TED@BCG London
Yves Morieux: How too many rules at work keep you from getting things done
Filmed:
Readability: 4.5
2,117,108 views
Modern work -- from waiting tables to crunching numbers to designing products -- is about solving brand-new problems every day, flexibly and collaboratively. But as Yves Morieux shows in this insightful talk, too often, an overload of rules, processes and metrics keeps us from doing our best work together. Meet the new frontier of productivity: cooperation.
Yves Morieux - Consultant
BCG's Yves Morieux researches how corporations can adapt to a modern and complex business landscape. Full bio
BCG's Yves Morieux researches how corporations can adapt to a modern and complex business landscape. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
Paul Krugman, the Nobel Prize
[winner] in economics, once wrote:
[winner] in economics, once wrote:
0
972
5933
00:18
"Productivity is not everything,
but in the long run,
but in the long run,
1
6929
5396
00:24
it is almost everything."
2
12349
2174
00:28
So this is serious.
3
16062
1406
00:30
There are not that many things on earth
that are "almost everything."
that are "almost everything."
4
18214
4804
00:36
Productivity is the principal driver
of the prosperity of a society.
of the prosperity of a society.
5
24138
6773
00:43
So we have a problem.
6
31560
1555
00:45
In the largest European economies,
7
33837
2769
00:48
productivity used to grow
five percent per annum
five percent per annum
8
36630
3150
00:51
in the '50s, '60s, early '70s.
9
39804
3115
00:54
From '73 to '83: three percent per annum.
10
42943
4028
00:58
From '83 to '95: two percent per annum.
11
46995
3289
01:02
Since 1995: less than
one percent per annum.
one percent per annum.
12
50308
4710
01:07
The same profile in Japan.
13
55042
2444
01:10
The same profile in the US,
14
58115
2870
01:13
despite a momentary rebound 15 years ago,
15
61009
5333
01:18
and despite all
the technological innovations
the technological innovations
16
66366
3364
01:21
around us: the Internet, the information,
17
69754
2579
01:24
the new information
and communication technologies.
and communication technologies.
18
72357
3221
01:28
When productivity grows
three percent per annum,
three percent per annum,
19
76155
4579
01:32
you double the standard of living
every generation.
every generation.
20
80758
3642
01:37
Every generation is twice
as well-off as its parents'.
as well-off as its parents'.
21
85169
5009
01:42
When it grows one percent per annum,
22
90686
3326
01:46
it takes three generations
to double the standard of living.
to double the standard of living.
23
94036
3627
01:49
And in this process, many people
will be less well-off than their parents.
will be less well-off than their parents.
24
97687
5794
01:55
They will have less of everything:
25
103505
2514
01:58
smaller roofs, or perhaps no roof at all,
26
106043
3491
02:02
less access to education, to vitamins,
to antibiotics, to vaccination --
to antibiotics, to vaccination --
27
110645
6399
02:09
to everything.
28
117068
1275
02:11
Think of all the problems
that we're facing at the moment.
that we're facing at the moment.
29
119502
5861
02:18
All.
30
126347
1162
02:20
Chances are that they are rooted
in the productivity crisis.
in the productivity crisis.
31
128692
4439
02:27
Why this crisis?
32
135226
1681
02:30
Because the basic tenets
about efficiency --
about efficiency --
33
138438
5475
02:35
effectiveness in organizations,
in management --
in management --
34
143937
4811
02:40
have become counterproductive
for human efforts.
for human efforts.
35
148772
4251
02:45
Everywhere in public services --
in companies, in the way we work,
in companies, in the way we work,
36
153539
4166
02:49
the way we innovate, invest --
try to learn to work better.
try to learn to work better.
37
157729
4336
02:54
Take the holy trinity of efficiency:
38
162954
4486
03:00
clarity, measurement, accountability.
39
168805
5912
03:07
They make human efforts derail.
40
175870
2597
03:11
There are two ways
to look at it, to prove it.
to look at it, to prove it.
41
179650
4072
03:15
One, the one I prefer,
42
183746
2666
03:18
is rigorous, elegant, nice -- math.
43
186436
5545
03:24
But the full math version
takes a little while,
takes a little while,
44
192593
3263
03:27
so there is another one.
45
195880
1795
03:29
It is to look at a relay race.
46
197699
2466
03:32
This is what we will do today.
47
200697
1668
03:34
It's a bit more animated, more visual
and also faster -- it's a race.
and also faster -- it's a race.
48
202389
6350
03:41
Hopefully, it's faster.
49
209572
1294
03:42
(Laughter)
50
210890
1364
03:44
World championship final -- women.
51
212278
4958
03:49
Eight teams in the final.
52
217260
2111
03:51
The fastest team is the US team.
53
219395
2805
03:55
They have the fastest women on earth.
54
223129
2667
03:58
They are the favorite team to win.
