TEDxCHUV
Daphne Bavelier: Your brain on video games
Filmed:
Readability: 3.8
7,326,863 views
How do fast-paced video games affect the brain? Step into the lab with cognitive researcher Daphne Bavelier to hear surprising news about how video games, even action-packed shooter games, can help us learn, focus and, fascinatingly, multitask.
Daphne Bavelier - Cognitive researcher
Daphne Bavelier studies how the brain adapts to changes in experience, either by nature or by training. Full bio
Daphne Bavelier studies how the brain adapts to changes in experience, either by nature or by training. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:16
I'm a brain scientist, and as a brain scientist,
0
578
3097
00:19
I'm actually interested in how the brain learns,
1
3675
3072
00:22
and I'm especially interested in a possibility of
2
6747
3367
00:26
making our brains smarter, better and faster.
3
10114
4732
00:30
This is in this context I'm going to tell you
4
14846
2876
00:33
about video games. When we say video games,
5
17722
2750
00:36
most of you think about children.
6
20472
2538
00:38
It's true. Ninety percent of children do play video games.
7
23010
3978
00:42
But let's be frank.
8
26988
2918
00:45
When the kids are in bed, who is in front of the PlayStation?
9
29906
4789
00:50
Most of you. The average age of a gamer is 33 years old,
10
34695
6484
00:57
not eight years old, and in fact, if we look
11
41179
3007
01:00
at the projected demographics of video game play,
12
44186
3709
01:03
the video game players of tomorrow are
13
47895
2733
01:06
older adults. (Laughter)
14
50628
3124
01:09
So video [gaming] is pervasive throughout our society.
15
53752
4251
01:13
It is clearly here to stay. It has an amazing impact
16
58003
4383
01:18
on our everyday life. Consider these statistics
17
62386
3387
01:21
released by Activision. After one month of release
18
65773
5815
01:27
of the game "Call Of Duty: Black Ops," it had been played
19
71588
4492
01:31
for 68,000 years
20
76080
3373
01:35
worldwide, right?
21
79453
1866
01:37
Would any of you complain if this was the case
22
81319
2947
01:40
about doing linear algebra?
23
84266
3163
01:43
So what we are asking in the lab is, how can we leverage that power?
24
87429
4295
01:47
Now I want to step back a bit.
25
91724
1848
01:49
I know most of you have had the experience of coming back
26
93572
3241
01:52
home and finding your kids playing these kinds of games.
27
96813
4720
01:57
(Shooting noises) The name of the game is to get
28
101533
2140
01:59
after your enemy zombie bad guys
29
103673
2964
02:02
before they get to you, right?
30
106637
3590
02:06
And I'm almost sure most of you have thought,
31
110227
3177
02:09
"Oh, come on, can't you do something more intelligent
32
113404
3321
02:12
than shooting at zombies?"
33
116725
3327
02:15
I'd like you to put this kind of knee-jerk reaction
34
120052
3466
02:19
in the context of what you would have thought
35
123518
2497
02:21
if you had found your girl playing sudoku
36
126015
3509
02:25
or your boy reading Shakespeare. Right?
37
129524
4351
02:29
Most parents would find that great.
38
133875
2737
02:32
Well, I'm not going to tell you that playing video games
39
136612
3344
02:35
days in and days out is actually good for your health.
40
139956
2968
02:38
It's not, and binging is never good.
41
142924
3200
02:42
But I'm going to argue that in reasonable doses,
42
146124
3991
02:46
actually the very game I showed you at the beginning,
43
150115
2969
02:48
those action-packed shooter games
44
153084
2584
02:51
have quite powerful effects and positive effects
45
155668
3776
02:55
on many different aspects of our behavior.
46
159444
3858
02:59
There's not one week that goes without some major
47
163302
3695
03:02
headlines in the media about whether video games are
48
166997
2776
03:05
good or bad for you, right? You're all bombarded with that.
