TEDGlobal 2013
Lesley Hazleton: The doubt essential to faith
Filmed:
Readability: 4.7
1,660,357 views
When Lesley Hazleton was writing a biography of Muhammad, she was struck by something: The night he received the revelation of the Koran, according to early accounts, his first reaction was doubt, awe, even fear. And yet this experience became the bedrock of his belief. Hazleton calls for a new appreciation of doubt and questioning as the foundation of faith -- and an end to fundamentalism of all kinds.
Lesley Hazleton - Writer, psychologist
Writer, psychologist and former Middle East reporter Lesley Hazleton explores the vast and often terrifying arena in which politics and religion intersect. Full bio
Writer, psychologist and former Middle East reporter Lesley Hazleton explores the vast and often terrifying arena in which politics and religion intersect. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
Writing biography is a strange thing to do.
0
496
5720
00:18
It's a journey into the foreign territory
1
6216
2683
00:20
of somebody else's life,
2
8899
3196
00:24
a journey, an exploration that can take you places
3
12095
2673
00:26
you never dreamed of going
4
14768
2271
00:29
and still can't quite believe you've been,
5
17039
2225
00:31
especially if, like me, you're an agnostic Jew
6
19264
3728
00:34
and the life you've been exploring
7
22992
1825
00:36
is that of Muhammad.
8
24817
4832
00:41
Five years ago, for instance,
9
29649
2431
00:44
I found myself waking each morning in misty Seattle
10
32080
3268
00:47
to what I knew was an impossible question:
11
35348
3483
00:50
What actually happened
12
38831
3218
00:54
one desert night,
13
42049
1439
00:55
half the world and almost half of history away?
14
43488
3594
00:59
What happened, that is,
15
47082
1720
01:00
on the night in the year 610
16
48802
2318
01:03
when Muhammad received the first revelation of the Koran
17
51120
3851
01:06
on a mountain just outside Mecca?
18
54971
4077
01:11
This is the core mystical moment of Islam,
19
59048
4605
01:15
and as such, of course,
20
63653
1366
01:17
it defies empirical analysis.
21
65019
3076
01:20
Yet the question wouldn't let go of me.
22
68095
4105
01:24
I was fully aware that for someone as secular as I am,
23
72200
3184
01:27
just asking it could be seen
24
75384
1879
01:29
as pure chutzpah.
25
77263
3260
01:32
(Laughter)
26
80523
2682
01:35
And I plead guilty as charged,
27
83205
2611
01:37
because all exploration, physical or intellectual,
28
85816
4031
01:41
is inevitably in some sense an act of transgression,
29
89847
3877
01:45
of crossing boundaries.
30
93724
3397
01:49
Still, some boundaries are larger than others.
31
97121
6015
01:55
So a human encountering the divine,
32
103136
2920
01:58
as Muslims believe Muhammad did,
33
106056
3122
02:01
to the rationalist, this is a matter not of fact
34
109178
2841
02:04
but of wishful fiction,
35
112019
1757
02:05
and like all of us, I like to think of myself as rational.
36
113776
3938
02:09
Which might be why when I looked at the earliest accounts
37
117714
2884
02:12
we have of that night,
38
120598
1777
02:14
what struck me even more than what happened
39
122375
2819
02:17
was what did not happen.
40
125194
5522
02:22
Muhammad did not come floating off the mountain
41
130716
3152
02:25
as though walking on air.
42
133868
2950
02:28
He did not run down shouting, "Hallelujah!"
43
136818
2474
02:31
and "Bless the Lord!"
44
139292
2360
02:33
He did not radiate light and joy.
45
141652
3728
02:37
There were no choirs of angels,
46
145380
1579
02:38
no music of the spheres, no elation, no ecstasy,
47
146959
3300
02:42
no golden aura surrounding him,
48
150259
3662
02:45
no sense of an absolute, fore-ordained role
49
153921
4142
02:50
as the messenger of God.
50
158063
3076
02:53
That is, he did none of the things
51
161139
2955
02:56
that might make it easy to cry foul,
52
164094
2754
02:58
to put down the whole story as a pious fable.
