TEDxSummit
William Noel: Revealing the lost codex of Archimedes
Filmed:
Readability: 3.8
1,033,767 views
How do you read a two-thousand-year-old manuscript that has been erased, cut up, written on and painted over? With a powerful particle accelerator, of course! Ancient books curator William Noel tells the fascinating story behind the Archimedes palimpsest, a Byzantine prayer book containing previously-unknown original writings from ancient Greek mathematician Archimedes and others.
William Noel - Curator, rare book scholar
William Noel is a curator who believes museums should make their collections free and available on the Internet. Full bio
William Noel is a curator who believes museums should make their collections free and available on the Internet. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:16
The great texts of the ancient world
0
471
2484
00:18
don't survive to us in their original form.
1
2955
3315
00:22
They survive because medieval scribes copied them
2
6270
3519
00:25
and copied them and copied them.
3
9789
1999
00:27
And so it is with Archimedes,
4
11788
2650
00:30
the great Greek mathematician.
5
14438
1766
00:32
Everything we know about Archimedes as a mathematician
6
16204
3002
00:35
we know about because of just three books,
7
19206
2698
00:37
and they're called A, B and C.
8
21904
1916
00:39
And A was lost by an Italian humanist in 1564.
9
23820
4833
00:44
And B was last heard of in the Pope's Library
10
28653
2803
00:47
about a hundred miles north of Rome in Viterbo in 1311.
11
31456
5832
00:53
Now Codex C was only discovered in 1906,
12
37288
4297
00:57
and it landed on my desk in Baltimore
13
41585
2549
01:00
on the 19th of January, 1999.
14
44134
4126
01:04
And this is Codex C here.
15
48260
2418
01:06
Now Codex C is actually buried in this book.
16
50678
5169
01:11
It's buried treasure.
17
55847
1450
01:13
Because this book is actually a prayer book.
18
57297
2335
01:15
It was finished by a guy called Johannes Myrones
19
59632
2964
01:18
on the 14th of April, 1229.
20
62596
3617
01:22
And to make his prayer book he used parchment.
21
66213
2485
01:24
But he didn't use new parchment,
22
68698
2415
01:27
he used parchment recycled from earlier manuscripts,
23
71113
3314
01:30
and there were seven of them.
24
74427
1737
01:32
And Archimedes Codex C was just one of those seven.
25
76164
3483
01:35
He took apart the Archimedes manuscript and the other seven manuscripts.
26
79647
5467
01:41
He erased all of their texts,
27
85114
3383
01:44
and then he cut the sheets down in the middle,
28
88497
2418
01:46
he shuffled them up,
29
90915
2244
01:49
and he rotated them 90 degrees,
30
93159
1918
01:50
and he wrote prayers on top of these books.
31
95077
2052
01:53
And essentially these seven manuscripts
32
97129
1697
01:54
disappeared for 700 years, and we have a prayer book.
33
98826
4348
01:59
The prayer book was discovered by this guy,
34
103174
3249
02:02
Johan Ludvig Heiberg, in 1906.
35
106423
2727
02:05
And with just a magnifying glass,
36
109150
1441
02:06
he transcribed as much of the text as he could.
37
110591
2884
02:09
And the thing is that he found two texts in this manuscript
38
113475
3182
02:12
that were unique texts.
39
116657
1768
02:14
They weren't in A and B at all;
40
118425
1600
02:15
they were completely new texts by Archimedes,
41
120025
1698
02:17
and they were called "The Method" and "The Stomachion."
42
121723
3235
02:20
And it became a world famous manuscript.
43
124958
2269
02:23
Now it should be clear by now
44
127227
1815
02:24
that this book is in bad condition.
45
129042
2714
02:27
It got in worse condition in the 20th century
46
131756
3470
02:31
after Heiberg saw it.
47
135226
1732
02:32
Forgeries were painted over it,
48
136958
1517
02:34
and it suffered very badly from mold.
49
138475
3083
02:37
This book is the definition of a write-off.
50
141558
3750
02:41
It's the sort of book
51
145308
1734
02:42
that you thought would be in an institution.
52
147042
2665
02:45
But it's not in an institution,
53
149707
2186
02:47
it was bought by a private owner in 1998.
54
151893
4632
02:52
Why did he buy this book?
55
156525
1750
02:54
Because he wanted to make that which was fragile safe.
56
158275
3537
02:57
He wanted to make that which was unique ubiquitous.
57
161812
3246
03:00
He wanted to make that which was expensive free.
58
165058
4666
03:05
And he wanted to do this as a matter of principle.
