TEDSalon Berlin 2014
Heather Barnett: What humans can learn from semi-intelligent slime
Filmed:
Readability: 5.7
1,179,448 views
Inspired by biological design and self-organizing systems, artist Heather Barnett co-creates with physarum polycephalum, a eukaryotic microorganism that lives in cool, moist areas. What can people learn from the semi-intelligent slime mold? Watch this talk to find out.
Heather Barnett - Artist
Heather Barnett creates art with slime mold -- a material used in diverse areas of scientific research, including biological computing, robotics and structural design. Full bio
Heather Barnett creates art with slime mold -- a material used in diverse areas of scientific research, including biological computing, robotics and structural design. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
I'd like to introduce you to an organism:
0
632
3105
00:15
a slime mold, Physarum polycephalum.
1
3737
3456
00:19
It's a mold with an identity
crisis, because it's not a mold,
crisis, because it's not a mold,
2
7193
2822
00:22
so let's get that straight to start with.
3
10015
1930
00:23
It is one of 700 known slime molds
4
11945
2536
00:26
belonging to the kingdom of the amoeba.
5
14481
2137
00:28
It is a single-celled organism, a cell,
6
16618
2623
00:31
that joins together with other cells
7
19241
2240
00:33
to form a mass super-cell
8
21481
2232
00:35
to maximize its resources.
9
23713
2240
00:37
So within a slime mold you might find thousands
10
25953
2160
00:40
or millions of nuclei,
11
28113
2247
00:42
all sharing a cell wall,
12
30360
1761
00:44
all operating as one entity.
13
32121
3108
00:47
In its natural habitat,
14
35229
1604
00:48
you might find the slime mold foraging in woodlands,
15
36833
2796
00:51
eating rotting vegetation,
16
39629
3701
00:55
but you might equally find it
17
43330
1540
00:56
in research laboratories,
18
44870
1542
00:58
classrooms, and even artists' studios.
19
46412
4202
01:02
I first came across the slime
mold about five years ago.
mold about five years ago.
20
50614
2935
01:05
A microbiologist friend of mine
21
53549
1557
01:07
gave me a petri dish with a little yellow blob in it
22
55106
3124
01:10
and told me to go home and play with it.
23
58230
3008
01:13
The only instructions I was given,
24
61238
2007
01:15
that it likes it dark and damp
25
63245
1784
01:17
and its favorite food is porridge oats.
26
65029
4331
01:21
I'm an artist who's worked for many years
27
69360
2018
01:23
with biology, with scientific processes,
28
71378
2847
01:26
so living material is not uncommon for me.
29
74225
3011
01:29
I've worked with plants, bacteria,
30
77236
2105
01:31
cuttlefish, fruit flies.
31
79341
1519
01:32
So I was keen to get my new collaborator home
32
80860
2602
01:35
to see what it could do.
33
83462
1376
01:36
So I took it home and I watched.
34
84838
3202
01:40
I fed it a varied diet.
35
88040
2770
01:42
I observed as it networked.
36
90810
1924
01:44
It formed a connection between food sources.
37
92734
2276
01:47
I watched it leave a trail behind it,
38
95010
2838
01:49
indicating where it had been.
39
97848
1759
01:51
And I noticed that when it was
fed up with one petri dish,
fed up with one petri dish,
40
99607
2948
01:54
it would escape and find a better home.
41
102555
2979
01:57
I captured my observations
42
105534
1728
01:59
through time-lapse photography.
43
107262
1760
02:01
Slime mold grows at about one centimeter an hour,
44
109022
2838
02:03
so it's not really ideal for live viewing
45
111860
2581
02:06
unless there's some form of
really extreme meditation,
really extreme meditation,
46
114441
2853
02:09
but through the time lapse,
47
117294
2528
02:11
I could observe some really interesting behaviors.
48
119822
3096
02:14
For instance, having fed on a nice pile of oats,
49
122918
3500
02:18
the slime mold goes off to explore new territories
50
126418
4444
02:22
in different directions simultaneously.
51
130862
2732
02:25
When it meets itself,
52
133594
2239
02:27
it knows it's already there,
53
135833
1867
02:29
it recognizes it's there,
54
137700
1954
02:31
and instead retreats back
55
139654
1547
02:33
and grows in other directions.
56
141201
3680
02:36
I was quite impressed by this feat,
57
144881
2324
02:39
at how what was essentially
just a bag of cellular slime
just a bag of cellular slime
58
147205
3550
02:42
could somehow map its territory,
59
150755
3230
02:45
know itself, and move with seeming intention.
60
153985
3472
02:49
I found countless scientific studies,
61
157457
3653
02:53
research papers, journal articles,
62
161110
2045
02:55
all citing incredible work with this one organism,
63
163155
4224
02:59
and I'm going to share a few of those with you.
