TEDxABQ
Megan Kamerick: Women should represent women in media
Filmed:
Readability: 4.6
334,487 views
How do you tell women’s stories? Ask women to tell them. At TEDxABQ, Megan Kamerick shows how the news media underrepresents women as reporters and news sources, and because of that tells an incomplete story.
Megan Kamerick - Reporter
Journalist Megan Kamerick fights for well-balanced storytelling in media. Full bio
Journalist Megan Kamerick fights for well-balanced storytelling in media. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:16
Like most journalists, I'm an idealist.
0
1046
2774
00:19
I love unearthing good stories, especially untold stories.
1
3820
5262
00:24
I just didn't think that, in 2011,
2
9082
2501
00:27
women would still be in that category.
3
11583
2827
00:30
I'm the President of the Journalism & Women Symposium,
4
14410
3482
00:33
JAWS. That's Sharky. (Laughter)
5
17892
3216
00:37
I joined 10 years ago because I wanted female role models,
6
21108
2806
00:39
and I was frustrated by the lagging status of women
7
23914
3011
00:42
in our profession, and what that meant for our image
8
26925
2862
00:45
in the media.
9
29787
2299
00:47
We make up half the population of the world,
10
32086
2087
00:50
but we're just 24 percent of the news subjects
11
34173
2280
00:52
quoted in news stories,
12
36453
2151
00:54
and we're just 20 percent of the experts quoted in stories,
13
38604
3735
00:58
and now, with today's technology,
14
42339
2066
01:00
it's possible to remove women from the picture completely.
15
44405
3616
01:03
This is a picture of President Barack Obama
16
48021
3633
01:07
and his advisors tracking the killing of Osama bin Laden.
17
51654
2942
01:10
You can see Hillary Clinton on the right.
18
54596
2264
01:12
Let's see how the photo ran
19
56860
1336
01:14
in an Orthodox Jewish newspaper based in Brooklyn.
20
58196
3926
01:18
Hillary's completely gone. (Laughter)
21
62122
4361
01:22
The paper apologized but said
22
66483
1901
01:24
it never runs photos of women.
23
68384
1843
01:26
They might be sexually provocative. (Laughter)
24
70227
3839
01:29
This is an extreme case, yes, but the fact is,
25
74066
2807
01:32
women are only 19 percent of the sources
26
76873
2410
01:35
in stories on politics,
27
79283
2222
01:37
and only 20 percent in stories on the economy.
28
81505
3913
01:41
The news continues to give us a picture where men
29
85418
2561
01:43
outnumber women in nearly all occupational categories
30
87979
3149
01:47
except two: students and homemakers. (Laughter)
31
91128
4904
01:51
So we all get a very distorted picture of reality.
32
96032
3767
01:55
The problem is, of course,
33
99799
1836
01:57
there aren't enough women in newsrooms.
34
101635
1715
01:59
They reported just 37 percent of stories
35
103350
2378
02:01
in print, TV and radio.
36
105728
2352
02:03
Even in stories on gender-based violence,
37
108080
2633
02:06
men get an overwhelming majority of print space
38
110713
2670
02:09
and airtime.
39
113383
1214
02:10
Case in point,
40
114597
1952
02:12
this March, the New York Times ran a story
41
116549
2395
02:14
by James McKinley about a gang rape of a young girl,
42
118944
2392
02:17
11 years old, in a small Texas town.
43
121336
2909
02:20
McKinley writes that the community's wondering,
44
124245
2250
02:22
"How could their boys have been drawn into this?"
45
126495
4498
02:26
"Drawn into this," like they were
46
130993
1960
02:28
seduced into committing an act of violence.
47
132953
2821
02:31
And the first person he quotes says,
48
135774
1677
02:33
"These boys will have to live with this the rest of their lives."
49
137451
2823
02:36
(Crowd reacts)
50
140274
2854
02:39
You don't hear much about the 11-year-old victim,
51
143128
3285
02:42
except that she wore clothes that were a little old for her
52
146413
3295
02:45
and she wore makeup.