59
169724
3135
03:08
Because not many people are really going to read Archimedes in ancient Greek,
60
172859
4532
03:13
but they should have the chance to do it.
61
177391
2684
03:15
So he gathered around himself the friends of Archimedes,
62
180075
3299
03:19
and he promised to pay for all the work.
63
183374
2136
03:21
And it was an expensive job,
64
185510
1698
03:23
but actually it wouldn't be as much as you think
65
187208
3470
03:26
because these people, they didn't come from money,
66
190678
2165
03:28
they came from Archimedes.
67
192843
1819
03:30
And they came from all sorts of different backgrounds.
68
194662
1716
03:32
They came from particle physics,
69
196378
2183
03:34
they came from classical philology,
70
198561
1566
03:36
they came from book conservation,
71
200127
1968
03:37
they came from ancient mathematics,
72
202095
2582
03:40
they came from data management,
73
204677
1917
03:42
they came from scientific imaging and program management.
74
206594
2917
03:45
And they got together to work on this manuscript.
75
209511
3556
03:48
The first problem was a conservation problem.
76
213067
3811
03:52
And this is the sort of thing that we had to deal with:
77
216878
2433
03:55
There was glue on the spine of the book.
78
219311
2200
03:57
And if you look at this photograph carefully,
79
221511
2201
03:59
the bottom half of this is rather brown.
80
223712
2048
04:01
And that glue is hide glue.
81
225760
1368
04:03
Now if you're a conservator,
82
227128
1385
04:04
you can take off this glue reasonably easily.
83
228513
2132
04:06
The top half is Elmer's wood glue.
84
230645
3365
04:09
It's polyvinyl acetate emulsion
85
234010
2117
04:12
that doesn't dissolve in water once it's dry.
86
236127
2667
04:14
And it's much tougher than the parchment that it was written on.
87
238794
3166
04:17
And so before we could start imaging Archimedes,
88
241960
3351
04:21
we had to take this book apart.
89
245311
1449
04:22
So it took four years to take apart.
90
246760
2851
04:25
And this is a rare action shot, ladies and gentlemen.
91
249611
3533
04:29
(Laughter)
92
253144
2771
04:31
Another thing is that we had to get rid of all the wax,
93
255915
4266
04:36
because this was used in the liturgical services
94
260181
2235
04:38
of the Greek Orthodox Church
95
262416
1741
04:40
and they'd used candle wax.
96
264157
1311
04:41
And the candle wax was dirty,
97
265468
1863
04:43
and we couldn't image through the wax.
98
267331
1233
04:44
So very carefully we had to mechanically scrape off all the wax.
99
268564
3335
04:47
It's hard to tell you exactly
100
271899
1902
04:49
how bad this condition of this book is,
101
273801
2714
04:52
but it came out in little bits very often.
102
276515
2766
04:55
And normally in a book, you wouldn't worry about the little bits,
103
279281
2350
04:57
but these little bits might contain unique Archimedes text.
104
281631
3000
05:00
So, tiny fragments
105
284631
2299
05:02
we actually managed to put back in the right place.
106
286930
4741
05:07
Then, having done that, we started to image the manuscript.
107
291671
3710
05:11
And we imaged the manuscript
108
295381
1500
05:12
in 14 different wavebands of light.
109
296881
2028
05:14
Because if you look at something in different wavebands of light,
110
298909
3906
05:18
you see different things.
111
302815
1216
05:19
And here is an image of a page
112
304031
1567
05:21
imaged in 14 different wavebands of light.
113
305598
2517
05:24
But none of them worked.
114
308115
2133
05:26
So what we did was we processed the images together,
115
310248
4417
05:30
and we put two images into one blank screen.
116
314665
3300
05:33
And here are two different images of the Archimedes manuscript.
117
317965
2833
05:36
And the image on the left
118
320798
1816
05:38
is the normal red image.
119
322614
1351
05:39
And the image on the right is an ultraviolet image.
120
323965
1912
05:41
And in the image on the right
121
325877
1140
05:42
you might be able to see some of the Archimedes writing.
122
327017
2448
05:45
If you merge them together into one digital canvas,
123
329465
2982
05:48
the parchment is bright in both images
124
332447
2818
05:51
and it comes out bright.
125
335265
1875
05:53
The prayer book is dark in both images
126
337140
3016
05:56
and it comes out dark.
127
340156
1697
05:57
The Archimedes text is dark in one image and bright in another.
128
341853
3351
06:01
And it'll come out dark but red,
129
345204
2400
06:03
and then you can start to read it rather clearly.
130
347604
2267
06:05
And that's what it looks like.
131
349871
2842
06:08
Now that's a before and after image,
132
352713
3342
06:11
but you don't read the image on the screen like that.
