TED Talks Live
Hector Garcia: We train soldiers for war. Let's train them to come home, too
Filmed:
Readability: 4.3
1,099,517 views
Before soldiers are sent into combat, they're trained on how to function in an immensely dangerous environment. But they also need training on how to return from the battlefield to civilian life, says psychologist Hector Garcia. Applying the same principles used to prepare soldiers for war, Garcia is helping veterans suffering from PTSD get their lives back.
Hector Garcia - Psychologist
Hector A. Garcia has spent his career as a frontline psychologist delivering evidence-based psychotherapies to veterans with posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Full bio
Hector A. Garcia has spent his career as a frontline psychologist delivering evidence-based psychotherapies to veterans with posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
Carlos,
0
924
1529
00:14
the Vietnam vet Marine
1
2477
1553
00:16
who volunteered for three tours
and got shot up in every one.
and got shot up in every one.
2
4054
3784
00:20
In 1971, he was medically retired
3
8650
2102
00:22
because he had so much
shrapnel in his body
shrapnel in his body
4
10776
2299
00:25
that he was setting off metal detectors.
5
13099
2118
00:28
For the next 42 years,
he suffered from nightmares,
he suffered from nightmares,
6
16279
3101
00:31
extreme anxiety in public,
7
19404
2214
00:33
isolation, depression.
8
21642
2011
00:35
He self-medicated with alcohol.
9
23677
1904
00:37
He was married and divorced three times.
10
25605
2906
00:40
Carlos had post-traumatic stress disorder.
11
28535
2721
00:44
Now, I became a psychologist
to help mitigate human suffering,
to help mitigate human suffering,
12
32129
3577
00:47
and for the past 10 years, my target
has been the suffering caused by PTSD,
has been the suffering caused by PTSD,
13
35730
4487
00:52
as experienced by veterans like Carlos.
14
40241
2522
00:55
Until recently, the science of PTSD
just wasn't there.
just wasn't there.
15
43356
5217
01:01
And so, we didn't know what to do.
16
49161
2376
01:03
We put some veterans on heavy drugs.
17
51561
2364
01:05
Others we hospitalized
and gave generic group therapy,
and gave generic group therapy,
18
53949
2804
01:08
and others still we simply said to them,
19
56777
2098
01:10
"Just go home and try to forget
about your experiences."
about your experiences."
20
58899
3314
01:15
More recently, we've tried therapy dogs,
wilderness retreats --
wilderness retreats --
21
63534
3343
01:18
many things which may
temporarily relieve stress,
temporarily relieve stress,
22
66901
2921
01:21
but which don't actually eliminate
PTSD symptoms over the long term.
PTSD symptoms over the long term.
23
69846
3905
01:26
But things have changed.
24
74654
1357
01:28
And I am here to tell you
that we can now eliminate PTSD,
that we can now eliminate PTSD,
25
76451
5156
01:33
not just manage the symptoms,
26
81631
1827
01:35
and in huge numbers of veterans.
27
83482
1548
01:37
Because new scientific research
has been able to show,
has been able to show,
28
85054
2978
01:40
objectively, repeatedly,
29
88056
2378
01:42
which treatments actually
get rid of symptoms and which do not.
get rid of symptoms and which do not.
30
90458
3475
01:45
Now as it turns out,
31
93957
1648
01:47
the best treatments for PTSD use
many of the very same training principles
many of the very same training principles
32
95629
5230
01:52
that the military uses
in preparing its trainees for war.
in preparing its trainees for war.
33
100883
3852
01:58
Now, making war --
34
106227
1479
02:00
this is something that we are good at.
35
108254
2305
02:02
We humans have been making war
since before we were even fully human.
since before we were even fully human.
36
110993
4140
02:08
And since then, we have gone
from using stone and sinew
from using stone and sinew
37
116006
3464
02:11
to developing the most sophisticated
and devastating weapon systems imaginable.
and devastating weapon systems imaginable.
38
119494
4590
02:16
And to enable our warriors
to use these weapons,
to use these weapons,
39
124108
2335
02:18
we employ the most cutting-edge
training methods.
training methods.
40
126467
2321
02:20
We are good at making war.
41
128812
1427
02:22
And we are good at training
our warriors to fight.
our warriors to fight.
42
130898
2987
02:26
Yet, when we consider the experience
of the modern-day combat veteran,
of the modern-day combat veteran,
43
134687
3489
02:30
we begin to see that we
have not been as good
have not been as good
44
138200
3187
02:33
at preparing them to come home.
