TEDxCERN
John Searle: Our shared condition -- consciousness
Filmed:
Readability: 4.3
1,460,625 views
Philosopher John Searle lays out the case for studying human consciousness -- and systematically shoots down some of the common objections to taking it seriously. As we learn more about the brain processes that cause awareness, accepting that consciousness is a biological phenomenon is an important first step. And no, he says, consciousness is not a massive computer simulation.
John Searle - Philosopher
John Searle has made countless contributions to contemporary thinking about consciousness, language, artificial intelligence and rationality itself. Full bio
John Searle has made countless contributions to contemporary thinking about consciousness, language, artificial intelligence and rationality itself. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
I'm going to talk about consciousness.
0
464
2617
00:15
Why consciousness?
1
3081
1480
00:16
Well, it's a curiously neglected subject,
2
4561
2826
00:19
both in our scientific and our philosophical culture.
3
7387
3564
00:22
Now why is that curious?
4
10951
1272
00:24
Well, it is the most important aspect of our lives
5
12223
3510
00:27
for a very simple, logical reason,
6
15733
1958
00:29
namely, it's a necessary condition on anything
7
17691
2397
00:32
being important in our lives that we're conscious.
8
20088
2477
00:34
You care about science, philosophy, music, art, whatever --
9
22565
3159
00:37
it's no good if you're a zombie or in a coma, right?
10
25724
3478
00:41
So consciousness is number one.
11
29202
2344
00:43
The second reason is that when people do
12
31546
2468
00:46
get interested in it, as I think they should,
13
34014
2316
00:48
they tend to say the most appalling things.
14
36330
2851
00:51
And then, even when they're not saying appalling things
15
39181
2159
00:53
and they're really trying to do serious research,
16
41340
2129
00:55
well, it's been slow. Progress has been slow.
17
43469
3855
00:59
When I first got interested in this, I thought, well,
18
47324
3140
01:02
it's a straightforward problem in biology.
19
50464
2206
01:04
Let's get these brain stabbers to get busy and figure out
20
52670
2497
01:07
how it works in the brain.
21
55167
884
01:08
So I went over to UCSF and I talked to all
22
56051
1902
01:09
the heavy-duty neurobiologists there,
23
57953
1915
01:11
and they showed some impatience,
24
59868
1576
01:13
as scientists often do when you ask them embarrassing questions.
25
61444
3383
01:16
But the thing that struck me is, one guy said in exasperation,
26
64827
3758
01:20
a very famous neurobiologist, he said, "Look,
27
68585
2015
01:22
in my discipline it's okay to be interested in consciousness,
28
70600
3575
01:26
but get tenure first. Get tenure first."
29
74175
3567
01:29
Now I've been working on this for a long time.
30
77742
2718
01:32
I think now you might actually get tenure
31
80460
1978
01:34
by working on consciousness.
32
82438
1291
01:35
If so, that's a real step forward.
33
83729
2613
01:38
Okay, now why then is this curious reluctance
34
86342
2905
01:41
and curious hostility to consciousness?
35
89247
1898
01:43
Well, I think it's a combination of two features
36
91145
2730
01:45
of our intellectual culture
37
93875
1905
01:47
that like to think they're opposing each other
38
95780
2526
01:50
but in fact they share a common set of assumptions.
39
98306
3623
01:53
One feature is the tradition of religious dualism:
40
101929
3962
01:57
Consciousness is not a part of the physical world.
41
105891
3325
02:01
It's a part of the spiritual world.
42
109216
1927
02:03
It belongs to the soul,
43
111143
1536
02:04
and the soul is not a part of the physical world.
44
112679
3296
02:07
That's the tradition of God, the soul and immortality.
45
115975
3031
02:11
There's another tradition that thinks it's opposed to this
46
119006
2105
02:13
but accepts the worst assumption.