53
149708
2515
02:48
The Times was deluged with criticism.
54
152223
2954
02:51
Initially, it defended itself, and said, "These aren't our views.
55
155177
2775
02:53
This is what we found in our reporting."
56
157952
2433
02:56
Now, here's a secret you probably know already:
57
160385
3206
02:59
Your stories are constructed.
58
163591
1523
03:01
As reporters, we research, we interview.
59
165114
2495
03:03
We try to give a good picture of reality.
60
167609
3482
03:06
We also have our own unconscious biases,
61
171091
2590
03:09
but the Times makes it sound like
62
173681
1325
03:10
anyone would have reported this story the same way.
63
175006
4050
03:14
I disagree with that.
64
179056
1591
03:16
So three weeks later, the Times revisits the story.
65
180647
3763
03:20
This time, it adds another byline to it with McKinley's:
66
184410
3471
03:23
Erica Goode.
67
187881
1359
03:25
What emerges is a truly sad, horrific tale of a young girl
68
189240
3756
03:28
and her family trapped in poverty.
69
192996
2516
03:31
She was raped numerous times by many men.
70
195512
3257
03:34
She had been a bright, easygoing girl.
71
198769
2447
03:37
She was maturing quickly, physically,
72
201216
2314
03:39
but her bed was still covered with stuffed animals.
73
203530
3028
03:42
It's a very different picture.
74
206558
1626
03:44
Perhaps the addition of Ms. Goode
75
208184
1814
03:45
is what made this story more complete.
76
209998
2962
03:48
The Global Media Monitoring Project has found that
77
212960
2162
03:51
stories by female reporters are more likely
78
215122
2320
03:53
to challenge stereotypes than those by male reporters.
79
217442
2935
03:56
At KUNM here in Albuquerque, Elaine Baumgartel
80
220377
2560
03:58
did some graduate research on the coverage
81
222937
2008
04:00
of violence against women.
82
224945
1400
04:02
What she found was many of these stories
83
226345
2601
04:04
tend to blame victims and devalue their lives.
84
228946
2574
04:07
They tend to sensationalize, and they lack context.
85
231520
3618
04:11
So for her graduate work, she did a three-part series
86
235138
2609
04:13
on the murder of 11 women
87
237747
1814
04:15
found buried on Albuquerque's West Mesa.
88
239561
2350
04:17
She tried to challenge those patterns and stereotypes
89
241911
2272
04:20
in her work, and she tried to show the challenges
90
244183
2577
04:22
that journalists face, from external sources,
91
246760
3104
04:25
their own internal biases, and cultural norms,
92
249864
3739
04:29
and she worked with an editor at National Public Radio
93
253603
2515
04:32
to try to get a story aired nationally.
94
256118
2774
04:34
She's not sure that would have happened
95
258892
1942
04:36
if the editor had not been a female.
96
260834
2498
04:39
Stories in the news are more than twice as likely
97
263332
2337
04:41
to present women as victims than men,
98
265669
3118
04:44
and women are more likely to be defined
99
268787
2342
04:47
by their body parts.
100
271129
2241
04:49
Wired magazine, November 2010.
101
273370
2937
04:52
Yes, the issue was about breast tissue engineering.
102
276307
3712
04:55
Now, I know you're all distracted, so I'll take that off. (Laughter)
103
280019
4329
05:00
Eyes up here. (Laughter)
104
284348
4682
05:04
So -- (Applause)
105
289030
4336
05:09
Here's the thing.
106
293366
2080
05:11
Wired almost never puts women on its cover.
107
295446
3025
05:14
Oh, there have been some gimmicky ones.
108
298471
1512
05:15
Pam from The Office.
109
299983
1733
05:17
Manga girls.
110
301716
1755
05:19
A voluptuous model covered in synthetic diamonds.