133
356055
2982
06:14
You zoom in and you zoom in
134
359037
2619
06:17
and you zoom in and you zoom in,
135
361656
3548
06:21
and you can just read it now.
136
365204
2068
06:23
(Applause)
137
367272
6348
06:29
If you process the same two images in a different way,
138
373620
3580
06:33
you can actually get rid of the prayer book text.
139
377200
2570
06:35
And this is terribly important,
140
379770
1018
06:36
because the diagrams in the manuscript
141
380788
2983
06:39
are the unique source for the diagrams
142
383771
2467
06:42
that Archimedes drew in the sand in the fourth century B.C.
143
386238
2817
06:44
And there we are, I can give them to you.
144
389055
3039
06:47
With this kind of imaging --
145
392094
2344
06:50
this kind of infrared, ultraviolet, invisible light imaging --
146
394438
2666
06:53
we were never going to image through the gold ground forgeries.
147
397104
2600
06:55
How were we going to do that?
148
399704
1853
06:57
Well we took the manuscript,
149
401557
1963
06:59
and we decided to image it in X-ray fluorescence imaging.
150
403520
4287
07:03
So an X-ray comes in in the diagram on the left
151
407807
3014
07:06
and it knocks out an electron from the inner shell of an atom.
152
410821
3852
07:10
And that electron disappears.
153
414673
1998
07:12
And as it disappears, an electron from a shell farther out
154
416671
3635
07:16
jumps in and takes its place.
155
420306
2482
07:18
And when it takes its place,
156
422788
1433
07:20
it sheds electromagnetic radiation.
157
424221
2834
07:22
It sheds an X-ray.
158
427055
1432
07:24
And this X-ray is specific in its wavelength
159
428487
2651
07:27
to the atom that it hits.
160
431138
1882
07:28
And what we wanted to get
161
433020
2168
07:31
was the iron.
162
435188
1733
07:32
Because the ink was written in iron.
163
436921
1867
07:34
And if we can map
164
438788
1683
07:36
where this X-ray that comes out, where it comes from,
165
440471
2584
07:38
we can map all the iron on the page,
166
443055
2066
07:41
then theoretically we can read the image.
167
445121
2599
07:43
The thing is that you need a very powerful light source to do this.
168
447720
4335
07:47
So we took it to the Stanford Synchrotron Radiation Laboratory
169
452055
3374
07:51
in California,
170
455429
1442
07:52
which is a particle accelerator.
171
456871
1568
07:54
Electrons go around one way,
172
458439
1732
07:56
positrons go around the other.
173
460171
1617
07:57
They meet in the middle,
174
461788
1316
07:59
and they create subatomic particles
175
463104
2436
08:01
like the charm quark and the tau lepton.
176
465540
2230
08:03
Now we weren't actually going to put Archimedes in that beam.
177
467770
3022
08:06
But as the electrons go round at the speed of light,
178
470792
3548
08:10
they shed X-rays.
179
474340
1267
08:11
And this is the most powerful light source in the solar system.
180
475607
2650
08:14
This is called synchrotron radiation,
181
478257
1949
08:16
and it's normally used to look at things
182
480206
1818
08:17
like proteins and that sort of thing.
183
482024
1667
08:19
But we wanted it to look at atoms, at iron atoms,
184
483691
3997
08:23
so that we could read the page from before and after.
185
487688
2869
08:26
And lo and behold, we found that we could do it.
186
490557
2298
08:28
It took about 17 minutes to do a single page.
187
492855
3448
08:32
So what did we discover?
188
496303
2655
08:34
Well one of the unique texts in Archimedes
189
498958
2182
08:37
is called "The Stomachion."
190
501140
1803
08:38
And this didn't exist in Codices A and B.
191
502943
2414
08:41
And we knew that it involved this square.
192
505357
2419
08:43
And this is a perfect square,
193
507776
1793
08:45
and it's divided into 14 bits.
194
509569
2021
08:47
But no one knew what Archimedes was doing with these 14 bits.
195
511590
2783
08:50
And now we think we know.
196
514373
2184
08:52
He was trying to work out
197
516557
1767
08:54
how many ways you can recombine those 14 bits
198
518324
2533
08:56
and still make a perfect square.
199
520857
2327
08:59
Anyone want to guess the answer?
200
523184
3502
09:02
It's 17,152 divided into 536 families.
201
526686
5362
09:07
And the important point about this
202
532048
2367
09:10
is that it's the earliest study in combinatorics in mathematics.
203
534415
3714
09:14
And combinatorics is a wonderful and interesting branch of mathematics.
