TED2014
Jennifer Senior: For parents, happiness is a very high bar
Filmed:
Readability: 3.9
2,370,134 views
The parenting section of the bookstore is overwhelming—it's "a giant, candy-colored monument to our collective panic," as writer Jennifer Senior puts it. Why is parenthood filled with so much anxiety? Because the goal of modern, middle-class parents—to raise happy children—is so elusive. In this honest talk, she offers some kinder and more achievable aims.
Jennifer Senior - Writer
In her new book "All Joy and No Fun," Jennifer Senior explores how children reshape their parents' lives -- for better and worse. Full bio
In her new book "All Joy and No Fun," Jennifer Senior explores how children reshape their parents' lives -- for better and worse. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
When I was born,
0
618
1438
00:14
there was really only one book
1
2056
1680
00:15
about how to raise your children,
2
3736
1886
00:17
and it was written by Dr. Spock.
3
5622
3167
00:20
(Laughter)
4
8789
1936
00:22
Thank you for indulging me.
5
10725
1231
00:23
I have always wanted to do that.
6
11956
3606
00:27
No, it was Benjamin Spock,
7
15562
2103
00:29
and his book was called "The Common
Sense Book of Baby And Child Care."
Sense Book of Baby And Child Care."
8
17665
3850
00:33
It sold almost 50 million copies
by the time he died.
by the time he died.
9
21515
5647
00:39
Today, I, as the mother of a six-year-old,
10
27162
3645
00:42
walk into Barnes and Noble,
11
30807
1677
00:44
and see this.
12
32484
2681
00:47
And it is amazing
13
35165
1959
00:49
the variety that one finds
on those shelves.
on those shelves.
14
37124
3704
00:52
There are guides to raising
an eco-friendly kid,
an eco-friendly kid,
15
40828
4422
00:57
a gluten-free kid,
16
45250
2195
00:59
a disease-proof kid,
17
47445
2365
01:01
which, if you ask me, is a little bit creepy.
18
49810
3953
01:05
There are guides to raising a bilingual kid
19
53763
2537
01:08
even if you only speak one language at home.
20
56300
2851
01:11
There are guides to raising a financially savvy kid
21
59151
3616
01:14
and a science-minded kid
22
62767
2762
01:17
and a kid who is a whiz at yoga.
23
65529
3110
01:20
Short of teaching your toddler how to defuse
24
68639
3210
01:23
a nuclear bomb,
25
71849
1350
01:25
there is pretty much a guide to everything.
26
73199
6506
01:31
All of these books are well-intentioned.
27
79705
2614
01:34
I am sure that many of them are great.
28
82319
4510
01:38
But taken together, I am sorry,
29
86829
4101
01:42
I do not see help
30
90930
2351
01:45
when I look at that shelf.
31
93281
3849
01:49
I see anxiety.
32
97130
2274
01:51
I see a giant candy-colored monument
33
99404
2727
01:54
to our collective panic,
34
102131
2943
01:57
and it makes me want to know,
35
105074
2581
01:59
why is it that raising our children
36
107655
2383
02:02
is associated with so much anguish
37
110038
1782
02:03
and so much confusion?
38
111820
2258
02:06
Why is it that we are at sixes and sevens
39
114078
2714
02:08
about the one thing human beings
40
116792
2976
02:11
have been doing successfully for millennia,
41
119768
1864
02:13
long before parenting message boards
42
121632
2836
02:16
and peer-reviewed studies came along?
43
124468
2877
02:19
Why is it that so many mothers and fathers
44
127345
2653
02:21
experience parenthood as a kind of crisis?
45
129998
6222
02:28
Crisis might seem like a strong word,
46
136220
2346
02:30
but there is data suggesting it probably isn't.
47
138566
2978
02:33
There was, in fact, a paper of just this very name,
48
141544
2756
02:36
"Parenthood as Crisis," published in 1957,
49
144300
4086
02:40
and in the 50-plus years since,
50
148386
2538
02:42
there has been plenty of scholarship
51
150924
2086
02:45
documenting a pretty clear pattern
52
153010
2407
02:47
of parental anguish.