49
169773
4616
03:10
I'd like to put this kind of Friday night bar discussion aside
50
174389
5688
03:15
and get you to actually step into the lab.
51
180077
3143
03:19
What we do in the lab is actually measure directly,
52
183220
2873
03:21
in a quantitative fashion, what is the impact
53
186093
2767
03:24
of video games on the brain.
54
188860
2769
03:27
And so I'm going to take a few examples from our work.
55
191629
3335
03:30
One first saying that I'm sure you all have heard
56
194964
2599
03:33
is the fact that too much screen time
57
197563
2286
03:35
makes your eyesight worse.
58
199849
2815
03:38
That's a statement about vision.
59
202664
2203
03:40
There may be vision scientists among you.
60
204867
2536
03:43
We actually know how to test that statement.
61
207403
2939
03:46
We can step into the lab and measure how good your vision is.
62
210342
3437
03:49
Well, guess what? People that don't play a lot
63
213779
3681
03:53
of action games, that don't actually spend a lot of time
64
217460
2990
03:56
in front of screens, have normal, or what we call
65
220450
3532
03:59
corrective-to-normal vision. That's okay.
66
223982
2654
04:02
The issue is what happens with these guys that actually
67
226636
2449
04:04
indulge into playing video games like five hours per week,
68
229085
3280
04:08
10 hours per week, 15 hours per week.
69
232365
1875
04:10
By that statement, their vision should be really bad, right?
70
234240
3228
04:13
Guess what? Their vision is really, really good.
71
237468
2697
04:16
It's better than those that don't play.
72
240165
2440
04:18
And it's better in two different ways.
73
242605
2272
04:20
The first way is that they're actually able to resolve
74
244877
2425
04:23
small detail in the context of clutter, and though that means
75
247302
3255
04:26
being able to read the fine print on a prescription
76
250557
3798
04:30
rather than using magnifier glasses, you can actually do it
77
254355
4627
04:34
with just your eyesight.
78
258982
1566
04:36
The other way that they are better is actually being able
79
260548
2816
04:39
to resolve different levels of gray.
80
263364
2909
04:42
Imagine you're driving in a fog. That makes a difference
81
266273
3171
04:45
between seeing the car in front of you
82
269444
2481
04:47
and avoiding the accident, or getting into an accident.
83
271925
3743
04:51
So we're actually leveraging that work to develop games
84
275668
3016
04:54
for patients with low vision, and to have an impact
85
278684
4474
04:59
on retraining their brain to see better.
86
283158
3335
05:02
Clearly, when it comes to action video games,
87
286493
3649
05:06
screen time doesn't make your eyesight worse.
88
290142
2895
05:08
Another saying that I'm sure you have all heard around:
89
293037
3986
05:12
Video games lead to attention problems and greater distractability.
90
297023
4374
05:17
Okay, we know how to measure attention in the lab.
91
301397
3905
05:21
I'm actually going to give you an example of how we do so.
92
305302
3601
05:24
I'm going to ask you to participate, so you're going to have
93
308903
2725
05:27
to actually play the game with me. I'm going to show you
94
311628
3024
05:30
colored words. I want you to shout out the color of the ink.
95
314652
5433
05:35
Right? So this is the first example.
96
320085
3383
05:39
["Chair"]
97
323468
1090
05:40
Orange, good. ["Table"] Green.
98
324558
3061
05:43
["Board"] Audience: Red.Daphne Bavelier: Red.
99
327619
1380
05:44
["Horse"] DB: Yellow. Audience: Yellow.
100
328999
1294
05:46
["Yellow"] DB: Red. Audience: Yellow.
101
330293
1325
05:47
["Blue"] DB: Yellow.
102
331618
1509
05:49
Okay, you get my point, right? (Laughter)
103
333127
6355
05:55
You're getting better, but it's hard. Why is it hard?
104
339482
3336
05:58
Because I introduced a conflict between
105
342818
3954
06:02
the word itself and its color.