47
121111
2104
02:15
That tradition thinks that we are heavy-duty scientific materialists:
48
123215
4078
02:19
Consciousness is not a part of the physical world.
49
127293
3465
02:22
Either it doesn't exist at all, or it's something else,
50
130758
2646
02:25
a computer program or some damn fool thing,
51
133404
2650
02:28
but in any case it's not part of science.
52
136054
3195
02:31
And I used to get in an argument that really gave me a stomachache.
53
139249
2208
02:33
Here's how it went.
54
141457
1619
02:35
Science is objective, consciousness is subjective,
55
143076
4032
02:39
therefore there cannot be a science of consciousness.
56
147108
3327
02:42
Okay, so these twin traditions are paralyzing us.
57
150435
6504
02:48
It's very hard to get out of these twin traditions.
58
156939
2868
02:51
And I have only one real message in this lecture,
59
159807
3018
02:54
and that is, consciousness is a biological phenomenon
60
162825
3384
02:58
like photosynthesis, digestion, mitosis --
61
166209
2889
03:01
you know all the biological phenomena -- and once you accept that,
62
169098
4335
03:05
most, though not all, of the hard problems
63
173433
2639
03:08
about consciousness simply evaporate.
64
176072
2275
03:10
And I'm going to go through some of them.
65
178347
2053
03:12
Okay, now I promised you to tell you some
66
180400
2333
03:14
of the outrageous things said about consciousness.
67
182733
2739
03:17
One: Consciousness does not exist.
68
185472
3600
03:21
It's an illusion, like sunsets.
69
189072
2230
03:23
Science has shown sunsets and rainbows are illusions.
70
191302
5065
03:28
So consciousness is an illusion.
71
196367
1923
03:30
Two: Well, maybe it exists, but it's really something else.
72
198290
3255
03:33
It's a computer program running in the brain.
73
201545
3781
03:37
Three: No, the only thing that exists is really behavior.
74
205326
3814
03:41
It's embarrassing how influential behaviorism was,
75
209140
3608
03:44
but I'll get back to that.
76
212748
1355
03:46
And four: Maybe consciousness exists,
77
214103
2734
03:48
but it can't make any difference to the world.
78
216837
2143
03:50
How could spirituality move anything?
79
218980
2792
03:53
Now, whenever somebody tells me that, I think,
80
221772
1795
03:55
you want to see spirituality move something?
81
223567
2290
03:57
Watch. I decide consciously to raise my arm,
82
225857
3272
04:01
and the damn thing goes up. (Laughter)
83
229129
2609
04:03
Furthermore, notice this:
84
231738
3771
04:07
We do not say, "Well, it's a bit like the weather in Geneva.
85
235509
3995
04:11
Some days it goes up and some days it doesn't go up."
86
239504
2648
04:14
No. It goes up whenever I damn well want it to.
87
242152
2655
04:16
Okay. I'm going to tell you how that's possible.
88
244807
2038
04:18
Now, I haven't yet given you a definition.
89
246845
3771
04:22
You can't do this if you don't give a definition.
90
250616
2252
04:24
People always say consciousness is very hard to define.
91
252868
3092
04:27
I think it's rather easy to define
92
255960
1883
04:29
if you're not trying to give a scientific definition.
93
257843
2209
04:32
We're not ready for a scientific definition,
94
260052
2280
04:34
but here's a common-sense definition.
95
262332
1739
04:36
Consciousness consists of all those states of feeling
96
264071
2849
04:38
or sentience or awareness.
97
266920
2068
04:40
It begins in the morning when you wake up from a dreamless sleep,
98
268988
3558
04:44
and it goes on all day until you fall asleep
99
272546
2469
04:47
or die or otherwise become unconscious.
100
275015
3198
04:50
Dreams are a form of consciousness on this definition.
101
278213
3120
04:53
Now, that's the common-sense definition. That's our target.
102
281333
2902
04:56
If you're not talking about that, you're not talking about consciousness.
