TEDxWomen 2012
iO Tillett Wright: Fifty shades of gay
Filmed:
Readability: 3.7
2,965,570 views
iO Tillett Wright has photographed 2,000 people who consider themselves somewhere on the LGBTQ spectrum -- and asked many of them: Can you assign a percentage to how gay or straight you are? Most people, it turns out, consider themselves to exist in the gray areas of sexuality, not 100% gay or straight. Which presents a real problem when it comes to discrimination: Where do you draw the line?
iO Tillett Wright - Photographer
As a child actor, iO Tillett Wright turned his shoes around in the bathroom stall so that people would think he was a boy. As a teenager, he fell in love with both women and men. His life in the gray areas of gender and sexuality deeply inform his work as an artist. Full bio
As a child actor, iO Tillett Wright turned his shoes around in the bathroom stall so that people would think he was a boy. As a teenager, he fell in love with both women and men. His life in the gray areas of gender and sexuality deeply inform his work as an artist. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:16
Human beings start putting each other into boxes
0
737
2429
00:19
the second that they see each other --
1
3166
1817
00:20
Is that person dangerous? Are they attractive?
2
4983
3070
00:23
Are they a potential mate? Are they a potential networking opportunity?
3
8053
3266
00:27
We do this little interrogation when we meet people
4
11319
2534
00:29
to make a mental resume for them.
5
13853
2167
00:31
What's your name? Where are you from?
6
16020
1517
00:33
How old are you? What do you do?
7
17537
3361
00:36
Then we get more personal with it.
8
20898
2801
00:39
Have you ever had any diseases?
9
23699
3148
00:42
Have you ever been divorced?
10
26847
1987
00:44
Does your breath smell bad while you're answering my interrogation right now?
11
28834
3446
00:48
What are you into? Who are you into?
12
32280
1717
00:49
What gender do you like to sleep with?
13
33997
1866
00:51
I get it.
14
35863
2430
00:54
We are neurologically hardwired
15
38293
1752
00:55
to seek out people like ourselves.
16
40045
2384
00:58
We start forming cliques as soon as we're old enough
17
42429
2185
01:00
to know what acceptance feels like.
18
44614
1933
01:02
We bond together based on anything that we can --
19
46547
2350
01:04
music preference, race, gender, the block that we grew up on.
20
48897
5452
01:10
We seek out environments that reinforce our personal choices.
21
54349
6888
01:17
Sometimes, though, just the question "what do you do?"
22
61237
2461
01:19
can feel like somebody's opening a tiny little box
23
63698
1960
01:21
and asking you to squeeze yourself inside of it.
24
65658
1529
01:23
Because the categories, I've found, are too limiting.
25
67187
3567
01:26
The boxes are too narrow.
26
70754
1884
01:28
And this can get really dangerous.
27
72638
2117
01:30
So here's a disclaimer about me, though,
28
74755
1781
01:32
before we get too deep into this.
29
76536
1602
01:34
I grew up in a very sheltered environment.
30
78138
2985
01:37
I was raised in downtown Manhattan in the early 1980s,
31
81123
3946
01:40
two blocks from the epicenter of punk music.
32
85069
3895
01:44
I was shielded from the pains of bigotry
33
88964
2090
01:46
and the social restrictions of a religiously-based upbringing.
34
91054
4100
01:51
Where I come from, if you weren't a drag queen or a radical thinker
35
95154
3421
01:54
or a performance artist of some kind,
36
98575
2128
01:56
you were the weirdo.
37
100703
1984
01:58
(Laughter)
38
102687
1283
01:59
It was an unorthodox upbringing,
39
103970
2085
02:01
but as a kid on the streets of New York,
40
106055
2511
02:04
you learn how to trust your own instincts,
41
108566
1971
02:06
you learn how to go with your own ideas.
42
110537
2933
02:09
So when I was six, I decided that I wanted to be a boy.
43
113470
3239
02:12
I went to school one day and the kids wouldn't let me play basketball with them.
44
116709
3467
02:16
They said they wouldn't let girls play.
45
120176
1433
02:17
So I went home, and I shaved my head,
46
121609
1410
02:18
and I came back the next day and I said, "I'm a boy."
47
123019
2622
02:21
I mean, who knows, right?