53
155417
2055
02:49
Parents experience more stress than non-parents.
54
157472
3306
02:52
Their marital satisfaction is lower.
55
160778
2916
02:55
There have been a number of studies
56
163694
1517
02:57
looking at how parents feel
57
165211
1289
02:58
when they are spending time with their kids,
58
166500
2417
03:00
and the answer often is, not so great.
59
168917
3900
03:04
Last year, I spoke with a researcher
60
172817
2038
03:06
named Matthew Killingsworth
61
174855
1296
03:08
who is doing a very, very imaginative project
62
176151
3460
03:11
that tracks people's happiness,
63
179611
1898
03:13
and here is what he told me he found:
64
181509
3969
03:17
"Interacting with your friends
65
185478
1614
03:19
is better than interacting with your spouse,
66
187092
2912
03:22
which is better than interacting with other relatives,
67
190004
3356
03:25
which is better than interacting with acquaintances,
68
193360
3225
03:28
which is better than interacting with parents,
69
196585
2945
03:31
which is better than interacting with children.
70
199530
3776
03:35
Who are on par with strangers."
71
203306
2000
03:37
(Laughter)
72
205306
4506
03:41
But here's the thing.
73
209812
2367
03:44
I have been looking at what underlies these data
74
212179
3078
03:47
for three years,
75
215257
1911
03:49
and children are not the problem.
76
217168
3226
03:52
Something about parenting right now at this moment
77
220394
4987
03:57
is the problem.
78
225381
2040
03:59
Specifically, I don't think we know
79
227421
2489
04:01
what parenting is supposed to be.
80
229910
2516
04:04
Parent, as a verb,
81
232426
2180
04:06
only entered common usage in 1970.
82
234606
4262
04:10
Our roles as mothers and fathers have changed.
83
238868
3322
04:14
The roles of our children have changed.
84
242190
2841
04:17
We are all now furiously improvising
85
245031
2342
04:19
our way through a situation
86
247373
1906
04:21
for which there is no script,
87
249279
3593
04:24
and if you're an amazing jazz musician,
88
252872
2041
04:26
then improv is great,
89
254913
2187
04:29
but for the rest of us,
90
257100
2405
04:31
it can kind of feel like a crisis.
91
259505
3816
04:35
So how did we get here?
92
263321
2580
04:37
How is it that we are all now navigating
93
265901
2116
04:40
a child-rearing universe
94
268017
1552
04:41
without any norms to guide us?
95
269569
2828
04:44
Well, for starters, there has been
96
272397
2160
04:46
a major historical change.
97
274557
1839
04:48
Until fairly recently,
98
276396
2193
04:50
kids worked, on our farms primarily,
99
278589
3712
04:54
but also in factories, mills, mines.
100
282301
2868
04:57
Kids were considered economic assets.
101
285169
2916
05:00
Sometime during the Progressive Era,
102
288085
2096
05:02
we put an end to this arrangement.
103
290181
1628
05:03
We recognized kids had rights,
104
291809
2271
05:06
we banned child labor,
105
294080
1520
05:07
we focused on education instead,
106
295600
2770
05:10
and school became a child's new work.
107
298370
3176
05:13
And thank God it did.
108
301546
1706
05:15
But that only made a parent's role
109
303252
2397
05:17
more confusing in a way.
110
305649
1771
05:19
The old arrangement might not have been
111
307420
1552
05:20
particularly ethical, but it was reciprocal.
112
308972
3118
05:24
We provided food, clothing, shelter,
113
312090
2356
05:26
and moral instruction to our kids,
114
314446
2124
05:28
and they in return provided income.
115
316570
5640
05:34
Once kids stopped working,
116
322210
1968
05:36
the economics of parenting changed.
117
324178
3304
05:39
Kids became, in the words of one
118
327482
2572
05:42
brilliant if totally ruthless sociologist,
119
330054
3442
05:45
"economically worthless but emotionally priceless."
120
333496
4762
05:50
Rather than them working for us,
121
338258
2391
05:52
we began to work for them,
122
340649
1903
05:54
because within only a matter of decades
123
342552
1860
05:56
it became clear:
124
344412
1408
05:57
if we wanted our kids to succeed,
125
345820
2370
06:00
school was not enough.