53
166848
5147
03:03
Quite the contrary.
54
171995
2832
03:06
In his own reported words,
55
174827
3745
03:10
he was convinced at first
56
178572
2377
03:12
that what had happened couldn't have been real.
57
180949
5281
03:18
At best, he thought, it had to have been a hallucination --
58
186230
2712
03:20
a trick of the eye or the ear, perhaps,
59
188942
1809
03:22
or his own mind working against him.
60
190751
2175
03:24
At worst, possession --
61
192926
2177
03:27
that he'd been seized by an evil jinn,
62
195103
2289
03:29
a spirit out to deceive him,
63
197392
1791
03:31
even to crush the life out of him.
64
199183
3009
03:34
In fact, he was so sure that he could only be majnun,
65
202192
3024
03:37
possessed by a jinn,
66
205216
1628
03:38
that when he found himself still alive,
67
206844
2112
03:40
his first impulse was to finish the job himself,
68
208956
4849
03:45
to leap off the highest cliff
69
213805
2203
03:48
and escape the terror of what he'd experienced
70
216008
4118
03:52
by putting an end to all experience.
71
220126
7102
03:59
So the man who fled down the mountain that night
72
227228
2920
04:02
trembled not with joy
73
230148
2451
04:04
but with a stark, primordial fear.
74
232599
4720
04:09
He was overwhelmed not with conviction, but by doubt.
75
237319
5920
04:15
And that panicked disorientation,
76
243239
2801
04:18
that sundering of everything familiar,
77
246040
2879
04:20
that daunting awareness of something
78
248919
3668
04:24
beyond human comprehension,
79
252603
2909
04:27
can only be called a terrible awe.
80
255512
6575
04:34
This might be somewhat difficult to grasp
81
262087
3214
04:37
now that we use the word "awesome"
82
265301
2538
04:39
to describe a new app or a viral video.
83
267839
4179
04:44
With the exception perhaps of a massive earthquake,
84
272018
3205
04:47
we're protected from real awe.
85
275223
2648
04:49
We close the doors and hunker down,
86
277871
1888
04:51
convinced that we're in control,
87
279759
2546
04:54
or, at least, hoping for control.
88
282305
3022
04:57
We do our best to ignore the fact that
89
285327
1908
04:59
we don't always have it,
90
287235
2061
05:01
and that not everything can be explained.
91
289296
2757
05:04
Yet whether you're a rationalist or a mystic,
92
292053
4162
05:08
whether you think the words Muhammad heard that night
93
296215
2695
05:10
came from inside himself or from outside,
94
298910
4264
05:15
what's clear is that he did experience them,
95
303174
4704
05:19
and that he did so with a force that would shatter
96
307878
2436
05:22
his sense of himself and his world
97
310314
2321
05:24
and transform this otherwise modest man
98
312635
3140
05:27
into a radical advocate for social and economic justice.
99
315775
6693
05:34
Fear was the only sane response,
100
322468
5242
05:39
the only human response.
101
327710
5024
05:44
Too human for some,
102
332734
2508
05:47
like conservative Muslim theologians who maintain that
103
335242
2733
05:49
the account of his wanting to kill himself
104
337975
1867
05:51
shouldn't even be mentioned, despite the fact
105
339842
2438
05:54
that it's in the earliest Islamic biographies.
106
342280
4454
05:58
They insist that he never doubted
107
346734
2791
06:01
for even a single moment, let alone despaired.
108
349525
6610
06:08
Demanding perfection, they refuse to tolerate
109
356135
3837
06:11
human imperfection.
110
359972
4719
06:16
Yet what, exactly, is imperfect about doubt?
111
364691
7195
06:23
As I read those early accounts, I realized it was
112
371886
2974
06:26
precisely Muhammad's doubt that brought him alive for me,
113
374860
3810
06:30
that allowed me to begin to see him in full,
114
378670
2397
06:33
to accord him the integrity of reality.