48
125641
1014
02:22
When you're six, maybe you can do that.
49
126655
3813
02:26
I didn't want anyone to know that I was a girl, and they didn't.
50
130468
3633
02:30
I kept up the charade for eight years.
51
134101
2642
02:32
So this is me when I was 11.
52
136743
4167
02:36
I was playing a kid named Walter
53
140910
1511
02:38
in a movie called "Julian Po."
54
142421
2189
02:40
I was a little street tough that followed Christian Slater around and badgered him.
55
144610
3434
02:43
See, I was also a child actor,
56
148044
2050
02:45
which doubled up the layers of the performance of my identity,
57
150094
2682
02:48
because no one knew that I was actually a girl really playing a boy.
58
152776
6088
02:54
In fact, no one in my life knew that I was a girl --
59
158864
3116
02:57
not my teachers at school, not my friends,
60
161980
2316
03:00
not the directors that I worked with.
61
164296
1852
03:02
Kids would often come up to me in class
62
166148
2265
03:04
and grab me by the throat to check for an Adam's apple
63
168413
2234
03:06
or grab my crotch to check what I was working with.
64
170647
3349
03:09
When I would go to the bathroom, I would turn my shoes around in the stalls
65
173996
2361
03:12
so that it looked like I was peeing standing up.
66
176357
2555
03:14
At sleepovers I would have panic attacks
67
178912
2068
03:16
trying to break it to girls that they didn't want to kiss me
68
180980
2384
03:19
without outing myself.
69
183364
1732
03:20
It's worth mentioning though
70
185096
2052
03:23
that I didn't hate my body or my genitalia.
71
187148
3849
03:26
I didn't feel like I was in the wrong body.
72
190997
1767
03:28
I felt like I was performing this elaborate act.
73
192764
2032
03:30
I wouldn't have qualified as transgender.
74
194796
3827
03:34
If my family, though, had been the kind of people to believe in therapy,
75
198623
2246
03:36
they probably would have diagnosed me
76
200869
1723
03:38
as something like gender dysmorphic
77
202592
1786
03:40
and put me on hormones to stave off puberty.
78
204378
2403
03:42
But in my particular case,
79
206781
884
03:43
I just woke up one day when I was 14,
80
207665
1715
03:45
and I decided that I wanted to be a girl again.
81
209380
2583
03:47
Puberty had hit, and I had no idea what being a girl meant,
82
211963
3000
03:50
and I was ready to figure out who I actually was.
83
214963
3625
03:54
When a kid behaves like I did,
84
218588
2405
03:56
they don't exactly have to come out, right?
85
220993
1836
03:58
No one is exactly shocked.
86
222829
2261
04:00
(Laughter)
87
225090
3744
04:04
But I wasn't asked to define myself by my parents.
88
228834
4463
04:09
When I was 15, and I called my father
89
233297
1866
04:11
to tell him that I had fallen in love,
90
235163
1700
04:12
it was the last thing on either of our minds
91
236863
2300
04:15
to discuss what the consequences were
92
239163
1616
04:16
of the fact that my first love was a girl.
93
240779
2418
04:19
Three years later, when I fell in love with a man,
94
243197
2282
04:21
neither of my parents batted an eyelash either.
95
245479
2584
04:23
See, it's one of the great blessings of my very unorthodox childhood
96
248063
3383
04:27
that I wasn't ever asked to define myself
97
251446
2034
04:29
as any one thing at any point.
98
253480
2347
04:31
I was just allowed to be me, growing and changing in every moment.
99
255827
3819
04:35
So four, almost five years ago,
100
259646
3045
04:38
Proposition 8, the great marriage equality debate,
101
262691
3315
04:41
was raising a lot of dust around this country.
102
266006
1975
04:43
And at the time, getting married wasn't really something
103
267981
2611
04:46
I spent a lot of time thinking about.
104
270592
1133
04:47
But I was struck by the fact that America,
105
271725
2806
04:50
a country with such a tarnished civil rights record,
106
274531
2065
04:52
could be repeating its mistakes so blatantly.
107
276596
2616
04:55
And I remember watching the discussion on television
108
279212
1968
04:57
and thinking how interesting it was
109
281180
1801
04:58
that the separation of church and state
110
282981
3031
05:01
was essentially drawing geographical boundaries throughout this country,
111
286012
3619
05:05
between places where people believed in it
112
289631
1582
05:07
and places where people didn't.