64
167379
1964
03:01
For example, a team in Hokkaido University in Japan
65
169343
2960
03:04
filled a maze with slime mold.
66
172303
2032
03:06
It joined together and formed a mass cell.
67
174335
2096
03:08
They introduced food at two points,
68
176431
2352
03:10
oats of course,
69
178783
1198
03:11
and it formed a connection
70
179981
1646
03:13
between the food.
71
181627
1414
03:15
It retracted from empty areas and dead ends.
72
183041
2484
03:17
There are four possible routes through this maze,
73
185525
2810
03:20
yet time and time again,
74
188335
2105
03:22
the slime mold established the shortest
75
190440
2167
03:24
and the most efficient route.
76
192607
2453
03:27
Quite clever.
77
195060
1251
03:28
The conclusion from their experiment
78
196311
1739
03:30
was that the slime mold had
a primitive form of intelligence.
a primitive form of intelligence.
79
198050
2997
03:33
Another study exposed cold air at
regular intervals to the slime mold.
regular intervals to the slime mold.
80
201047
3863
03:36
It didn't like it. It doesn't like it cold.
81
204910
2345
03:39
It doesn't like it dry.
82
207255
1193
03:40
They did this at repeat intervals,
83
208448
2115
03:42
and each time, the slime mold
84
210563
1658
03:44
slowed down its growth in response.
85
212221
3130
03:47
However, at the next interval,
86
215351
1844
03:49
the researchers didn't put the cold air on,
87
217195
2824
03:52
yet the slime mold slowed down in anticipation
88
220019
3294
03:55
of it happening.
89
223313
1336
03:56
It somehow knew that it was about the time
90
224649
2526
03:59
for the cold air that it didn't like.
91
227175
1956
04:01
The conclusion from their experiment
92
229131
1689
04:02
was that the slime mold was able to learn.
93
230820
3270
04:06
A third experiment:
94
234090
1231
04:07
the slime mold was invited
95
235321
1767
04:09
to explore a territory covered in oats.
96
237088
4192
04:13
It fans out in a branching pattern.
97
241280
3047
04:16
As it goes, each food node it finds,
98
244327
2648
04:18
it forms a network, a connection to,
99
246975
2700
04:21
and keeps foraging.
100
249675
1748
04:23
After 26 hours, it established
101
251423
2441
04:25
quite a firm network
102
253864
1617
04:27
between the different oats.
103
255481
1790
04:29
Now there's nothing remarkable in this
104
257271
1820
04:31
until you learn that the center oat that it started from
105
259091
2412
04:33
represents the city of Tokyo,
106
261503
2014
04:35
and the surrounding oats are
suburban railway stations.
suburban railway stations.
107
263517
4066
04:39
The slime mold had replicated
108
267583
2481
04:42
the Tokyo transport network
109
270064
2416
04:44
— (Laughter) —
110
272480
1655
04:46
a complex system developed over time
111
274135
2995
04:49
by community dwellings, civil
engineering, urban planning.
engineering, urban planning.
112
277130
3900
04:53
What had taken us well over 100 years
113
281030
2273
04:55
took the slime mold just over a day.
114
283303
3166
04:58
The conclusion from their experiment
115
286469
1653
05:00
was that the slime mold can form efficient networks
116
288122
2510
05:02
and solve the traveling salesman problem.
117
290632
2623
05:05
It is a biological computer.
118
293255
2264
05:07
As such, it has been mathematically modeled,
119
295519
2624
05:10
algorithmically analyzed.
120
298143
1661
05:11
It's been sonified, replicated, simulated.
121
299804
2705
05:14
World over, teams of researchers
122
302509
2970
05:17
are decoding its biological principles
123
305479
2970
05:20
to understand its computational rules
124
308449
2141
05:22
and applying that learning
to the fields of electronics,
to the fields of electronics,
125
310590
2254
05:24
programming and robotics.
126
312844
2236
05:27
So the question is,
127
315080
2154
05:29
how does this thing work?
128
317234
2020
05:31
It doesn't have a central nervous system.
129
319254
2160
05:33
It doesn't have a brain,
130
321414
1698
05:35
yet it can perform behaviors
131
323112
1828
05:36
that we associate with brain function.
132
324940
1988
05:38
It can learn, it can remember,
133
326928
1908
05:40
it can solve problems, it can make decisions.
134
328836
2757
05:43
So where does that intelligence lie?