103
284235
3485
04:59
But they think, "Well, if that's it, that's an awful problem.
104
287720
3500
05:03
How can such a thing exist as part of the real world?"
105
291220
3958
05:07
And this, if you've ever had a philosophy course,
106
295178
1890
05:09
this is known as the famous mind-body problem.
107
297068
3219
05:12
I think that has a simple solution too. I'm going to give it to you.
108
300287
2845
05:15
And here it is: All of our conscious states, without exception,
109
303132
4420
05:19
are caused by lower-level neurobiological processes in the brain,
110
307552
5525
05:25
and they are realized in the brain
111
313077
2181
05:27
as higher-level or system features.
112
315258
2334
05:29
It's about as mysterious as the liquidity of water.
113
317592
3156
05:32
Right? The liquidity is not an extra juice squirted out
114
320748
3475
05:36
by the H2O molecules.
115
324223
1690
05:37
It's a condition that the system is in.
116
325913
2878
05:40
And just as the jar full of water can go from liquid to solid
117
328791
5162
05:45
depending on the behavior of the molecules,
118
333953
1953
05:47
so your brain can go from a state of being conscious
119
335906
2996
05:50
to a state of being unconscious,
120
338902
1640
05:52
depending on the behavior of the molecules.
121
340542
2986
05:55
The famous mind-body problem is that simple.
122
343528
4385
05:59
All right? But now we get into some harder questions.
123
347913
3177
06:03
Let's specify the exact features of consciousness,
124
351090
3444
06:06
so that we can then answer those four objections
125
354534
2472
06:09
that I made to it.
126
357006
1287
06:10
Well, the first feature is, it's real and irreducible.
127
358293
4267
06:14
You can't get rid of it.
128
362560
2054
06:16
You see, the distinction between reality and illusion
129
364614
4171
06:20
is the distinction between how things
130
368785
2669
06:23
consciously seem to us and how they really are.
131
371454
3874
06:27
It consciously seems like there's --
132
375328
1876
06:29
I like the French "arc-en-ciel" —
133
377204
1668
06:30
it seems like there's an arch in the sky,
134
378872
2198
06:33
or it seems like the sun is setting over the mountains.
135
381070
3780
06:36
It consciously seems to us, but that's not really happening.
136
384850
3097
06:39
But for that distinction between
137
387947
1927
06:41
how things consciously seem and how they really are,
138
389874
2465
06:44
you can't make that distinction for the very existence of consciousness,
139
392339
4091
06:48
because where the very existence of consciousness is concerned,
140
396430
3851
06:52
if it consciously seems to you that you are conscious,
141
400281
2980
06:55
you are conscious.
142
403261
1885
06:57
I mean, if a bunch of experts come to me and say,
143
405146
3354
07:00
"We are heavy-duty neurobiologists and we've done a study
144
408500
2286
07:02
of you, Searle, and we're convinced you are not conscious,
145
410786
3155
07:05
you are a very cleverly constructed robot,"
146
413941
2028
07:07
I don't think, "Well, maybe these guys are right, you know?"
147
415969
3313
07:11
I don't think that for a moment, because, I mean,
148
419282
2563
07:13
Descartes may have made a lot of mistakes, but he was right about this.
149
421845
2910
07:16
You cannot doubt the existence of your own consciousness.
150
424755
2955
07:19
Okay, that's the first feature of consciousness.
151
427710
2173
07:21
It's real and irreducible.
152
429883
1941
07:23
You cannot get rid of it by showing that it's an illusion
153
431824
3231
07:27
in a way that you can with other standard illusions.
154
435055
3229
07:30
Okay, the second feature is this one
155
438284
2532
07:32
that has been such a source of trouble to us,
156
440816
2465
07:35
and that is, all of our conscious states
157
443281
2182
07:37
have this qualitative character to them.