113
291213
1785
05:08
And then, that this discussion was drawing geographical boundaries around me.
114
292998
6248
05:15
If this was a war with two disparate sides,
115
299246
3118
05:18
I, by default, fell on team gay,
116
302364
2781
05:21
because I certainly wasn't 100 percent straight.
117
305145
3186
05:24
At the time I was just beginning to emerge
118
308331
3249
05:27
from this eight-year personal identity crisis zigzag
119
311580
3917
05:31
that saw me go from being a boy
120
315497
1833
05:33
to being this awkward girl that looked like a boy in girl's clothes
121
317330
3222
05:36
to the opposite extreme of this super skimpy,
122
320552
2790
05:39
over-compensating, boy-chasing girly-girl
123
323342
2666
05:41
to finally just a hesitant exploration of what I actually was,
124
326008
3968
05:45
a tomboyish girl
125
329976
2407
05:48
who liked both boys and girls depending on the person.
126
332383
3209
05:51
I had spent a year photographing this new generation of girls, much like myself,
127
335592
5151
05:56
who fell kind of between-the-lines --
128
340743
1666
05:58
girls who skateboarded but did it in lacy underwear,
129
342409
3537
06:01
girls who had boys' haircuts but wore girly nail polish,
130
345946
3958
06:05
girls who had eyeshadow to match their scraped knees,
131
349904
2995
06:08
girls who liked girls and boys who all liked boys and girls
132
352899
3098
06:11
who all hated being boxed in to anything.
133
355997
1849
06:13
I loved these people, and I admired their freedom,
134
357846
3751
06:17
but I watched as the world outside of our utopian bubble
135
361597
2933
06:20
exploded into these raging debates
136
364530
1850
06:22
where pundits started likening our love to bestiality on national television.
137
366380
5566
06:27
And this powerful awareness rolled in over me
138
371946
2333
06:30
that I was a minority, and in my own home country,
139
374279
5367
06:35
based on one facet of my character.
140
379646
2651
06:38
I was legally and indisputably a second-class citizen.
141
382297
5615
06:43
I was not an activist.
142
387912
1534
06:45
I wave no flags in my own life.
143
389446
2500
06:47
But I was plagued by this question:
144
391946
2139
06:49
How could anyone vote to strip the rights
145
394085
2946
06:52
of the vast variety of people that I knew
146
397031
2165
06:55
based on one element of their character?
147
399196
3434
06:58
How could they say that we as a group
148
402630
1516
07:00
were not deserving of equal rights as somebody else?
149
404146
2933
07:02
Were we even a group? What group?
150
407079
2367
07:05
And had these people ever even consciously met a victim of their discrimination?
151
409446
3867
07:09
Did they know who they were voting against and what the impact was?
152
413313
4043
07:13
And then it occurred to me,
153
417356
1891
07:15
perhaps if they could look into the eyes
154
419247
2283
07:17
of the people that they were casting into second-class citizenship
155
421530
3781
07:21
it might make it harder for them to do.
156
425311
1902
07:23
It might give them pause.
157
427213
1984
07:25
Obviously I couldn't get 20 million people to the same dinner party,
158
429197
5840
07:30
so I figured out a way where I could introduce them to each other photographically
159
435037
4331
07:35
without any artifice, without any lighting,
160
439368
2966
07:38
or without any manipulation of any kind on my part.
161
442334
3234
07:41
Because in a photograph you can examine a lion's whiskers
162
445568
2750
07:44
without the fear of him ripping your face off.
163
448318
2716
07:46
For me, photography is not just about exposing film,
164
451034
3397
07:50
it's about exposing the viewer
165
454431
1953
07:52
to something new, a place they haven't gone before,
166
456384
2101
07:54
but most importantly, to people that they might be afraid of.
167
458485
3315
07:57
Life magazine introduced generations of people
168
461800
1844
07:59
to distant, far-off cultures they never knew existed through pictures.
169
463644
4074
08:03
So I decided to make a series of very simple portraits,
170
467718
6233
08:09
mugshots if you will.