204
538129
3764
09:17
The really astonishing thing though about this manuscript
205
541893
3235
09:21
is that we looked at the other manuscripts
206
545128
2369
09:23
that the palimpsester had made,
207
547497
1418
09:24
the scribe had made his book out of,
208
548915
2566
09:27
and one of them was a manuscript containing text by Hyperides.
209
551481
2932
09:30
Now Hyperides was an Athenian orator from the fourth century B.C.
210
554413
4368
09:34
He was an exact contemporary of Demosthenes.
211
558781
2417
09:37
And in 338 B.C. he and Demosthenes together
212
561198
4399
09:41
decided that they wanted to stand up
213
565597
1684
09:43
to the military might of Philip of Macedon.
214
567281
2000
09:45
So Athens and Thebes went out to fight Philip of Macedon.
215
569281
3649
09:48
This was a bad idea,
216
572930
1268
09:50
because Philip of Macedon had a son called Alexander the Great,
217
574198
3433
09:53
and they lost the battle of Chaeronea.
218
577631
2283
09:55
Alexander the Great went on to conquer the known world;
219
579914
2718
09:58
Hyperides found himself on trial for treason.
220
582632
2750
10:01
And this is the speech that he gave when he was on trial --
221
585382
3600
10:04
and it's a great speech:
222
588982
1148
10:06
"Best of all," he says, "is to win.
223
590130
2268
10:08
But if you can't win,
224
592398
1734
10:10
then you should fight for a noble cause,
225
594132
2041
10:12
because then you'll be remembered.
226
596173
1575
10:13
Consider the Spartans.
227
597748
1598
10:15
They won enumerable victories,
228
599346
1868
10:17
but no one remembers what they are
229
601214
1832
10:18
because they were all fought for selfish ends.
230
603046
2135
10:21
The one battle that the Spartans fought that everybody remembers
231
605181
3566
10:24
is the the battle of Thermopylae
232
608747
1716
10:26
where they were butchered to a man,
233
610463
2003
10:28
but fought for the freedom of Greece."
234
612466
1932
10:30
It was such a great speech
235
614398
2265
10:32
that the Athenian law courts let him off.
236
616663
3735
10:36
He lived for another 10 years,
237
620398
2066
10:38
then the Macedonian faction caught up with him.
238
622464
2651
10:41
They cut out his tongue in mockery of his oratory,
239
625115
2584
10:43
and no one knows what they did with his body.
240
627699
3431
10:47
So this is the discovery of a lost voice from antiquity,
241
631130
3151
10:50
speaking to us, not from the grave,
242
634281
1982
10:52
because his grave doesn't exist,
243
636263
1478
10:53
but from the Athenian law courts.
244
637741
1773
10:55
Now I should say at this point
245
639514
1649
10:57
that normally when you're looking
246
641163
2767
10:59
at medieval manuscripts that have been scraped off,
247
643930
1996
11:01
you don't find unique texts.
248
645926
1486
11:03
And to find two in one manuscript is really something.
249
647412
3102
11:06
To find three is completely weird.
250
650514
3217
11:09
And we found three.
251
653731
1681
11:11
Aristotle's "Categories"
252
655412
1266
11:12
is one of the foundational texts of Western philosophy.
253
656678
2453
11:15
And we found a third century A.D. commentary on it,
254
659131
4416
11:19
possibly by Galen and probably by Porphyry.
255
663547
3184
11:22
Now all this data that we collected,
256
666731
2198
11:24
all the images, all the raw images,
257
668929
2535
11:27
all the transcriptions that we made and that sort of thing
258
671464
2350
11:29
have been put online under a Creative Commons license
259
673814
3486
11:33
for anyone to use for any commercial purpose.
260
677300
2914
11:36
(Applause)
261
680214
6533
11:42
Why did the owner of the manuscript do this?
262
686747
3304
11:45
He did this because he understands data as well as books.
263
690051
3746
11:49
Now the thing to do with books,
264
693797
1335
11:51
if you want to ensure their long-term utility,
265
695132
2131
11:53
is to hide them away in closets
266
697263
2216
11:55
and let very few people look at them.
267
699479
1800
11:57
The thing to do with data, if you want it to survive,
268
701279
2419
11:59
is to let it out and have everybody have it
269
703698
3301
12:02
with as little control on that data as possible.
270
706999
3099
12:05
And that's what he did.
271
710098
1164
12:07
And institutions can learn from this.
272
711262
3428
12:10
Because institutions at the moment
273
714690
2552
12:13
confine their data with copyright restrictions and that sort of thing.