135
331593
2715
05:46
So this is a microscopy, a video I shot,
136
334308
2492
05:48
and it's about 100 times magnification,
137
336800
2653
05:51
sped up about 20 times,
138
339453
2867
05:54
and inside the slime mold,
139
342320
1786
05:56
there is a rhythmic pulsing flow,
140
344106
3442
05:59
a vein-like structure carrying
141
347548
2168
06:01
cellular material, nutrients and chemical information
142
349716
3772
06:05
through the cell,
143
353488
1858
06:07
streaming first in one direction
and then back in another.
and then back in another.
144
355346
3618
06:10
And it is this continuous, synchronous oscillation
145
358964
3817
06:14
within the cell that allows it to form
146
362781
2256
06:17
quite a complex understanding of its environment,
147
365037
2982
06:20
but without any large-scale control center.
148
368019
3369
06:23
This is where its intelligence lies.
149
371388
2581
06:25
So it's not just academic researchers
150
373969
3244
06:29
in universities that are interested in this organism.
151
377213
2644
06:31
A few years ago, I set up SliMoCo,
152
379857
2873
06:34
the Slime Mould Collective.
153
382730
2340
06:37
It's an online, open, democratic network
154
385070
3223
06:40
for slime mold researchers and enthusiasts
155
388293
2096
06:42
to share knowledge and experimentation
156
390389
2729
06:45
across disciplinary divides
157
393118
2968
06:48
and across academic divides.
158
396086
3695
06:51
The Slime Mould Collective
membership is self-selecting.
membership is self-selecting.
159
399781
3440
06:55
People have found the collective
160
403221
2796
06:58
as the slime mold finds the oats.
161
406017
3698
07:01
And it comprises of scientists
162
409715
1693
07:03
and computer scientists and researchers
163
411408
1559
07:04
but also artists like me,
164
412967
2287
07:07
architects, designers, writers, activists, you name it.
165
415254
5092
07:12
It's a very interesting, eclectic membership.
166
420346
4183
07:16
Just a few examples:
167
424529
1337
07:17
an artist who paints with fluorescent Physarum;
168
425866
3125
07:20
a collaborative team
169
428991
1572
07:22
who are combining biological and electronic design
170
430563
3778
07:26
with 3D printing technologies in a workshop;
171
434341
3145
07:29
another artist who is using the slime mold
172
437486
2134
07:31
as a way of engaging a community
173
439620
2100
07:33
to map their area.
174
441720
3004
07:36
Here, the slime mold is being used directly
175
444724
2162
07:38
as a biological tool, but metaphorically
176
446886
2878
07:41
as a symbol for ways of talking
177
449764
1984
07:43
about social cohesion, communication
178
451748
3854
07:47
and cooperation.
179
455602
1864
07:49
Other public engagement activities,
180
457466
2510
07:51
I run lots of slime mold workshops,
181
459976
2018
07:53
a creative way of engaging with the organism.
182
461994
2462
07:56
So people are invited to come and learn
183
464456
1684
07:58
about what amazing things it can do,
184
466140
1896
08:00
and they design their own petri dish experiment,
185
468036
2646
08:02
an environment for the slime mold to navigate
186
470682
2316
08:04
so they can test its properties.
187
472998
1638
08:06
Everybody takes home a new pet
188
474636
2444
08:09
and is invited to post their results
189
477080
2940
08:12
on the Slime Mould Collective.
190
480020
2418
08:14
And the collective has enabled me
191
482438
1448
08:15
to form collaborations
192
483886
2362
08:18
with a whole array of interesting people.
193
486248
2593
08:20
I've been working with filmmakers
194
488841
1593
08:22
on a feature-length slime mold documentary,
195
490434
3466
08:25
and I stress feature-length,
196
493900
2658
08:28
which is in the final stages of edit
197
496558
1709
08:30
and will be hitting your cinema screens very soon.
198
498267
3026
08:33
(Laughter)
199
501293
1480
08:34
It's also enabled me to conduct what I think is
200
502773
3335
08:38
the world's first human slime mold experiment.
201
506108
2873
08:40
This is part of an exhibition in Rotterdam last year.
202
508981
2972
08:43
We invited people to become
slime mold for half an hour.
slime mold for half an hour.
203
511953
4691
08:48
So we essentially tied people together
204
516644
3341
08:51
so they were a giant cell,
205
519985
2324
08:54
and invited them to follow slime mold rules.
206
522309
2844
08:57
You have to communicate through oscillations,
207
525153
3431
09:00
no speaking.
208
528584
1296
09:01
You have to operate as one entity, one mass cell,
209
529880
4933
09:06
no egos,
210
534813
1584
09:08
and the motivation for moving
211
536397
2585
09:10
and then exploring the environment
212
538982
1908
09:12
is in search of food.
213
540890
1899
09:14
So a chaotic shuffle ensued
as this bunch of strangers
as this bunch of strangers
214
542789
3631
09:18
tied together with yellow ropes
wearing "Being Slime Mold" t-shirts
wearing "Being Slime Mold" t-shirts
215
546420
3908
09:22
wandered through the museum park.