126
348190
2993
06:03
Today, extracurricular activities are a kid's new work,
127
351183
4797
06:07
but that's work for us too,
128
355980
1757
06:09
because we are the ones
driving them to soccer practice.
driving them to soccer practice.
129
357737
3183
06:12
Massive piles of homework are a kid's new work,
130
360920
2863
06:15
but that's also work for us,
131
363783
1568
06:17
because we have to check it.
132
365351
2111
06:19
About three years ago, a Texas woman
133
367462
2325
06:21
told something to me
134
369787
1054
06:22
that totally broke my heart.
135
370841
3279
06:26
She said, almost casually,
136
374120
4040
06:30
"Homework is the new dinner."
137
378160
4434
06:34
The middle class now pours all of its time
138
382594
2600
06:37
and energy and resources into its kids,
139
385194
3442
06:40
even though the middle class
140
388636
1353
06:41
has less and less of those things to give.
141
389989
3613
06:45
Mothers now spend more time with their children
142
393602
3284
06:48
than they did in 1965,
143
396886
2383
06:51
when most women were not even in the workforce.
144
399269
5394
06:56
It would probably be easier for parents
145
404663
2112
06:58
to do their new roles
146
406775
1391
07:00
if they knew what they were preparing their kids for.
147
408166
3565
07:03
This is yet another thing that
makes modern parenting
makes modern parenting
148
411731
2444
07:06
so very confounding.
149
414175
2070
07:08
We have no clue what portion our wisdom, if any,
150
416245
3688
07:11
is of use to our kids.
151
419933
1757
07:13
The world is changing so rapidly,
152
421690
1433
07:15
it's impossible to say.
153
423123
2203
07:17
This was true even when I was young.
154
425326
2075
07:19
When I was a kid, high school specifically,
155
427401
3024
07:22
I was told that I would be at sea
156
430425
1984
07:24
in the new global economy
157
432409
1785
07:26
if I did not know Japanese.
158
434194
4506
07:30
And with all due respect to the Japanese,
159
438700
2502
07:33
it didn't turn out that way.
160
441202
2441
07:35
Now there is a certain kind of middle-class parent
161
443643
2288
07:37
that is obsessed with teaching their kids Mandarin,
162
445931
2704
07:40
and maybe they're onto something,
163
448635
2610
07:43
but we cannot know for sure.
164
451245
2735
07:45
So, absent being able to anticipate the future,
165
453980
2629
07:48
what we all do, as good parents,
166
456609
2625
07:51
is try and prepare our kids
167
459234
1927
07:53
for every possible kind of future,
168
461161
3048
07:56
hoping that just one of our efforts will pay off.
169
464209
4057
08:00
We teach our kids chess,
170
468266
1928
08:02
thinking maybe they will need analytical skills.
171
470194
2635
08:04
We sign them up for team sports,
172
472829
2445
08:07
thinking maybe they will need collaborative skills,
173
475274
3287
08:10
you know, for when they go
to Harvard Business School.
to Harvard Business School.
174
478561
2520
08:13
We try and teach them to be financially savvy
175
481081
3229
08:16
and science-minded and eco-friendly
176
484310
3457
08:19
and gluten-free,
177
487767
2966
08:22
though now is probably a good time to tell you
178
490733
1972
08:24
that I was not eco-friendly and gluten-free as a child.
179
492705
5540
08:30
I ate jars of pureed macaroni and beef.
180
498245
4790
08:35
And you know what? I'm doing okay.
181
503035
2177
08:37
I pay my taxes.
182
505212
2413
08:39
I hold down a steady job.
183
507625
3217
08:42
I was even invited to speak at TED.
184
510842
4328
08:47
But the presumption now is that
185
515170
1382
08:48
what was good enough for me,
or for my folks for that matter,
or for my folks for that matter,
186
516552
3398
08:51
isn't good enough anymore.
187
519950
1811
08:53
So we all make a mad dash to that bookshelf,
188
521761
3664
08:57
because we feel like if we aren't trying everything,
189
525425
3312
09:00
it's as if we're doing nothing
190
528737
2130
09:02
and we're defaulting on our obligations to our kids.