274
717242
3057
12:16
And if you want to look at medieval manuscripts on the Web,
275
720299
2192
12:18
at the moment you have to go to the National Library of Y's site
276
722491
3471
12:21
or the University Library of X's site,
277
725962
2668
12:24
which is about the most boring way
278
728630
1899
12:26
in which you can deal with digital data.
279
730529
1777
12:28
What you want to do is to aggregate it all together.
280
732306
2993
12:31
Because the Web of the ancient manuscripts of the future
281
735299
3097
12:34
isn't going to be built by institutions.
282
738396
2286
12:36
It's going to be built by users,
283
740682
3108
12:39
by people who get this data together,
284
743790
1774
12:41
by people who want to aggregate all sorts of maps
285
745564
3535
12:44
from wherever they come from,
286
749099
1632
12:46
all sorts of medieval romances
287
750731
1800
12:48
from wherever they come from,
288
752531
1549
12:49
people who just want to curate their own glorious selection
289
754080
3783
12:53
of beautiful things.
290
757863
1517
12:55
And that is the future of the Web.
291
759380
1617
12:56
And it's an attractive and beautiful future,
292
760997
3183
13:00
if only we can make it happen.
293
764180
1602
13:01
Now we at the Walters Art Museum have followed this example,
294
765782
3181
13:04
and we have put up all our manuscripts on the Web
295
768963
3350
13:08
for people to enjoy --
296
772313
1683
13:09
all the raw data, all the descriptions, all the metadata.
297
773996
2584
13:12
under a Creative Commons license.
298
776580
2883
13:15
Now the Walters Art Museum is a small museum
299
779463
1518
13:16
and it has beautiful manuscripts,
300
780981
1548
13:18
but the data is fantastic.
301
782529
2018
13:20
And the result of this
302
784547
1783
13:22
is that if you do a Google search on images right now
303
786330
3018
13:25
and you type in "Illuminated manuscript Koran" for example,
304
789348
3332
13:28
24 of the 28 images you'll find come from my institution.
305
792680
4417
13:32
(Applause)
306
797097
5550
13:38
Now, let's think about this for a minute.
307
802647
5033
13:43
What's in it for the institution?
308
807680
1983
13:45
There are all sorts of things that are in it for the institution.
309
809663
2596
13:48
You can talk about the Humanities and that sort of thing,
310
812259
2123
13:50
but let's talk about selfish things.
311
814382
1881
13:52
Because what's really in it for the institution is this:
312
816263
3868
13:56
Now why do people go to the Louvre?
313
820131
3056
13:59
They go to see the Mona Lisa.
314
823187
2984
14:02
Why do they go to see the Mona Lisa?
315
826171
3059
14:05
Because they already know what she looks like.
316
829230
2382
14:07
And they know what she looks like
317
831612
2334
14:09
because they've seen pictures of her absolutely everywhere.
318
833946
4702
14:14
Now, there is no need
319
838648
4449
14:18
for these restrictions at all.
320
843097
2279
14:21
And I think that institutions should stand up
321
845376
2087
14:23
and release all their data under unrestricted licenses,
322
847463
3134
14:26
and it would be a great benefit to everybody.
323
850597
2216
14:28
Why don't we just let everybody have access to this data
324
852813
3166
14:31
and curate their own collection
325
855979
2336
14:34
of ancient knowledge and wonderful and beautiful things
326
858315
2165
14:36
and increase the beauty and the cultural significance
327
860480
3088
14:39
of the Internet.
328
863568
1228
14:40
Thank you very much indeed.
329
864796
1517
14:42
(Applause)
330
866313
4433
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
William Noel - Curator, rare book scholarWilliam Noel is a curator who believes museums should make their collections free and available on the Internet.
Why you should listen
William Noel is the Curator of Manuscripts and Rare Books at the Walters Art Museum. But for someone who spends the majority of his time analyzing ancient and medieval artifacts, he also embraces social media and stresses its value even for the oldest, most established academic and cultural institutions. Noel believes passionately that institutions should free their digital data.
Since 1999 Noel has spearheaded the conservation of a manuscript known as the Archimedes Palimpsest. The palimpsest is a unique Byzantine prayer book made up of parchments which contain hidden writings from three original previously-unknown texts: treatises written by Archimedes; works by the 4th-century B.C. Attic Orator Hyperides; and 3rd-century commentary on Aristotle’s Categories, by an unknown author. Using a powerful particle accelerator Noel and his team were able to uncover the hidden texts and publish all their images and findings on the Internet, available to anyone for free under a Creative Commons license.
Noel currently lives in Baltimore, Maryland, where he curates at the Walters, working to ensure that the public has free digital access to his collection.
William Noel | Speaker | TED.com