106
346772
2913
06:05
How good your attention is determines actually how fast
107
349685
3039
06:08
you resolve that conflict, so the young guys here
108
352724
2527
06:11
at the top of their game probably, like, did a little better
109
355251
2561
06:13
than some of us that are older.
110
357812
2544
06:16
What we can show is that when you do this kind of task
111
360356
2568
06:18
with people that play a lot of action games,
112
362924
1600
06:20
they actually resolve the conflict faster.
113
364524
3320
06:23
So clearly playing those action games doesn't lead
114
367844
3208
06:26
to attention problems.
115
371052
2483
06:29
Actually, those action video game players have
116
373535
1971
06:31
many other advantages in terms of attention, and one
117
375506
2317
06:33
aspect of attention which is also improved for the better
118
377823
2899
06:36
is our ability to track objects around in the world.
119
380722
4778
06:41
This is something we use all the time. When you're driving,
120
385500
2544
06:43
you're tracking, keeping track of the cars around you.
121
388044
3248
06:47
You're also keeping track of the pedestrian, the running dog,
122
391292
3075
06:50
and that's how you can actually be safe driving, right?
123
394367
3053
06:53
In the lab, we get people to come to the lab,
124
397420
3064
06:56
sit in front of a computer screen, and we give them
125
400484
2080
06:58
little tasks that I'm going to get you to do again.
126
402564
2896
07:01
You're going to see yellow happy faces
127
405460
2952
07:04
and a few sad blue faces. These are children
128
408412
3816
07:08
in the schoolyard in Geneva during a recess
129
412228
3820
07:11
during the winter. Most kids are happy. It's actually recess.
130
416048
4301
07:16
But a few kids are sad and blue because they've forgotten their coat.
131
420349
3127
07:19
Everybody begins to move around, and your task
132
423476
3320
07:22
is to keep track of who had a coat at the beginning
133
426796
3124
07:25
and who didn't. So I'm just going to show you an example
134
429920
2491
07:28
where there is only one sad kid. It's easy because you can
135
432411
2829
07:31
actually track it with your eyes. You can track,
136
435240
2337
07:33
you can track, and then when it stops, and there is
137
437577
2280
07:35
a question mark, and I ask you, did this kid have a coat or not?
138
439857
3931
07:39
Was it yellow initially or blue?
139
443788
2828
07:42
I hear a few yellow. Good. So most of you have a brain. (Laughter)
140
446616
3797
07:46
I'm now going to ask you to do the task, but now with
141
450413
4796
07:51
a little more challenging task. There are going to be
142
455209
2088
07:53
three of them that are blue. Don't move your eyes.
143
457297
3183
07:56
Please don't move your eyes. Keep your eyes fixated
144
460480
2253
07:58
and expand, pull your attention. That's the only way
145
462733
2646
08:01
you can actually do it. If you move your eyes, you're doomed.
146
465379
2848
08:04
Yellow or blue?
147
468227
1463
08:05
Audience: Yellow.DB: Good.
148
469690
1646
08:07
So your typical normal young adult
149
471336
2503
08:09
can have a span of about three or four objects of attention.
150
473839
3636
08:13
That's what we just did. Your action video game player
151
477475
2760
08:16
has a span of about six to seven objects of attention,
152
480235
3200
08:19
which is what is shown in this video here.
153
483435
2978
08:22
That's for you guys, action video game players.
154
486413
3476
08:25
A bit more challenging, right? (Laughter)
155
489889
1885
08:27
Yellow or blue? Blue. We have some people
156
491774
3708
08:31
that are serious out there. Yeah. (Laughter)
157
495482
3204
08:34
Good. So in the same way that we actually see
158
498686
3604
08:38
the effects of video games on people's behavior,
159
502290
3478
08:41
we can use brain imaging and look at the impact
160
505768
3065
08:44
of video games on the brain, and we do find many changes,
161
508833
3785
08:48
but the main changes are actually to the brain networks
162
512618
3360
08:51
that control attention. So one part is the parietal cortex
163
515978
4544
08:56
which is very well known to control the orientation of attention.
