Jablonski, a truly eclectic scientist. She's also a paleontologist and primatologist, studying the form, behavior and diet of mammals in light of climate change and evolution. She teaches at Penn State and recently found the world's oldest chimpanzee fossil.
Nina Jablonski | Speaker | TED.com