216
550328
2956
09:25
When they met trees, they had to reshape
217
553284
3326
09:28
their connections and reform as a mass cell
218
556610
3132
09:31
through not speaking.
219
559742
3987
09:35
This is a ludicrous experiment in many, many ways.
220
563729
3358
09:39
This isn't hypothesis-driven.
221
567087
1949
09:41
We're not trying to prove, demonstrate anything.
222
569036
2443
09:43
But what it did provide us was a way
223
571479
2134
09:45
of engaging a broad section of the public
224
573613
2348
09:47
with ideas of intelligence, agency, autonomy,
225
575961
4431
09:52
and provide a playful platform
226
580392
2329
09:54
for discussions about
227
582721
3732
09:58
the things that ensued.
228
586453
2384
10:00
One of the most exciting things
229
588837
2333
10:03
about this experiment
230
591170
2860
10:06
was the conversation that happened afterwards.
231
594030
2187
10:08
An entirely spontaneous symposium
happened in the park.
happened in the park.
232
596217
3823
10:12
People talked about the human psychology,
233
600040
2029
10:14
of how difficult it was to let go
234
602069
1657
10:15
of their individual personalities and egos.
235
603726
3309
10:19
Other people talked about bacterial communication.
236
607035
3183
10:22
Each person brought in their own
237
610218
1979
10:24
individual interpretation,
238
612197
2857
10:27
and our conclusion from this experiment was that
239
615054
1905
10:28
the people of Rotterdam were highly cooperative,
240
616959
3906
10:32
especially when given beer.
241
620865
2796
10:35
We didn't just give them oats.
242
623661
1966
10:37
We gave them beer as well.
243
625627
1562
10:39
But they weren't as efficient as the slime mold,
244
627189
2194
10:41
and the slime mold, for me,
245
629383
1984
10:43
is a fascinating subject matter.
246
631367
2369
10:45
It's biologically fascinating,
247
633736
1857
10:47
it's computationally interesting,
248
635593
1584
10:49
but it's also a symbol,
249
637177
2074
10:51
a way of engaging with ideas of community,
250
639251
3658
10:54
collective behavior, cooperation.
251
642909
3654
10:58
A lot of my work draws on the scientific research,
252
646563
2126
11:00
so this pays homage to the maze experiment
253
648689
3184
11:03
but in a different way.
254
651873
1582
11:05
And the slime mold is also my working material.
255
653455
2358
11:07
It's a coproducer of photographs, prints, animations,
256
655813
5217
11:13
participatory events.
257
661030
1599
11:14
Whilst the slime mold doesn't choose
258
662629
2348
11:16
to work with me, exactly,
259
664977
1906
11:18
it is a collaboration of sorts.
260
666883
2602
11:21
I can predict certain behaviors
261
669485
2092
11:23
by understanding how it operates,
262
671577
2056
11:25
but I can't control it.
263
673633
1730
11:27
The slime mold has the final say
264
675363
1584
11:28
in the creative process.
265
676947
2131
11:31
And after all, it has its own internal aesthetics.
266
679078
3489
11:34
These branching patterns that we see
267
682567
1804
11:36
we see across all forms, scales of nature,
268
684371
2550
11:38
from river deltas to lightning strikes,
269
686921
2800
11:41
from our own blood vessels to neural networks.
270
689721
4036
11:45
There's clearly significant rules at play
271
693757
2463
11:48
in this simple yet complex organism,
272
696220
2265
11:50
and no matter what our disciplinary
perspective or our mode of inquiry,
perspective or our mode of inquiry,
273
698485
3792
11:54
there's a great deal that we can learn
274
702277
1783
11:56
from observing and engaging
275
704060
1769
11:57
with this beautiful, brainless blob.
276
705829
3121
12:00
I give you Physarum polycephalum.
277
708950
3215
12:04
Thank you.
278
712165
1753
12:05
(Applause)
279
713918
962
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Heather Barnett - ArtistHeather Barnett creates art with slime mold -- a material used in diverse areas of scientific research, including biological computing, robotics and structural design.
Why you should listen
Heather Barnett creates fascinating biodesigns with the semi-intelligent slime mold. While it has no brain nor central nervous system, the single celled organism, Physarum polycephalum, shows a primitive form of memory, problem-solving skills and the apparent ability to make decisions. It is used as a model organism in diverse areas of scientific research, including biological computing, robotics and structural design. “It is also quite beautiful,” says Barnett, “and makes therefore for a great creative collaborator. Although ultimately I cannot control the final outcome, it is a rather independent organism.“
More profile about the speakerHeather Barnett | Speaker | TED.com