164
520522
3719
09:00
The other one is the frontal lobe, which controls
165
524241
2433
09:02
how we sustain attention, and another one
166
526674
2710
09:05
is the anterior cingulate, which controls how we allocate
167
529384
2569
09:07
and regulate attention and resolve conflict.
168
531953
3297
09:11
Now, when we do brain imaging, we find that all three
169
535250
2864
09:14
of these networks are actually much more efficient
170
538114
3344
09:17
in people that play action games.
171
541458
2760
09:20
This actually leads me to a rather counterintuitive finding
172
544218
4751
09:24
in the literature about technology and the brain.
173
548969
3441
09:28
You all know about multitasking. You all have been faulty
174
552410
4449
09:32
of multitasking when you're driving
175
556859
2210
09:34
and you pick up your cellphone. Bad idea. Very bad idea.
176
559069
4691
09:39
Why? Because as your attention shifts to your cell phone,
177
563760
3903
09:43
you are actually losing the capacity to react swiftly
178
567663
4148
09:47
to the car braking in front of you, and so you're
179
571811
2448
09:50
much more likely to get engaged into a car accident.
180
574259
5571
09:55
Now, we can measure that kind of skills in the lab.
181
579830
2876
09:58
We obviously don't ask people to drive around and see
182
582706
2472
10:01
how many car accidents they have. That would be a little
183
585178
2345
10:03
costly proposition. But we design tasks on the computer
184
587523
3547
10:06
where we can measure, to millisecond accuracy,
185
591070
3118
10:10
how good they are at switching from one task to another.
186
594188
4528
10:14
When we do that, we actually find that people
187
598716
2568
10:17
that play a lot of action games are really, really good.
188
601284
3084
10:20
They switch really fast, very swiftly. They pay a very small cost.
189
604368
4483
10:24
Now I'd like you to remember that result, and put it
190
608851
2658
10:27
in the context of another group of technology users,
191
611509
3732
10:31
a group which is actually much revered by society,
192
615241
2410
10:33
which are people that engage in multimedia-tasking.
193
617651
4539
10:38
What is multimedia-tasking? It's the fact that most of us,
194
622190
3645
10:41
most of our children, are engaged with listening to music
195
625835
3281
10:45
at the same time as they're doing search on the web
196
629116
2747
10:47
at the same time as they're chatting on Facebook with their friends.
197
631863
3357
10:51
That's a multimedia-tasker.
198
635220
2336
10:53
There was a first study done by colleagues at Stanford
199
637556
3560
10:57
and that we replicated that showed that
200
641116
2553
10:59
those people that identify as being high multimedia-taskers
201
643669
4647
11:04
are absolutely abysmal at multitasking.
202
648316
3847
11:08
When we measure them in the lab, they're really bad.
203
652163
2737
11:10
Right? So these kinds of results really
204
654900
2706
11:13
makes two main points.
205
657606
2486
11:15
The first one is that not all media are created equal.
206
660092
3192
11:19
You can't compare the effect of multimedia-tasking
207
663284
4912
11:24
and the effect of playing action games. They have
208
668196
1646
11:25
totally different effects on different aspects of cognition,
209
669842
3392
11:29
perception and attention.
210
673234
3114
11:32
Even within video games, I'm telling you right now
211
676348
2840
11:35
about these action-packed video games.
212
679188
1753
11:36
Different video games have a different effect on your brains.
213
680941
3334
11:40
So we actually need to step into the lab and really measure
214
684275
2682
11:42
what is the effect of each video game.
215
686957
2511
11:45
The other lesson is that general wisdom carries no weight.
216
689468
4287
11:49
I showed that to you already, like we looked at the fact that
217
693755
3056
11:52
despite a lot of screen time, those action gamers
218
696811
2448
11:55
have a lot of very good vision, etc.