158
445463
2964
07:40
There's something that it feels like to drink beer
159
448427
2396
07:42
which is not what it feels like to do your income tax
160
450823
2954
07:45
or listen to music, and this qualitative feel
161
453777
3068
07:48
automatically generates a third feature,
162
456845
2561
07:51
namely, conscious states are by definition subjective
163
459406
3794
07:55
in the sense that they only exist as experienced
164
463200
2955
07:58
by some human or animal subject,
165
466155
2195
08:00
some self that experiences them.
166
468350
1873
08:02
Maybe we'll be able to build a conscious machine.
167
470223
2383
08:04
Since we don't know how our brains do it,
168
472606
2153
08:06
we're not in a position, so far, to build a conscious machine.
169
474759
4135
08:10
Okay. Another feature of consciousness
170
478894
2775
08:13
is that it comes in unified conscious fields.
171
481669
4151
08:17
So I don't just have the sight of the people in front of me
172
485820
2356
08:20
and the sound of my voice and the weight of my shoes
173
488176
2714
08:22
against the floor, but they occur to me
174
490890
2175
08:25
as part of one single great conscious field
175
493065
3482
08:28
that stretches forward and backward.
176
496547
2016
08:30
That is the key to understanding
177
498563
1769
08:32
the enormous power of consciousness.
178
500332
2439
08:34
And we have not been able to do that in a robot.
179
502771
2944
08:37
The disappointment of robotics derives from the fact
180
505715
2388
08:40
that we don't know how to make a conscious robot,
181
508103
2012
08:42
so we don't have a machine that can do this kind of thing.
182
510115
3508
08:45
Okay, the next feature of consciousness,
183
513623
2509
08:48
after this marvelous unified conscious field,
184
516132
3115
08:51
is that it functions causally in our behavior.
185
519247
2792
08:54
I gave you a scientific demonstration by raising my hand,
186
522039
3203
08:57
but how is that possible?
187
525242
1750
08:58
How can it be that this thought in my brain
188
526992
3764
09:02
can move material objects?
189
530756
2200
09:04
Well, I'll tell you the answer.
190
532956
1366
09:06
I mean, we don't know the detailed answer,
191
534322
1771
09:08
but we know the basic part of the answer, and that is,
192
536093
3090
09:11
there is a sequence of neuron firings,
193
539183
2293
09:13
and they terminate where the acetylcholine
194
541476
3087
09:16
is secreted at the axon end-plates of the motor neurons.
195
544563
2821
09:19
Sorry to use philosophical terminology here,
196
547384
2075
09:21
but when it's secreted at the axon end-plates of the motor neurons,
197
549459
4016
09:25
a whole lot of wonderful things happen in the ion channels
198
553475
2598
09:28
and the damned arm goes up.
199
556073
2094
09:30
Now, think of what I told you.
200
558167
2124
09:32
One and the same event,
201
560291
1742
09:34
my conscious decision to raise my arm
202
562033
3035
09:37
has a level of description where it has all of these
203
565068
2795
09:39
touchy-feely spiritual qualities.
204
567863
2146
09:42
It's a thought in my brain, but at the same time,
205
570009
2401
09:44
it's busy secreting acetylcholine
206
572410
1986
09:46
and doing all sorts of other things
207
574396
1535
09:47
as it makes its way from the motor cortex
208
575931
2788
09:50
down through the nerve fibers in the arm.
209
578719
2697
09:53
Now, what that tells us is that our traditional vocabularies
210
581416
3816
09:57
for discussing these issues are totally obsolete.
211
585232
3384
10:00
One and the same event has a level of description
212
588616
3257
10:03
where it's neurobiological, and another level of description
213
591873
2966
10:06
where it's mental, and that's a single event,
214
594839
2191
10:09
and that's how nature works. That's how it's possible
215
597030
2110
10:11
for consciousness to function causally.