111
303471
4015
05:23
Texas State University professor Cindy Royal wondered
112
307486
2768
05:26
in her blog, "How are young women like her students
113
310254
2450
05:28
supposed to feel about their roles in technology reading Wired?"
114
312704
3834
05:32
Chris Anderson, the editor of Wired, defended his choice
115
316538
3502
05:35
and said, there aren't enough women, prominent women
116
320040
2266
05:38
in technology to sell a cover, to sell an issue.
117
322306
4275
05:42
Part of that is true. There aren't as many
118
326581
1627
05:44
prominent women in technology.
119
328208
2187
05:46
Here's my problem with that argument.
120
330395
2256
05:48
Media tells us every day what's important,
121
332651
2839
05:51
by the stories they choose and where they place them.
122
335490
2266
05:53
It's called agenda-setting.
123
337756
2685
05:56
How many people knew the founders of Facebook
124
340441
1984
05:58
and Google before their faces were on a magazine cover?
125
342425
2959
06:01
Putting them there made them more recognizable.
126
345384
2653
06:03
Now, Fast Company Magazine embraces that idea.
127
348037
3084
06:07
This is its cover from November 15, 2010.
128
351121
3018
06:10
The issue is about the most prominent and influential women
129
354139
2724
06:12
in technology.
130
356863
1441
06:14
Editor Robert Safian told the Poynter Institute,
131
358304
3086
06:17
"Silicon Valley is very white and very male,
132
361390
2582
06:19
but that's not what Fast Company thinks the business world
133
363972
3065
06:22
will look like in the future, so it tries to give a picture
134
367037
2896
06:25
of where the globalized world is moving."
135
369933
3271
06:29
By the way, apparently Wired took all this to heart.
136
373204
2704
06:31
This was its issue in April. (Laughter)
137
375908
4026
06:35
That's Limor Fried, the founder of Adafruit Industries,
138
379934
2841
06:38
in the Rosie the Riveter pose.
139
382775
2607
06:41
It would help to have more women in positions of leadership
140
385382
2468
06:43
in the media. A recent global survey found that
141
387850
2911
06:46
73 percent of the top media management jobs
142
390761
2152
06:48
are still held by men.
143
392913
2104
06:50
But this is also about something far more complex:
144
395017
2833
06:53
our own unconscious biases and blind spots.
145
397850
3721
06:57
Shankar Vedantam is the author of "The Hidden Brain:
146
401571
2786
07:00
How Our Unconscious Minds Elect Presidents,
147
404357
2044
07:02
Control Markets, Wage Wars, and Save Our Lives."
148
406401
2686
07:04
He told the former ombudsman
149
409087
2664
07:07
at National Public Radio, who was doing
150
411751
1448
07:09
a report on how women fare in NPR coverage,
151
413199
3065
07:12
unconscious bias flows throughout most of our lives.
152
416264
3464
07:15
It's really difficult to disentangle those strands.
153
419728
2992
07:18
But he did have one suggestion.
154
422720
2479
07:21
He used to work for two editors who said
155
425199
3197
07:24
every story had to have at least one female source.
156
428396
3522
07:27
He balked, at first, but said he eventually
157
431918
2496
07:30
followed the directive happily because his stories got better
158
434414
3083
07:33
and his job got easier.
159
437497
2517
07:35
Now, I don't know if one of the editors was a woman,
160
440014
2516
07:38
but that can make the biggest differences.
161
442530
2507
07:40
The Dallas Morning News won a Pulitzer Prize in 1994
162
445037
3529
07:44
for a series it did on women around the world,
163
448566
2664
07:47
but one of the reporters told me she's convinced
164
451230
2808
07:49
it never would have happened if they had not had
165
454038
2280
07:52
a female assistant foreign editor,
166
456318
2760
07:54
and they would not have gotten some of those stories
167
459078
2280
07:57
without female reporters and editors on the ground,
168
461358
2858
08:00
particularly one on female genital mutilation.
169
464216
2911
08:03
Men would just not be allowed into those situations.