219
699259
4008
11:59
Here, what was really striking is that these undergraduates
220
703267
3318
12:02
that actually report engaging in a lot of high
221
706585
3241
12:05
multimedia-tasking are convinced they aced the test.
222
709826
4977
12:10
So you show them their data, you show them they are bad
223
714803
2290
12:12
and they're like, "Not possible." You know, they have
224
717093
2686
12:15
this sort of gut feeling that, really, they are doing really, really good.
225
719779
3856
12:19
That's another argument for why we need to step into the lab
226
723635
2945
12:22
and really measure the impact of technology on the brain.
227
726580
3592
12:26
Now in a sense, when we think about the effect
228
730172
4583
12:30
of video games on the brain, it's very similar
229
734755
2480
12:33
to the effect of wine on the health.
230
737235
3864
12:36
There are some very poor uses of wine. There are some
231
741099
3040
12:40
very poor uses of video games. But when consumed
232
744139
4216
12:44
in reasonable doses, and at the right age,
233
748355
3481
12:47
wine can be very good for health. There are actually
234
751836
3271
12:51
specific molecules that have been identified
235
755107
3264
12:54
in red wine as leading to greater life expectancy.
236
758371
5832
13:00
So it's the same way, like those action video games
237
764203
3272
13:03
have a number of ingredients that are actually really
238
767475
1662
13:05
powerful for brain plasticity, learning, attention,
239
769137
3970
13:09
vision, etc., and so we need and we're working on
240
773107
3605
13:12
understanding what are those active ingredients so that
241
776712
2755
13:15
we can really then leverage them to deliver better games,
242
779467
3890
13:19
either for education or for rehabilitation of patients.
243
783357
4243
13:23
Now because we are interested in having an impact
244
787600
3779
13:27
for education or rehabilitation of patients, we are actually
245
791379
2488
13:29
not that interested in how those of you that choose
246
793867
3416
13:33
to play video games for many hours on end perform.
247
797283
3872
13:37
I'm much more interested in taking any of you
248
801155
3825
13:40
and showing that by forcing you to play an action game,
249
804980
3780
13:44
I can actually change your vision for the better,
250
808760
2863
13:47
whether you want to play that action game or not, right?
251
811623
2331
13:49
That's the point of rehabilitation or education.
252
813954
2416
13:52
Most of the kids don't go to school saying,
253
816370
1926
13:54
"Great, two hours of math!"
254
818296
2740
13:56
So that's really the crux of the research, and to do that,
255
821036
4439
14:01
we need to go one more step.
256
825475
2464
14:03
And one more step is to do training studies.
257
827939
3024
14:06
So let me illustrate that step with
258
830963
3400
14:10
a task which is called mental rotation.
259
834363
3568
14:13
Mental rotation is a task where I'm going to ask you,
260
837931
4175
14:18
and again you're going to do the task,
261
842106
1885
14:19
to look at this shape. Study it, it's a target shape,
262
843991
3685
14:23
and I'm going to present to you four different shapes.
263
847676
3254
14:26
One of these four different shapes is actually a rotated
264
850930
2840
14:29
version of this shape. I want you to tell me which one:
265
853770
4304
14:33
the first one, second one, third one or fourth one?
266
858074
4841
14:38
Okay, I'll help you. Fourth one.
267
862915
2417
14:41
One more. Get those brains working. Come on.
268
865332
4530
14:45
That's our target shape.
269
869862
4974
14:50
Third. Good! This is hard, right?
270
874836
3703
14:54
Like, the reason that I asked you to do that is because
271
878539
1487
14:55
you really feel your brain cringing, right?
272
880026
2734
14:58
It doesn't really feel like playing mindless action video games.
273
882760
3432
15:02
Well, what we do in these training studies is, people
274
886192
2705
15:04
come to the lab, they do tasks like this one,
275
888897
2609
15:07
we then force them to play 10 hours of action games.
276
891506
4330
15:11
They don't play 10 hours of action games in a row.
277
895836
2746
15:14
They do distributed practice, so little shots of 40 minutes
278
898582
3110
15:17
several days over a period of two weeks.