216
599140
3031
10:14
Okay, now with that in mind,
217
602171
2859
10:17
with going through these various features of consciousness,
218
605030
3067
10:20
let's go back and answer some of those early objections.
219
608097
3172
10:23
Well, the first one I said was, consciousness doesn't exist,
220
611269
3609
10:26
it's an illusion. Well, I've already answered that.
221
614878
1834
10:28
I don't think we need to worry about that.
222
616712
1516
10:30
But the second one had an incredible influence,
223
618228
3864
10:34
and may still be around, and that is,
224
622092
1844
10:35
"Well, if consciousness exists, it's really something else.
225
623936
3191
10:39
It's really a digital computer program running in your brain
226
627127
3763
10:42
and that's what we need to do to create consciousness
227
630890
2505
10:45
is get the right program.
228
633395
1496
10:46
Yeah, forget about the hardware. Any hardware will do
229
634891
2239
10:49
provided it's rich enough and stable enough to carry the program."
230
637130
2960
10:52
Now, we know that that's wrong.
231
640090
3074
10:55
I mean, anybody who's thought about computers at all
232
643164
3009
10:58
can see that that's wrong, because computation
233
646173
2464
11:00
is defined as symbol manipulation,
234
648637
2415
11:03
usually thought of as zeros as ones, but any symbols will do.
235
651052
2884
11:05
You get an algorithm that you can program
236
653936
3167
11:09
in a binary code, and that's the defining trait
237
657103
3107
11:12
of the computer program.
238
660210
2051
11:14
But we know that that's purely syntactical. That's symbolic.
239
662261
3883
11:18
We know that actual human consciousness has something more than that.
240
666144
4015
11:22
It's got a content in addition to the syntax.
241
670159
3193
11:25
It's got a semantics.
242
673352
1497
11:26
Now that argument, I made that argument 30 --
243
674849
2489
11:29
oh my God, I don't want to think about it —
244
677338
1291
11:30
more than 30 years ago,
245
678629
1342
11:31
but there's a deeper argument implicit in what I've told you,
246
679971
2490
11:34
and I want to tell you that argument briefly, and that is,
247
682461
3043
11:37
consciousness creates an observer-independent reality.
248
685504
4589
11:42
It creates a reality of money, property, government,
249
690093
3488
11:45
marriage, CERN conferences,
250
693581
3972
11:49
cocktail parties and summer vacations,
251
697553
2619
11:52
and all of those are creations of consciousness.
252
700172
2749
11:54
Their existence is observer-relative.
253
702921
2835
11:57
It's only relative to conscious agents that a piece of paper
254
705756
3503
12:01
is money or that a bunch of buildings is a university.
255
709259
2847
12:04
Now, ask yourself about computation.
256
712106
3874
12:07
Is that absolute, like force and mass and gravitational attraction?
257
715980
3669
12:11
Or is it observer-relative?
258
719649
2132
12:13
Well, some computations are intrinsic.
259
721781
3527
12:17
I add two plus two to get four.
260
725308
1911
12:19
That's going on no matter what anybody thinks.
261
727219
2571
12:21
But when I haul out my pocket calculator
262
729790
2489
12:24
and do the calculation, the only intrinsic phenomenon
263
732279
3782
12:28
is the electronic circuit and its behavior.
264
736061
3175
12:31
That's the only absolute phenomenon.
265
739236
1764
12:33
All the rest is interpreted by us.
266
741000
2428
12:35
Computation only exists relative to consciousness.
267
743428
3841
12:39
Either a conscious agent is carrying out the computation,
268
747269
2775
12:42
or he's got a piece of machinery that admits of a computational interpretation.
269
750044
3643
12:45
Now that doesn't mean computation is arbitrary.
270
753687
3068
12:48
I spent a lot of money on this hardware.
271
756755
2448
12:51
But we have this persistent confusion
272
759203
2146
12:53
between objectivity and subjectivity as features of reality
273
761349
4721
12:58
and objectivity and subjectivity as features of claims.