55
226153
2775
04:00
Notably, if you compare them
to an average team,
to an average team,
56
228952
4190
04:05
say, the French team,
57
233166
1374
04:06
(Laughter)
58
234564
1587
04:08
based on their best performances
in the 100-meter race,
in the 100-meter race,
59
236175
5195
04:13
if you add the individual times
of the US runners,
of the US runners,
60
241394
5769
04:19
they arrive at the finish line
3.2 meters ahead of the French team.
3.2 meters ahead of the French team.
61
247187
6912
04:26
And this year, the US team
is in great shape.
is in great shape.
62
254438
3024
04:30
Based on their best performance this year,
63
258034
2386
04:32
they arrive 6.4 meters
ahead of the French team,
ahead of the French team,
64
260444
4905
04:37
based on the data.
65
265373
1365
04:39
We are going to look at the race.
66
267274
1579
04:40
At some point you will see,
towards the end,
towards the end,
67
268877
2423
04:43
that Torri Edwards,
the fourth US runner, is ahead.
the fourth US runner, is ahead.
68
271324
6306
04:49
Not surprising -- this year she got
the gold medal in the 100-meter race.
the gold medal in the 100-meter race.
69
277654
6489
04:56
And by the way, Chryste Gaines,
the second runner in the US team,
the second runner in the US team,
70
284167
4942
05:01
is the fastest woman on earth.
71
289133
2637
05:03
So, there are 3.5 billion women on earth.
72
291794
5153
05:09
Where are the two fastest? On the US team.
73
297890
3173
05:13
And the two other runners
on the US team are not bad, either.
on the US team are not bad, either.
74
301087
3273
05:16
(Laughter)
75
304384
1716
05:18
So clearly, the US team has won
the war for talent.
the war for talent.
76
306124
4671
05:24
But behind, the average team
is trying to catch up.
is trying to catch up.
77
312391
3981
05:28
Let's watch the race.
78
316396
1349
05:30
(Video: French sportscasters narrate race)
79
318300
5025
06:18
(Video: Race narration ends)
80
366886
2000
06:22
Yves Morieux: So what happened?
81
370112
1495
06:23
The fastest team did not win;
the slower one did.
the slower one did.
82
371631
4411
06:28
By the way, I hope you appreciate
83
376809
1937
06:30
the deep historical research I did
to make the French look good.
to make the French look good.
84
378770
5926
06:36
(Laughter)
85
384720
2295
06:41
But let's not exaggerate --
it's not archeology, either.
it's not archeology, either.
86
389485
4419
06:45
(Laughter)
87
393928
1981
06:47
But why?
88
395933
1166
06:49
Because of cooperation.
89
397123
1540
06:50
When you hear this sentence:
90
398687
1834
06:52
"Thanks to cooperation, the whole
is worth more than the sum of the parts."
is worth more than the sum of the parts."
91
400545
4401
06:57
This is not poetry;
this is not philosophy.
this is not philosophy.
92
405707
3315
07:01
This is math.
93
409046
1515
07:03
Those who carry the baton are slower,
94
411196
3280
07:06
but their baton is faster.
95
414500
1697
07:08
Miracle of cooperation:
96
416848
1635
07:11
it multiplies energy,
intelligence in human efforts.
intelligence in human efforts.
97
419057
5280
07:16
It is the essence of human efforts:
98
424361
2975
07:19
how we work together, how each effort
contributes to the efforts of others.
contributes to the efforts of others.
99
427360
5816
07:26
With cooperation,
we can do more with less.
we can do more with less.
100
434017
3248
07:29
Now, what happens to cooperation
when the holy grail --
when the holy grail --
101
437788
5548
07:35
the holy trinity, even --
102
443360
2438
07:37
of clarity, measurement, accountability --
103
445822
6221
07:44
appears?
104
452067
1169
07:46
Clarity.
105
454952
1152
07:48
Management reports are full of complaints
about the lack of clarity.
about the lack of clarity.
106
456128
4581
07:53
Compliance audits,
consultants' diagnostics.
consultants' diagnostics.
107
461424
3717
07:58
We need more clarity, we need
to clarify the roles, the processes.
to clarify the roles, the processes.
108
466490
4532
08:04
It is as though the runners
on the team were saying,
on the team were saying,
109
472092
4016
08:08
"Let's be clear -- where does my role
really start and end?
really start and end?
110
476132
5948
08:14
Am I supposed to run for 95 meters,
96, 97...?"
96, 97...?"
111
482938
4832
08:19
It's important, let's be clear.
112
487794
1790
08:22
If you say 97, after 97 meters,
113
490885
3006
08:25
people will drop the baton, whether
there is someone to take it or not.
there is someone to take it or not.
114
493915
3532
08:31
Accountability.
115
499145
1222
08:33
We are constantly trying
to put accountability
to put accountability
116
501084
3450
08:36
in someone's hands.
117
504558
1573
08:38
Who is accountable for this process?
118
506559
2573
08:41
We need somebody accountable
for this process.
for this process.