45
141411
1620
02:35
Why is that?
46
143447
1202
02:37
Well, our ancestors lived
immersed in conflict,
immersed in conflict,
47
145731
3274
02:41
and they fought right where they lived.
48
149029
2378
02:44
So until only very recently
in our evolutionary history,
in our evolutionary history,
49
152094
3014
02:47
there was hardly a need to learn
how to come home from war,
how to come home from war,
50
155132
2892
02:50
because we never really did.
51
158048
2126
02:53
But thankfully, today,
52
161377
1242
02:54
most of humanity lives
in far more peaceful societies,
in far more peaceful societies,
53
162643
3015
02:57
and when there is conflict,
we, especially in the United States,
we, especially in the United States,
54
165682
3979
03:01
now have the technology to put
our warriors through advanced training,
our warriors through advanced training,
55
169685
3497
03:05
drop them in to fight
anywhere on the globe
anywhere on the globe
56
173206
2817
03:08
and when they're done,
57
176047
1459
03:09
jet them back to peacetime suburbia.
58
177530
2025
03:12
But just imagine for a moment
what this must feel like.
what this must feel like.
59
180514
3858
03:17
I've spoken with veterans who've told me
60
185064
2020
03:19
that one day they're in a brutal
firefight in Afghanistan
firefight in Afghanistan
61
187108
3092
03:22
where they saw carnage and death,
62
190224
2875
03:25
and just three days later,
they found themselves
they found themselves
63
193867
2470
03:28
toting an ice chest
to their kid's soccer game.
to their kid's soccer game.
64
196361
2584
03:32
"Mindfuck" is the most common term.
65
200405
2765
03:35
(Laughter)
66
203194
1414
03:36
It's the most common term
I've heard to describe that experience.
I've heard to describe that experience.
67
204632
3119
03:39
And that's exactly what that is.
68
207775
1524
03:41
Because while our warriors
spend countless hours training for war,
spend countless hours training for war,
69
209323
3989
03:45
we've only recently come to understand
70
213336
1893
03:47
that many require training
on how to return to civilian life.
on how to return to civilian life.
71
215253
3460
03:51
Now, like any training, the best
PTSD treatments require repetition.
PTSD treatments require repetition.
72
219642
4091
03:55
In the military,
73
223757
1151
03:56
we don't simply hand trainees
Mark-19 automatic grenade launchers
Mark-19 automatic grenade launchers
74
224932
3240
04:00
and say, "Here's the trigger,
here's some ammo and good luck."
here's some ammo and good luck."
75
228196
3192
04:03
No. We train them, on the range
and in specific contexts,
and in specific contexts,
76
231412
4696
04:08
over and over and over
77
236132
1686
04:09
until lifting their weapon
and engaging their target
and engaging their target
78
237842
2789
04:12
is so engrained into muscle memory
79
240655
1836
04:14
that it can be performed
without even thinking,
without even thinking,
80
242515
2328
04:16
even under the most stressful
conditions you can imagine.
conditions you can imagine.
81
244867
2920
04:20
Now, the same holds
for training base treatments.
for training base treatments.
82
248630
2734
04:23
The first of these treatments
is cognitive therapy,
is cognitive therapy,
83
251875
3331
04:27
and this is a kind
of mental recalibration.
of mental recalibration.
84
255230
3369
04:31
When veterans come home from war,
85
259166
1629
04:32
their way of mentally framing
the world is calibrated
the world is calibrated
86
260819
2596
04:35
to an immensely
more dangerous environment.
more dangerous environment.
87
263439
2659
04:38
So when you try to overlay that mind frame
onto a peacetime environment,
onto a peacetime environment,
88
266860
5156
04:44
you get problems.
89
272040
1205
04:45
You begin drowning in worries
about dangers that aren't present.
about dangers that aren't present.
90
273269
4455
04:49
You begin not trusting family or friends.
91
277748
3323
04:53
Which is not to say there are no
dangers in civilian life; there are.
dangers in civilian life; there are.
92
281935
4064
04:58
It's just that the probability
of encountering them
of encountering them
93
286402
2692
05:01
compared to combat
94
289118
1270
05:02
is astronomically lower.
95
290412
2308
05:05
So we never advise veterans
to turn off caution completely.
to turn off caution completely.