191
530867
5337
09:08
So it's hard enough to navigate our new roles
192
536204
2608
09:10
as mothers and fathers.
193
538812
1522
09:12
Now add to this problem something else:
194
540334
2446
09:14
we are also navigating new roles
195
542780
1928
09:16
as husbands and wives
196
544708
1604
09:18
because most women today are in the workforce.
197
546312
3648
09:21
This is another reason, I think,
198
549960
1530
09:23
that parenthood feels like a crisis.
199
551490
2322
09:25
We have no rules, no scripts, no norms
200
553812
2650
09:28
for what to do when a child comes along
201
556462
2540
09:31
now that both mom and dad are breadwinners.
202
559002
3191
09:34
The writer Michael Lewis once put this
203
562193
2405
09:36
very, very well.
204
564598
1237
09:37
He said that the surest way
205
565835
2512
09:40
for a couple to start fighting
206
568347
1795
09:42
is for them to go out to dinner with another couple
207
570142
3028
09:45
whose division of labor
208
573170
1185
09:46
is ever so slightly different from theirs,
209
574355
3610
09:49
because the conversation in
the car on the way home
the car on the way home
210
577965
3676
09:53
goes something like this:
211
581641
2217
09:56
"So, did you catch that Dave is the one
212
584775
4633
10:01
who walks them to school every morning?"
213
589408
3901
10:05
(Laughter)
214
593309
3821
10:09
Without scripts telling us who does what
215
597742
2515
10:12
in this brave new world, couples fight,
216
600257
3049
10:15
and both mothers and fathers each have
217
603306
3239
10:18
their legitimate gripes.
218
606545
1930
10:20
Mothers are much more likely
219
608475
1855
10:22
to be multi-tasking when they are at home,
220
610330
2078
10:24
and fathers, when they are at home,
221
612408
2211
10:26
are much more likely to be mono-tasking.
222
614619
2959
10:29
Find a guy at home, and odds are
223
617578
2568
10:32
he is doing just one thing at a time.
224
620146
3761
10:35
In fact, UCLA recently did a study
225
623907
2904
10:38
looking at the most common configuration
226
626811
2533
10:41
of family members in middle-class homes.
227
629344
3046
10:44
Guess what it was?
228
632390
1733
10:46
Dad in a room by himself.
229
634123
2647
10:48
According to the American Time Use Survey,
230
636770
2440
10:51
mothers still do twice as much childcare as fathers,
231
639210
3225
10:54
which is better than it was in Erma Bombeck's day,
232
642435
3599
10:58
but I still think that something she wrote
233
646034
2266
11:00
is highly relevant:
234
648300
2872
11:03
"I have not been alone in the
bathroom since October."
bathroom since October."
235
651172
3718
11:06
(Laughter)
236
654890
4334
11:11
But here is the thing: Men are doing plenty.
237
659224
4830
11:16
They spend more time with their kids
238
664054
1776
11:17
than their fathers ever spent with them.
239
665830
3334
11:21
They work more paid hours, on average,
240
669164
1980
11:23
than their wives,
241
671144
1693
11:24
and they genuinely want to be good,
242
672837
1834
11:26
involved dads.
243
674671
1579
11:28
Today, it is fathers, not mothers,
244
676250
3368
11:31
who report the most work-life conflict.
245
679618
4111
11:35
Either way, by the way,
246
683729
2232
11:37
if you think it's hard for traditional families
247
685961
2335
11:40
to sort out these new roles,
248
688296
1624
11:41
just imagine what it's like now
249
689920
1836
11:43
for non-traditional families:
250
691756
1895
11:45
families with two dads, families with two moms,
251
693651
2595
11:48
single-parent households.
252
696246
1705
11:49
They are truly improvising as they go.
253
697951
4393
11:54
Now, in a more progressive country,
254
702344
3791
11:58
and forgive me here for capitulating to cliché
255
706135
2730
12:00
and invoking, yes, Sweden,
256
708865
3054
12:03
parents could rely on the state
257
711919
2921
12:06
for support.