279
901692
4301
15:21
Then, once they are done with the training, they come back
280
905993
1796
15:23
a few days later and they are tested again on a similar type
281
907789
3973
15:27
of mental rotation task. So this is work from a colleague
282
911762
3616
15:31
in Toronto. What they showed is that, initially,
283
915378
2535
15:33
you know, subjects perform where they are expected
284
917913
2198
15:36
to perform given their age. After two weeks of training
285
920111
5210
15:41
on action video games, they actually perform better,
286
925321
3856
15:45
and the improvement is still there five months after
287
929177
5356
15:50
having done the training. That's really, really important.
288
934533
2868
15:53
Why? Because I told you we want to use these games
289
937401
2480
15:55
for education or for rehabilitation. We need to have effects
290
939881
3200
15:58
that are going to be long-lasting.
291
943081
2936
16:01
Now, at this point, a number of you are probably wondering
292
946017
2853
16:04
well, what are you waiting for, to put on the market
293
948870
3633
16:08
a game that would be good for the attention
294
952503
2552
16:10
of my grandmother and that she would actually enjoy,
295
955055
3520
16:14
or a game that would be great to rehabilitate the vision
296
958575
2583
16:17
of my grandson who has amblyopia, for example?
297
961158
3809
16:20
Well, we're working on it, but here is a challenge.
298
964967
4480
16:25
There are brain scientists like me that are beginning
299
969447
1911
16:27
to understand what are the good ingredients in games
300
971358
3257
16:30
to promote positive effects, and that's what I'm going
301
974615
3105
16:33
to call the broccoli side of the equation.
302
977720
3574
16:37
There is an entertainment software industry
303
981294
3736
16:40
which is extremely deft at coming up with
304
985030
3472
16:44
appealing products that you can't resist.
305
988502
4144
16:48
That's the chocolate side of the equation.
306
992646
3528
16:52
The issue is we need to put the two together,
307
996174
3024
16:55
and it's a little bit like with food.
308
999198
2256
16:57
Who really wants to eat chocolate-covered broccoli?
309
1001454
3641
17:00
None of you. (Laughter) And you probably have had
310
1005095
2259
17:03
that feeling, right, picking up an education game
311
1007354
2332
17:05
and sort of feeling, hmm, you know, it's not really fun,
312
1009686
3392
17:08
it's not really engaging. So what we need
313
1013078
2417
17:11
is really a new brand of chocolate, a brand of chocolate
314
1015495
3351
17:14
that is irresistible, that you really want to play,
315
1018846
4011
17:18
but that has all the ingredients, the good ingredients
316
1022857
2985
17:21
that are extracted from the broccoli that you can't recognize
317
1025842
3228
17:24
but are still working on your brains. And we're working on it,
318
1029070
2839
17:27
but it takes brain scientists to come and to get together,
319
1031909
4476
17:32
people that work in the entertainment software industry,
320
1036385
2963
17:35
and publishers, so these are not people that usually
321
1039348
2738
17:37
meet every day, but it's actually doable,
322
1042086
2337
17:40
and we are on the right track.
323
1044423
2647
17:42
I'd like to leave you with that thought,
324
1047070
1782
17:44
and thank you for your attention. (Applause)
325
1048852
3367
17:48
(Applause)
326
1052219
4000
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Daphne Bavelier - Cognitive researcherDaphne Bavelier studies how the brain adapts to changes in experience, either by nature or by training.
Why you should listen
Daphne Bavelier studies how humans learn -- in particular, how the brain adapts to changes in experience, either by nature (for example, deafness) or by training (for example, playing video games). At her lab, her work shows that playing fast-paced, action-packed entertainment video games typically thought to be mind-numbing actually benefits several aspects of behavior. Exploiting this counterintuitive finding, her lab now investigates how new media, such as video games, can be leveraged to foster learning and brain plasticity.
Daphne Bavelier | Speaker | TED.com