96
293675
3140
05:08
We do train them, however,
to adjust caution
to adjust caution
97
296839
2384
05:11
according to where they are.
98
299247
1641
05:13
If you find yourself
in a bad neighborhood,
in a bad neighborhood,
99
301685
2485
05:16
you turn it up.
100
304194
1255
05:17
Out to dinner with family?
101
305878
1649
05:19
You turn it way down.
102
307551
1928
05:21
We train veterans to be fiercely rational,
103
309975
2772
05:25
to systematically gauge
the actual statistical probability
the actual statistical probability
104
313271
3554
05:28
of encountering, say, an IED
here in peacetime America.
here in peacetime America.
105
316849
3808
05:33
With enough practice,
those recalibrations stick.
those recalibrations stick.
106
321460
4264
05:39
The next of these treatments
is exposure therapy,
is exposure therapy,
107
327193
2314
05:41
and this is a kind of field training,
108
329531
2427
05:44
and the fastest of the proven
effective treatments out there.
effective treatments out there.
109
332453
3061
05:47
You remember Carlos?
110
335974
1557
05:49
This was the treatment that he chose.
111
337555
1867
05:51
And so we started off
by giving him exercises,
by giving him exercises,
112
339869
2440
05:54
for him, challenging ones:
113
342333
1306
05:55
going to a grocery store,
114
343663
1946
05:57
going to a shopping mall,
going to a restaurant,
going to a restaurant,
115
345633
2625
06:00
sitting with his back to the door.
116
348282
2490
06:03
And, critically --
117
351214
1185
06:05
staying in these environments.
118
353032
1513
06:07
Now, at first he was very anxious.
119
355791
1710
06:09
He wanted to sit
where he could scan the room,
where he could scan the room,
120
357525
2492
06:12
where he could plan escape routes,
121
360041
1925
06:13
where he could get his hands
on a makeshift weapon.
on a makeshift weapon.
122
361990
3027
06:17
And he wanted to leave, but he didn't.
123
365041
2840
06:20
He remembered his training
in the Marine Corps,
in the Marine Corps,
124
368390
2871
06:23
and he pushed through his discomfort.
125
371285
1844
06:25
And every time he did this,
his anxiety ratcheted down a little bit,
his anxiety ratcheted down a little bit,
126
373530
3192
06:28
and then a little bit more
and then a little bit more,
and then a little bit more,
127
376746
2759
06:31
until in the end,
128
379529
1314
06:32
he had effectively relearned
how to sit in a public space
how to sit in a public space
129
380867
4910
06:38
and just enjoy himself.
130
386785
1484
06:41
He also listened to recordings
of his combat experiences,
of his combat experiences,
131
389704
3318
06:45
over and over and over.
132
393046
2181
06:47
He listened until those memories
no longer generated any anxiety.
no longer generated any anxiety.
133
395706
4240
06:52
He processed his memories so much
134
400419
2562
06:55
that his brain no longer needed
to return to those experiences
to return to those experiences
135
403005
3229
06:58
in his sleep.
136
406258
1285
07:00
And when I spoke with him
a year after treatment had finished,
a year after treatment had finished,
137
408400
3553
07:03
he told me,
138
411977
1371
07:05
"Doc, this is the first time in 43 years
139
413372
4401
07:10
that I haven't had nightmares."
140
418472
1586
07:13
Now, this is different
than erasing a memory.
than erasing a memory.
141
421412
4178
07:18
Veterans will always remember
their traumatic experiences,
their traumatic experiences,
142
426087
2995
07:21
but with enough practice,
143
429106
1657
07:22
those memories are no longer as raw
or as painful as they once were.
or as painful as they once were.
144
430787
5206
07:28
They don't feel emotionally
like they just happened yesterday,
like they just happened yesterday,
145
436379
3561
07:31
and that is an immensely
better place to be.
better place to be.
146
439964
3806
07:37
But it's often difficult.
147
445985
1270
07:39
And, like any training,
it may not work for everybody.
it may not work for everybody.
148
447677
3638
07:44
And there are trust issues.
149
452117
1291
07:45
Sometimes I'm asked,
150
453931
1282
07:47
"If you haven't been there, Doc,
how can you help me?"
how can you help me?"
151
455237
2654
07:49
Which is understandable.
152
457915
1463
07:52
But at the point of returning
to civilian life,
to civilian life,
153
460244
4371
07:56
you do not require
somebody who's been there.
somebody who's been there.