258
714840
2649
12:09
There are countries that acknowledge
259
717489
1879
12:11
the anxieties and the changing roles
260
719368
1433
12:12
of mothers and fathers.
261
720801
2364
12:15
Unfortunately, the United States is not one of them,
262
723165
3264
12:18
so in case you were wondering what the U.S.
263
726429
1965
12:20
has in common with Papua New Guinea and Liberia,
264
728394
5303
12:25
it's this:
265
733697
3031
12:28
We too have no paid maternity leave policy.
266
736728
3727
12:32
We are one of eight known countries that does not.
267
740455
7247
12:39
In this age of intense confusion,
268
747702
3571
12:43
there is just one goal upon which
269
751273
3402
12:46
all parents can agree,
270
754675
1832
12:48
and that is whether they are
271
756507
1464
12:49
tiger moms or hippie moms, helicopters or drones,
272
757971
4566
12:54
our kids' happiness is paramount.
273
762537
4141
12:58
That is what it means
274
766678
1882
13:00
to raise kids in an age
275
768560
2450
13:03
when they are economically worthless
276
771010
2225
13:05
but emotionally priceless.
277
773235
2245
13:07
We are all the custodians of their self-esteem.
278
775480
3400
13:10
The one mantra no parent ever questions is,
279
778880
3833
13:14
"All I want is for my children to be happy."
280
782713
5731
13:20
And don't get me wrong:
281
788444
1713
13:22
I think happiness is a wonderful goal for a child.
282
790157
4880
13:27
But it is a very elusive one.
283
795037
3706
13:30
Happiness and self-confidence,
284
798743
3940
13:34
teaching children that is not like teaching them
285
802683
1981
13:36
how to plow a field.
286
804664
1516
13:38
It's not like teaching them how to ride a bike.
287
806180
2701
13:40
There's no curriculum for it.
288
808881
2557
13:43
Happiness and self-confidence can
be the byproducts of other things,
be the byproducts of other things,
289
811438
3597
13:47
but they cannot really be goals unto themselves.
290
815035
3055
13:50
A child's happiness
291
818090
1666
13:51
is a very unfair burden to place on a parent.
292
819756
3755
13:55
And happiness is an even more unfair burden
293
823521
2838
13:58
to place on a kid.
294
826359
2840
14:01
And I have to tell you,
295
829199
2023
14:03
I think it leads to some very strange excesses.
296
831222
3882
14:07
We are now so anxious
297
835104
2402
14:09
to protect our kids from the world's ugliness
298
837506
3318
14:12
that we now shield them from "Sesame Street."
299
840824
4752
14:17
I wish I could say I was kidding about this,
300
845576
2136
14:19
but if you go out and you buy
301
847712
2672
14:22
the first few episodes of "Sesame Street" on DVD,
302
850384
2939
14:25
as I did out of nostalgia,
303
853323
3081
14:28
you will find a warning at the beginning
304
856404
3113
14:31
saying that the content is not suitable
305
859517
2630
14:34
for children.
306
862147
1768
14:35
(Laughter)
307
863915
2110
14:38
Can I just repeat that?
308
866025
1205
14:39
The content of the original "Sesame Street"
309
867230
2631
14:41
is not suitable for children.
310
869861
3342
14:45
When asked about this by The New York Times,
311
873203
3642
14:48
a producer for the show gave
a variety of explanations.
a variety of explanations.
312
876845
3305
14:52
One was that Cookie Monster smoked a pipe
313
880150
2759
14:54
in one skit and then swallowed it.
314
882909
1761
14:56
Bad modeling. I don't know.
315
884670
1435
14:58
But the thing that stuck with me
316
886105
2982
15:01
is she said that she didn't know
317
889087
2455
15:03
whether Oscar the Grouch could be invented today
318
891542
4339
15:07
because he was too depressive.
319
895881
4898
15:12
I cannot tell you how much this distresses me.
320
900779
2408
15:15
(Laughter)
321
903187
1519
15:16
You are looking at a woman
322
904706
1853
15:18
who has a periodic table of the Muppets
323
906559
3044
15:21
hanging from her cubicle wall.