170
467127
2944
08:05
This is an important point to consider,
171
470071
2407
08:08
because much of our foreign policy now revolves around
172
472478
2495
08:10
countries where the treatment of women is an issue,
173
474973
2682
08:13
such as Afghanistan.
174
477655
4002
08:17
What we're told in terms of arguments against leaving
175
481657
2968
08:20
this country is that the fate of the women is primary.
176
484625
5212
08:25
Now I'm sure a male reporter in Kabul can find women
177
489837
2464
08:28
to interview. Not so sure about rural, traditional areas,
178
492301
4412
08:32
where I'm guessing women can't talk to strange men.
179
496713
4114
08:36
It's important to keep talking about this
180
500827
1612
08:38
in light of Lara Logan.
181
502439
2530
08:40
She was the CBS News correspondent who was
182
504969
2088
08:42
brutally sexually assaulted in Egypt's Tahrir Square
183
507057
2622
08:45
right after this photo was taken.
184
509679
2306
08:47
Almost immediately, pundits weighed in
185
511985
2331
08:50
blaming her and saying things like, "You know,
186
514316
3612
08:53
maybe women shouldn't be sent to cover those stories."
187
517928
3552
08:57
I never heard anyone say this about Anderson Cooper
188
521480
2641
09:00
and his crew who were attacked covering the same story.
189
524121
4042
09:04
One way to get more women into leadership
190
528163
2173
09:06
is to have other women mentor them.
191
530336
2304
09:08
One of my board members is an editor at a major
192
532640
2447
09:10
global media company, but she never thought about this
193
535087
2312
09:13
as a career path until she met female role models at JAWS.
194
537399
4927
09:18
But this is not just a job for super-journalists,
195
542326
2468
09:20
or my organization. You all have a stake in a strong,
196
544794
2779
09:23
vibrant media.
197
547573
2240
09:25
Analyze your news, and speak up when there are gaps
198
549813
3016
09:28
missing in coverage like people at the New York Times did.
199
552829
3201
09:31
Suggest female sources to reporters and editors.
200
556030
3216
09:35
Remember, a complete picture of reality
201
559246
2458
09:37
may depend upon it.
202
561704
1628
09:39
And I'll leave you with a video clip that I first saw in [1987]
203
563332
3526
09:42
when I was a student in London.
204
566858
2114
09:44
It's for the Guardian newspaper.
205
568972
1492
09:46
It's actually long before I ever thought about
206
570464
1525
09:47
becoming a journalist, but I was very interested
207
571989
2337
09:50
in how we learn to perceive our world.
208
574326
4159
09:54
Narrator: An event seen from one point of view
209
578485
2964
09:57
gives one impression.
210
581449
7130
10:04
Seen from another point of view,
211
588579
1656
10:06
it gives quite a different impression.
212
590235
4607
10:10
But it's only when you get the whole picture
213
594842
2862
10:13
you can fully understand what's going on.
214
597704
5746
10:19
"The Guardian"
215
603450
1912
10:21
Megan Kamerick: I think you'll all agree
216
605362
1266
10:22
that we'd be better off if we all had the whole picture.
217
606628
4429
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Megan Kamerick - ReporterJournalist Megan Kamerick fights for well-balanced storytelling in media.
Why you should listen
Megan Kamerick is passionate about getting women’s voices into media. A journalist for 20 years, she is the former president of the Journalism & Women Symposium, an organization dedicated to advancing the careers of women in journalism and to promoting a more accurate representation of society as a whole. She is currently the producer of "New Mexico in Focus," a weekly public affairs show on KNME/New Mexico PBS. She is also an independent producer for public radio station KUNM where she produces a newscast focused on news about women. Megan previously produced and hosted Public Square on New Mexico PBS, and she worked at business weeklies in San Antonio, New Orleans and Albuquerque. She has also freelanced for many publications and produced stories for Latino USA and National Public Radio.
More profile about the speakerMegan Kamerick | Speaker | TED.com