171
473951
1750
08:11
And I basically decided to photograph anyone in this country
172
475701
3768
08:15
that was not 100 percent straight,
173
479469
2401
08:17
which, if you don't know, is a limitless number of people.
174
481870
3183
08:20
(Laughter)
175
485053
2050
08:23
So this was a very large undertaking,
176
487103
2666
08:25
and to do it we needed some help.
177
489769
1884
08:27
So I ran out in the freezing cold,
178
491653
2533
08:30
and I photographed every single person that I knew that I could get to
179
494186
3408
08:33
in February of about two years ago.
180
497594
3970
08:37
And I took those photographs, and I went to the HRC and I asked them for some help.
181
501564
4123
08:41
And they funded two weeks of shooting in New York.
182
505687
2366
08:43
And then we made this.
183
508053
3011
08:46
(Music)
184
511064
12277
08:59
Video: I'm iO Tillett Wright, and I'm an artist born and raised in New York City.
185
523341
4183
09:03
(Music)
186
527524
13308
09:16
Self Evident Truths is a photographic record of LGBTQ America today.
187
540832
4662
09:21
My aim is to take a simple portrait
188
545494
1623
09:23
of anyone who's anything other than 100 percent straight
189
547117
2650
09:25
or feels like they fall in the LGBTQ spectrum in any way.
190
549767
5220
09:30
My goal is to show the humanity that exists in every one of us
191
554987
2998
09:33
through the simplicity of a face.
192
557985
2118
09:36
(Music)
193
560103
2688
09:38
"We hold these truths to be self-evident that all men are created equal."
194
562791
3090
09:41
It's written in the Declaration of Independence.
195
565881
2417
09:44
We are failing as a nation
196
568298
1267
09:45
to uphold the morals upon which we were founded.
197
569565
2109
09:47
There is no equality in the United States.
198
571674
2207
09:49
["What does equality mean to you?"]
199
573896
2383
09:52
["Marriage"] ["Freedom"] ["Civil rights"]
200
576279
1638
09:53
["Treat every person as you'd treat yourself"]
201
577917
2126
09:55
It's when you don't have to think about it, simple as that.
202
580043
3620
09:59
The fight for equal rights is not just about gay marriage.
203
583663
2790
10:02
Today in 29 states, more than half of this country,
204
586453
4096
10:06
you can legally be fired just for your sexuality.
205
590549
4371
10:10
["Who is responsible for equality?"]
206
594920
3151
10:13
I've heard hundreds of people give the same answer:
207
598071
3011
10:16
"We are all responsible for equality."
208
601082
3476
10:20
So far we've shot 300 faces in New York City.
209
604558
2853
10:23
And we wouldn't have been able to do any of it
210
607411
1416
10:24
without the generous support of the Human Rights Campaign.
211
608827
2885
10:27
I want to take the project across the country.
212
611712
1949
10:29
I want to visit 25 American cities, and I want to shoot 4,000 or 5,000 people.
213
613661
4083
10:33
This is my contribution to the civil rights fight of my generation.
214
617744
3983
10:37
I challenge you to look into the faces of these people
215
621727
2177
10:39
and tell them that they deserve less than any other human being.
216
623904
2862
10:42
(Music)
217
626766
2040
10:44
["Self evident truths"]
218
628806
2267
10:46
["4,000 faces across America"]
219
631088
1664
10:48
(Music)
220
632753
4556
10:53
(Applause)
221
637309
8248
11:01
iO Tillett Wright: Absolutely nothing could have prepared us for what happened after that.
222
645557
4283
11:05
Almost 85,000 people watched that video,
223
649840
3250
11:08
and then they started emailing us from all over the country,
224
653090
2500
11:11
asking us to come to their towns and help them to show their faces.
225
655590
4667
11:16
And a lot more people wanted to show their faces than I had anticipated.
226
660257
4350
11:20
So I changed my immediate goal to 10,000 faces.
227
664607
3501
11:24
That video was made in the spring of 2011,
228
668108
4065
11:28
and as of today I have traveled to almost 20 cities
229
672173
3457
11:31
and photographed almost 2,000 people.
230
675630
2906
11:34
I know that this is a talk,
231
678536
3010
11:37
but I'd like to have a minute of just quiet
232
681546
3266
11:40
and have you just look at these faces
233
684812
1249
11:41
because there is nothing that I can say that will add to them.