324
909603
3792
15:25
The offending muppet, right there.
325
913395
3759
15:30
That's my son the day he was born.
326
918239
4786
15:35
I was high as a kite on morphine.
327
923025
2192
15:37
I had had an unexpected C-section.
328
925217
3863
15:41
But even in my opiate haze,
329
929080
3516
15:44
I managed to have one very clear thought
330
932596
2933
15:47
the first time I held him.
331
935529
2952
15:50
I whispered it into his ear.
332
938481
1904
15:52
I said, "I will try so hard not to hurt you."
333
940385
8884
16:01
It was the Hippocratic Oath,
334
949269
1320
16:02
and I didn't even know I was saying it.
335
950589
3878
16:06
But it occurs to me now
336
954467
2324
16:08
that the Hippocratic Oath
337
956791
2079
16:10
is a much more realistic aim than happiness.
338
958870
4332
16:15
In fact, as any parent will tell you,
339
963202
3600
16:18
it's awfully hard.
340
966802
2768
16:21
All of us have said or done hurtful things
341
969570
4854
16:26
that we wish to God we could take back.
342
974424
5974
16:32
I think in another era
343
980398
2848
16:35
we did not expect quite so much from ourselves,
344
983246
3992
16:39
and it is important that we all remember that
345
987238
3682
16:42
the next time we are staring with our hearts racing
346
990920
3834
16:46
at those bookshelves.
347
994754
4046
16:52
I'm not really sure how to create new norms
348
1000254
3254
16:55
for this world,
349
1003508
1678
16:57
but I do think that
350
1005186
3084
17:00
in our desperate quest to create happy kids,
351
1008270
3318
17:03
we may be assuming the wrong moral burden.
352
1011588
3027
17:06
It strikes me as a better goal,
353
1014615
1718
17:08
and, dare I say, a more virtuous one,
354
1016333
2216
17:10
to focus on making productive kids
355
1018549
2719
17:13
and moral kids,
356
1021268
1340
17:14
and to simply hope that happiness will come to them
357
1022608
2316
17:16
by virtue of the good that they do
358
1024924
2746
17:19
and their accomplishments
359
1027670
2228
17:21
and the love that they feel from us.
360
1029898
2898
17:24
That, anyway, is one response to having no script.
361
1032796
5633
17:30
Absent having new scripts,
362
1038429
3333
17:33
we just follow the oldest ones in the book --
363
1041762
3685
17:37
decency, a work ethic, love —
364
1045447
5599
17:43
and let happiness and self-esteem
take care of themselves.
take care of themselves.
365
1051046
4324
17:47
I think if we all did that,
366
1055370
2044
17:49
the kids would still be all right,
367
1057414
3541
17:52
and so would their parents,
368
1060955
2646
17:55
possibly in both cases even better.
369
1063601
3968
17:59
Thank you.
370
1067569
1879
18:01
(Applause)
371
1069448
4000
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Jennifer Senior - WriterIn her new book "All Joy and No Fun," Jennifer Senior explores how children reshape their parents' lives -- for better and worse.
Why you should listen
Jennifer Senior is a contributing editor at New York Magazine, where she writes profiles and cover stories about politics, social science and mental health. In a groundbreaking 2010 story for the magazine, called "All Joy and No Fun: Why Parents Hate Parenting," she examined the social science around modern parenting, looking at happiness research from Dan Gilbert, Danny Kahneman and others, as well as anthropological research (she was an anthro major) around how families behave. Her conclusion: Hey, parents, it's okay not to feel blissfully happy all the time.
She expanded the piece into a book that dives deeper into the research and paradoxes of modern American parenting styles -- including parents' sometimes inflated expectations of constant awesomeness, meaningfulness and bliss. As she says, "I think of this book as a series of mini-ethnographies -- portraits of how American families live now."
More profile about the speakerShe expanded the piece into a book that dives deeper into the research and paradoxes of modern American parenting styles -- including parents' sometimes inflated expectations of constant awesomeness, meaningfulness and bliss. As she says, "I think of this book as a series of mini-ethnographies -- portraits of how American families live now."
Jennifer Senior | Speaker | TED.com