274
766070
3928
13:01
And the bottom line of this part of my talk is this:
275
769998
3166
13:05
You can have a completely objective science,
276
773164
3651
13:08
a science where you make objectively true claims,
277
776815
2912
13:11
about a domain whose existence is subjective,
278
779727
3430
13:15
whose existence is in the human brain
279
783157
3235
13:18
consisting of subjective states of sentience
280
786392
2139
13:20
or feeling or awareness.
281
788531
1685
13:22
So the objection that you can't have an objective science of consciousness
282
790216
4337
13:26
because it's subjective and science is objective, that's a pun.
283
794553
4208
13:30
That's a bad pun on objectivity and subjectivity.
284
798761
2709
13:33
You can make objective claims
285
801470
2324
13:35
about a domain that is subjective in its mode of existence,
286
803794
4042
13:39
and indeed that's what neurologists do.
287
807836
1573
13:41
I mean, you have patients that actually suffer pains,
288
809409
2490
13:43
and you try to get an objective science of that.
289
811899
2689
13:46
Okay, I promised to refute all these guys,
290
814588
2072
13:48
and I don't have an awful lot of time left,
291
816660
1575
13:50
but let me refute a couple more of them.
292
818235
1908
13:52
I said that behaviorism ought to be
293
820143
2235
13:54
one of the great embarrassments of our intellectual culture,
294
822378
3289
13:57
because it's refuted the moment you think about it.
295
825667
2893
14:00
Your mental states are identical with your behavior?
296
828560
2857
14:03
Well, think about the distinction between feeling a pain
297
831417
3151
14:06
and engaging in pain behavior.
298
834568
1703
14:08
I won't demonstrate pain behavior, but I can tell you
299
836271
1988
14:10
I'm not having any pains right now.
300
838259
1839
14:12
So it's an obvious mistake. Why did they make the mistake?
301
840098
4120
14:16
The mistake was — and you can go back and read
302
844218
1884
14:18
the literature on this, you can see this over and over —
303
846102
2589
14:20
they think if you accept the irreducible existence
304
848691
4016
14:24
of consciousness, you're giving up on science.
305
852707
2795
14:27
You're giving up on 300 years of human progress
306
855502
3071
14:30
and human hope and all the rest of it.
307
858573
1749
14:32
And the message I want to leave you with is,
308
860322
2900
14:35
consciousness has to become accepted
309
863222
2443
14:37
as a genuine biological phenomenon,
310
865665
2488
14:40
as much subject to scientific analysis
311
868153
2467
14:42
as any other phenomenon in biology,
312
870620
1960
14:44
or, for that matter, the rest of science.
313
872580
2154
14:46
Thank you very much.
314
874734
1382
14:48
(Applause)
315
876116
5493
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
John Searle - PhilosopherJohn Searle has made countless contributions to contemporary thinking about consciousness, language, artificial intelligence and rationality itself.
Why you should listen
American philosopher John Serle has made countless contributions to contemporary thinking about consciousness, language, artificial intelligence and rationality itself. In his early work, he focused on the nature of language and what we are conveying when we speak and how the intention behind what we intend to say can the meaning of words from context to context.
He is best known for his “Chinese Room” thought experiment, which challenges the notion of a truly intelligent artificial intelligence. In it, he imagines a room containing an individual, who speaks only English, working with a set of English instructions to write a series of Chinese characters in order to anonymous communicate with a Chinese speaker outside the room. If that individual follows the instructions carefully, she can effectively fool the Chinese speaker into thinking he’s talking to someone who understands his language. Serle argues that, at the very least, the metaphor raises deep complications as to whether or not one can truly describe convincing simulations of intelligence as intelligent.
He remains of firm believer that subjective experiences are real -- even if they don’t always describe things are they really are -- and are worth thinking about in objective terms because of it.
John Searle | Speaker | TED.com