234
686061
3870
11:45
Because if a picture is worth a thousand words,
235
689931
2533
11:48
then a picture of a face needs a whole new vocabulary.
236
692464
3339
12:12
So after traveling and talking to people
237
717069
3679
12:16
in places like Oklahoma or small-town Texas,
238
720748
3848
12:20
we found evidence that the initial premise was dead on.
239
724596
3535
12:24
Visibility really is key.
240
728131
1886
12:25
Familiarity really is the gateway drug to empathy.
241
730017
3263
12:29
Once an issue pops up in your own backyard or amongst your own family,
242
733280
3450
12:32
you're far more likely to explore sympathy for it
243
736730
2917
12:35
or explore a new perspective on it.
244
739647
1566
12:37
Of course, in my travels I met people
245
741213
2651
12:39
who legally divorced their children for being other than straight,
246
743864
4199
12:43
but I also met people who were Southern Baptists
247
748063
2368
12:46
who switched churches because their child was a lesbian.
248
750431
3016
12:49
Sparking empathy had become the backbone of Self Evident Truths.
249
753447
4150
12:53
But here's what I was starting to learn that was really interesting:
250
757597
3416
12:56
Self Evident Truths doesn't erase the differences between us.
251
761013
4350
13:01
In fact, on the contrary, it highlights them.
252
765363
3384
13:04
It presents, not just the complexities
253
768747
2099
13:06
found in a procession of different human beings,
254
770846
2167
13:08
but the complexities found within each individual person.
255
773013
3600
13:12
It wasn't that we had too many boxes, it was that we had too few.
256
776613
4885
13:23
At some point I realized that my mission to photograph "gays" was inherently flawed,
257
787518
6785
13:30
because there were a million different shades of gay.
258
794303
3188
13:33
Here I was trying to help,
259
797491
2746
13:36
and I had perpetuated the very thing I had spent my life trying to avoid --
260
800237
3193
13:39
yet another box.
261
803430
2506
13:41
At some point I added a question to the release form
262
805936
3220
13:45
that asked people to quantify themselves
263
809156
1929
13:46
on a scale of one to 100 percent gay.
264
811085
2800
13:49
And I watched so many existential crises unfold in front of me.
265
813885
3916
13:53
(Laughter)
266
817801
2801
13:56
People didn't know what to do
267
820602
1200
13:57
because they had never been presented with the option before.
268
821802
2403
14:00
Can you quantify your openness?
269
824205
2187
14:02
Once they got over the shock, though,
270
826392
1910
14:04
by and large people opted for somewhere between 70 to 95 percent
271
828302
4083
14:08
or the 3 to 20 percent marks.
272
832385
2517
14:10
Of course, there were lots of people who opted for a 100 percent one or the other,
273
834902
2701
14:13
but I found that a much larger proportion of people
274
837603
2468
14:15
identified as something that was much more nuanced.
275
840071
2849
14:18
I found that most people fall on a spectrum of what I have come to refer to as "Grey."
276
842920
6209
14:25
Let me be clear though -- and this is very important --
277
849129
3984
14:29
in no way am I saying that preference doesn't exist.
278
853113
4716
14:33
And I am not even going to address the issue of choice versus biological imperative,
279
857829
4800
14:38
because if any of you happen to be of the belief
280
862629
2867
14:41
that sexual orientation is a choice,
281
865496
1867
14:43
I invite you to go out and try to be grey.
282
867363
1533
14:44
I'll take your picture just for trying.
283
868896
2266
14:47
(Laughter)
284
871162
1383
14:48
What I am saying though is that human beings are not one-dimensional.
285
872545
4417
14:52
The most important thing to take from the percentage system is this:
286
876962
5768
14:58
If you have gay people over here
287
882730
2217
15:00
and you have straight people over here,
288
884947
3648
15:04
and while we recognize that most people identify
289
888595
2968
15:07
as somewhere closer to one binary or another,
290
891563
2703
15:10
there is this vast spectrum of people that exist in between.
291
894266
4946
15:15
And the reality that this presents is a complicated one.
292
899212
3034
15:18
Because, for example, if you pass a law
293
902246
2284
15:20
that allows a boss to fire an employee for homosexual behavior,
294
904530
3503
15:23
where exactly do you draw the line?