115
381067
3586
06:36
And the more I thought about it,
116
384653
2169
06:38
the more it made sense that he doubted,
117
386822
3017
06:41
because doubt is essential to faith.
118
389839
6583
06:48
If this seems a startling idea at first,
119
396422
2880
06:51
consider that doubt, as Graham Greene once put it,
120
399302
3661
06:54
is the heart of the matter.
121
402963
3835
06:58
Abolish all doubt, and what's left is not faith,
122
406798
4405
07:03
but absolute, heartless conviction.
123
411203
5243
07:08
You're certain that you possess the Truth --
124
416446
3871
07:12
inevitably offered with an implied uppercase T --
125
420317
4291
07:16
and this certainty quickly devolves
126
424608
2558
07:19
into dogmatism and righteousness,
127
427166
3512
07:22
by which I mean a demonstrative, overweening pride
128
430678
4103
07:26
in being so very right,
129
434781
3788
07:30
in short, the arrogance of fundamentalism.
130
438569
7888
07:38
It has to be one of the multiple ironies of history
131
446457
4476
07:42
that a favorite expletive of Muslim fundamentalists
132
450933
3058
07:45
is the same one once used by the Christian fundamentalists
133
453991
3191
07:49
known as Crusaders:
134
457182
2812
07:51
"infidel," from the Latin for "faithless."
135
459994
5225
07:57
Doubly ironic, in this case, because their absolutism
136
465219
4339
08:01
is in fact the opposite of faith.
137
469558
4465
08:06
In effect, they are the infidels.
138
474023
5959
08:11
Like fundamentalists of all religious stripes,
139
479982
2827
08:14
they have no questions, only answers.
140
482809
3845
08:18
They found the perfect antidote to thought
141
486654
2792
08:21
and the ideal refuge of the hard demands of real faith.
142
489446
3771
08:25
They don't have to struggle for it like Jacob
143
493217
1949
08:27
wrestling through the night with the angel,
144
495166
2050
08:29
or like Jesus in his 40 days and nights in the wilderness,
145
497216
3158
08:32
or like Muhammad, not only that night on the mountain,
146
500374
3202
08:35
but throughout his years as a prophet,
147
503576
2494
08:38
with the Koran constantly urging him not to despair,
148
506070
4184
08:42
and condemning those who most loudly proclaim
149
510254
3288
08:45
that they know everything there is to know
150
513542
3797
08:49
and that they and they alone are right.
151
517339
6894
08:56
And yet we, the vast and still far too silent majority,
152
524233
7413
09:03
have ceded the public arena to this extremist minority.
153
531646
5769
09:09
We've allowed Judaism to be claimed
154
537415
2493
09:11
by violently messianic West Bank settlers,
155
539908
3871
09:15
Christianity by homophobic hypocrites
156
543779
2947
09:18
and misogynistic bigots,
157
546726
2520
09:21
Islam by suicide bombers.
158
549246
4959
09:26
And we've allowed ourselves to be blinded to the fact that
159
554205
2771
09:28
no matter whether they claim to be Christians,
160
556976
2192
09:31
Jews or Muslims,
161
559168
1615
09:32
militant extremists are none of the above.
162
560783
5655
09:38
They're a cult all their own, blood brothers
163
566438
5614
09:44
steeped in other people's blood.
164
572052
5494
09:49
This isn't faith.
165
577546
2202
09:51
It's fanaticism, and we have to stop confusing the two.
166
579748
5162
09:56
We have to recognize that real faith has no easy answers.
167
584910
5022
10:01
It's difficult and stubborn.
168
589932
4078
10:06
It involves an ongoing struggle,
169
594010
2238
10:08
a continual questioning of what we think we know,
170
596248
3054
10:11
a wrestling with issues and ideas.
171
599302
2565
10:13
It goes hand in hand with doubt,
172
601867
3300
10:17
in a never-ending conversation with it,
173
605167
3077
10:20
and sometimes in conscious defiance of it.
174
608244
6395
10:26
And this conscious defiance is why I, as an agnostic,
175
614639
5048
10:31
can still have faith.