154
464639
2985
07:59
You don't require training
for operations on the battlefield;
for operations on the battlefield;
155
467985
3116
08:03
you require training on how to come home.
156
471125
3913
08:10
For the past 10 years of my work,
157
478626
2265
08:13
I have been exposed to detailed accounts
158
481336
2748
08:16
of the worst experiences
that you can imagine,
that you can imagine,
159
484108
2600
08:18
daily.
160
486732
1229
08:19
And it hasn't always been easy.
161
487985
2098
08:22
There have been times
where I have just felt my heart break
where I have just felt my heart break
162
490107
3365
08:25
or that I've absorbed too much.
163
493496
1847
08:28
But these training-based
treatments work so well,
treatments work so well,
164
496150
3323
08:31
that whatever this work takes out of me,
it puts back even more,
it puts back even more,
165
499497
3082
08:34
because I see people get better.
166
502603
3246
08:38
I see people's lives transform.
167
506754
1823
08:42
Carlos can now enjoy outings
with his grandchildren,
with his grandchildren,
168
510656
3338
08:46
which is something he couldn't even do
with his own children.
with his own children.
169
514018
3207
08:49
And what's amazing to me
is that after 43 years of suffering,
is that after 43 years of suffering,
170
517638
3986
08:53
it only took him 10 weeks
of intense training to get his life back.
of intense training to get his life back.
171
521648
3819
08:58
And when I spoke with him, he told me,
172
526001
2308
09:00
"I know that I can't get those years back.
173
528333
4017
09:05
But at least now, whatever days
that I have left on this Earth,
that I have left on this Earth,
174
533088
4909
09:10
I can live them in peace."
175
538021
1917
09:13
He also said, "I hope that these
younger veterans don't wait
younger veterans don't wait
176
541114
3472
09:16
to get the help they need."
177
544610
1348
09:18
And that's my hope, too.
178
546588
1286
09:21
Because ...
179
549020
1186
09:23
this life is short,
180
551003
1443
09:25
and if you are fortunate enough
to have survived war
to have survived war
181
553383
3172
09:28
or any kind of traumatic experience,
182
556579
2080
09:30
you owe it to yourself
to live your life well.
to live your life well.
183
558683
3515
09:34
And you shouldn't wait
to get the training you need
to get the training you need
184
562629
2641
09:37
to make that happen.
185
565294
1385
09:40
Now, the best way of ending
human suffering caused by war
human suffering caused by war
186
568663
5315
09:46
is to never go to war.
187
574883
1500
09:49
But we are just not there
yet as a species.
yet as a species.
188
577422
2166
09:52
Until we are,
189
580157
1260
09:53
the mental suffering that we create
in our sons and in our daughters
in our sons and in our daughters
190
581441
5233
09:58
when we send them off to fight
191
586698
1548
10:00
can be alleviated.
192
588682
2250
10:03
But we must ensure that the science,
the energy level, the value
the energy level, the value
193
591675
6086
10:09
that we place on sending them off to war
194
597785
2932
10:13
is at the very least mirrored
195
601516
1910
10:15
in how well we prepare them
to come back home to us.
to come back home to us.
196
603450
3606
10:19
This much, we owe them.
197
607868
1573
10:22
Thank you.
198
610186
1183
10:23
(Applause)
199
611393
6931
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Hector Garcia - PsychologistHector A. Garcia has spent his career as a frontline psychologist delivering evidence-based psychotherapies to veterans with posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD).
Why you should listen
Hector A. Garcia is a psychologist with the Valley Coastal Bend Veterans Health Care System and a clinical assistant professor in the Department of Psychiatry at UT Health Science Center at San Antonio.
In his work as a researcher, Garcia examines barriers to PTSD care, masculine identity and its impact on PTSD treatment-seeking, and how occupational burnout impacts PTSD care providers, who daily hear detailed accounts of trauma. As a teacher and scientist, he explores how evolutionary psychology and biology have influenced human tendencies toward violence in religion.
Garcia's groundbreaking book, Alpha God: The Psychology of Religious Violence and Oppression, reveals how human evolutionary history has left us prone to religiously inspired bloodshed. In particular, he explains how men's competition over evolutionary resources -- especially sexual primacy and territorial control -- has too often been projected onto notions of God, resulting in religious warfare, the oppression of women and ecological devastation. His regular blog on Psychology Today examines the evolutionary psychology of violence, politics, religion and our everyday lives.
Hector Garcia | Speaker | TED.com