295
908033
2767
15:26
Is it over here, by the people who have had one or two heterosexual experiences so far?
296
910800
5866
15:32
Or is it over here
297
916666
1301
15:33
by the people who have only had one or two homosexual experiences thus far?
298
917967
4099
15:37
Where exactly does one become a second-class citizen?
299
922066
4650
15:42
Another interesting thing that I learned from my project and my travels
300
926716
4816
15:47
is just what a poor binding agent sexual orientation is.
301
931532
4302
15:51
After traveling so much and meeting so many people,
302
935834
2611
15:54
let me tell you, there are just as many jerks and sweethearts
303
938445
3505
15:57
and Democrats and Republicans and jocks and queens
304
941950
2949
16:00
and every other polarization you can possibly think of
305
944899
2950
16:03
within the LGBT community
306
947849
2134
16:05
as there are within the human race.
307
949983
3516
16:09
Aside from the fact that we play with one legal hand tied behind our backs,
308
953499
4618
16:14
and once you get past the shared narrative of prejudice and struggle,
309
958117
3665
16:17
just being other than straight
310
961782
1401
16:19
doesn't necessarily mean that we have anything in common.
311
963183
5016
16:24
So in the endless proliferation of faces that Self Evident Truths is always becoming,
312
968199
8401
16:32
as it hopefully appears across more and more platforms,
313
976600
3199
16:35
bus shelters, billboards, Facebook pages, screen savers,
314
979799
5459
16:41
perhaps in watching this procession of humanity,
315
985258
3075
16:44
something interesting and useful will begin to happen.
316
988333
2917
16:47
Hopefully these categories, these binaries,
317
991250
3717
16:50
these over-simplified boxes
318
994967
1749
16:52
will begin to become useless and they'll begin to fall away.
319
996716
5066
16:57
Because really, they describe nothing that we see
320
1001782
3418
17:01
and no one that we know and nothing that we are.
321
1005200
3349
17:04
What we see are human beings in all their multiplicity.
322
1008549
5601
17:10
And seeing them makes it harder to deny their humanity.
323
1014150
3583
17:13
At the very least I hope it makes it harder to deny their human rights.
324
1017733
4341
17:17
So is it me particularly
325
1022074
3559
17:21
that you would choose to deny the right to housing,
326
1025633
3502
17:25
the right to adopt children, the right to marriage,
327
1029135
2981
17:28
the freedom to shop here, live here, buy here?
328
1032116
3633
17:31
Am I the one that you choose to disown
329
1035749
2079
17:33
as your child or your brother or your sister or your mother or your father,
330
1037828
4422
17:38
your neighbor, your cousin, your uncle, the president,
331
1042250
2348
17:40
your police woman or the fireman?
332
1044598
3450
17:43
It's too late.
333
1048048
3018
17:46
Because I already am all of those things.
334
1051066
3301
17:50
We already are all of those things, and we always have been.
335
1054367
4365
17:54
So please don't greet us as strangers,
336
1058732
2806
17:57
greet us as your fellow human beings, period.
337
1061538
3553
18:00
Thank you.
338
1065091
1316
18:02
(Applause)
339
1066407
10927
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
iO Tillett Wright - PhotographerAs a child actor, iO Tillett Wright turned his shoes around in the bathroom stall so that people would think he was a boy. As a teenager, he fell in love with both women and men. His life in the gray areas of gender and sexuality deeply inform his work as an artist.
Why you should listen
iO Tillett Wright thanks his parents for not asking him to define himself as a child. His experience of growing up without having check boxes like “female,” “male,” “gay” or straight” thoroughly infuses his art.
iO’s photography can be seen regularly in two features in The New York Times: Notes from the Underground and The Lowdown. He is also the creator of Self Evident Truths—an ongoing project to document the wide variety of experiences in LGBTQ America. So far, he has photographed about 2,000 people for the project. His goal: 10,000 portraits and a nationwide rethinking of discriminatory laws.
iO had his first solo show at Fuse gallery in New York City in 2010, and exhibited his work at The Hole Gallery in early summer of 2012. He has published three books of photographs; Lose My Number, KISSER, and Look Ma’, No Hands. He has directed several music videos, and spent nineteen years acting in films.
iO Tillett Wright | Speaker | TED.com