176
619687
4141
10:35
I have faith, for instance, that peace in the Middle East
177
623828
2988
10:38
is possible despite the ever-accumulating mass of evidence
178
626816
4310
10:43
to the contrary.
179
631126
3161
10:46
I'm not convinced of this.
180
634287
2372
10:48
I can hardly say I believe it.
181
636659
2124
10:50
I can only have faith in it,
182
638783
1942
10:52
commit myself, that is, to the idea of it,
183
640725
4018
10:56
and I do this precisely because of the temptation
184
644743
3001
10:59
to throw up my hands in resignation
185
647744
2000
11:01
and retreat into silence.
186
649744
3521
11:05
Because despair is self-fulfilling.
187
653265
4681
11:09
If we call something impossible,
188
657946
2320
11:12
we act in such a way that we make it so.
189
660266
3768
11:16
And I, for one, refuse to live that way.
190
664034
5933
11:21
In fact, most of us do,
191
669967
2299
11:24
whether we're atheist or theist
192
672266
3576
11:27
or anywhere in between or beyond, for that matter,
193
675842
3940
11:31
what drives us is that, despite our doubts
194
679782
4316
11:36
and even because of our doubts,
195
684098
2328
11:38
we reject the nihilism of despair.
196
686426
4472
11:42
We insist on faith in the future
197
690898
3233
11:46
and in each other.
198
694131
4738
11:50
Call this naive if you like.
199
698869
3501
11:54
Call it impossibly idealistic if you must.
200
702370
3097
11:57
But one thing is sure:
201
705467
2428
11:59
Call it human.
202
707895
3466
12:03
Could Muhammad have so radically changed his world
203
711361
3035
12:06
without such faith, without the refusal
204
714396
2852
12:09
to cede to the arrogance of closed-minded certainty?
205
717248
4716
12:13
I think not.
206
721964
3266
12:17
After keeping company with him as a writer
207
725230
2043
12:19
for the past five years, I can't see
208
727273
3300
12:22
that he'd be anything but utterly outraged
209
730573
5103
12:27
at the militant fundamentalists who claim to speak
210
735676
3147
12:30
and act in his name in the Middle East and elsewhere today.
211
738823
5469
12:36
He'd be appalled at the repression of half the population
212
744292
4290
12:40
because of their gender.
213
748582
2998
12:43
He'd be torn apart by the bitter divisiveness of sectarianism.
214
751580
7981
12:51
He'd call out terrorism for what it is,
215
759561
2706
12:54
not only criminal but an obscene travesty
216
762267
4744
12:59
of everything he believed in and struggled for.
217
767011
4905
13:03
He'd say what the Koran says: Anyone who takes a life
218
771916
5269
13:09
takes the life of all humanity.
219
777185
3201
13:12
Anyone who saves a life, saves the life of all humanity.
220
780386
7196
13:19
And he'd commit himself fully
221
787582
3070
13:22
to the hard and thorny process of making peace.
222
790652
7020
13:29
Thank you.
223
797672
1435
13:31
(Applause)
224
799107
4399
13:35
Thank you. (Applause)
225
803506
4000
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Lesley Hazleton - Writer, psychologistWriter, psychologist and former Middle East reporter Lesley Hazleton explores the vast and often terrifying arena in which politics and religion intersect.
Why you should listen
Lesley Hazleton has traced the roots of conflict in several books, including compelling 'flesh-and-blood' biographies of Muhammad and Mary, and casts "an agnostic eye on politics, religion, and existence" on her blog, AccidentalTheologist.com.
Her newest book, Agnostic: A Spirited Manifesto, celebrates the agnostic stance as "rising above the flat two-dimensional line of belief/unbelief, creating new possibilities for how we think about being in the world." In it, she explores what we mean by the search for meaning, invokes the humbling perspective of infinity and reconsiders what we talk about when we talk about soul.
Hazleton's approach has been praised as "vital and mischievous" by the New York Times, and as "a positive orientation to life, one that embraces both science and mystery ... while remaining intimately grounded and engaged."
Lesley Hazleton | Speaker | TED.com