119
509156
3121
08:44
So in the relay race,
since passing the baton is so important,
since passing the baton is so important,
120
512634
4461
08:49
then we need somebody
clearly accountable for passing the baton.
clearly accountable for passing the baton.
121
517119
3747
08:53
So between each runner,
122
521786
2179
08:55
now we will have a new dedicated athlete,
123
523989
4724
09:00
clearly dedicated to taking
the baton from one runner,
the baton from one runner,
124
528737
4545
09:05
and passing it to the next runner.
125
533306
2296
09:08
And we will have at least two like that.
126
536284
2509
09:12
Well, will we, in that case, win the race?
127
540381
6460
09:19
That I don't know, but for sure,
128
547903
2001
09:21
we would have a clear interface,
129
549928
3270
09:25
a clear line of accountability.
130
553222
2644
09:27
We will know who to blame.
131
555890
1928
09:30
But we'll never win the race.
132
558834
2241
09:33
If you think about it,
we pay more attention
we pay more attention
133
561099
4987
09:38
to knowing who to blame in case we fail,
134
566110
4155
09:42
than to creating
the conditions to succeed.
the conditions to succeed.
135
570289
3721
09:47
All the human intelligence
put in organization design --
put in organization design --
136
575384
3363
09:50
urban structures, processing systems --
137
578771
2785
09:53
what is the real goal?
138
581580
1624
09:56
To have somebody guilty in case they fail.
139
584347
2930
10:00
We are creating
organizations able to fail,
organizations able to fail,
140
588499
4887
10:05
but in a compliant way,
141
593410
2977
10:08
with somebody clearly
accountable when we fail.
accountable when we fail.
142
596411
3442
10:11
And we are quite effective
at that -- failing.
at that -- failing.
143
599877
3824
10:16
Measurement.
144
604892
1161
10:18
What gets measured gets done.
145
606674
1428
10:20
Look, to pass the baton,
you have to do it at the right time,
you have to do it at the right time,
146
608126
4391
10:24
in the right hand, at the right speed.
147
612541
2475
10:27
But to do that, you have to put
energy in your arm.
energy in your arm.
148
615457
2559
10:30
This energy that is in your arm
will not be in your legs.
will not be in your legs.
149
618040
2991
10:33
It will come at the expense
of your measurable speed.
of your measurable speed.
150
621491
2979
10:37
You have to shout early enough
to the next runner
to the next runner
151
625367
3453
10:40
when you will pass the baton,
to signal that you are arriving,
to signal that you are arriving,
152
628844
3311
10:44
so that the next runner
can prepare, can anticipate.
can prepare, can anticipate.
153
632179
3205
10:47
And you have to shout loud.
154
635408
2163
10:50
But the blood, the energy
that will be in your throat
that will be in your throat
155
638182
3973
10:54
will not be in your legs.
156
642179
1400
10:55
Because you know, there are
eight people shouting at the same time.
eight people shouting at the same time.
157
643603
3756
10:59
So you have to recognize the voice
of your colleague.
of your colleague.
158
647383
2639
11:02
You cannot say, "Is it you?"
159
650372
1753
11:04
Too late!
160
652570
1154
11:05
(Laughter)
161
653748
1206
11:06
Now, let's look at the race
in slow motion,
in slow motion,
162
654978
4976
11:11
and concentrate on the third runner.
163
659978
2548
11:14
Look at where she allocates her efforts,
164
662550
4423
11:18
her energy, her attention.
165
666997
2707
11:22
Not all in her legs -- that would
be great for her own speed --
be great for her own speed --
166
670878
3144
11:26
but in also in her throat,
arm, eye, brain.
arm, eye, brain.
167
674046
3490
11:29
That makes a difference in whose legs?
168
677560
2346
11:32
In the legs of the next runner.
169
680314
2112
11:34
But when the next runner runs super-fast,
170
682728
2834
11:37
is it because she made a super effort,
171
685586
2128
11:39
or because of the way
the third runner passed the baton?
the third runner passed the baton?
172
687738
3237
11:43
There is no metric on earth
that will give us the answer.
that will give us the answer.
173
691403
3855
11:48
And if we reward people on the basis
of their measurable performance,
of their measurable performance,
174
696310
4511
11:52
they will put their energy,
their attention, their blood
their attention, their blood
175
700845
3054
11:55
in what can get measured -- in their legs.
176
703923
2023
11:58
And the baton will fall and slow down.
177
706581
2246
12:01
To cooperate is not a super effort,
178
709534
2572
12:04
it is how you allocate your effort.
179
712130
2023
12:07
It is to take a risk,
180
715280
1840
12:09
because you sacrifice
the ultimate protection
the ultimate protection
181
717144
4230
12:13
granted by objectively measurable
individual performance.
individual performance.
182
721398
5427
12:20
It is to make a super difference
in the performance of others,
in the performance of others,
183
728516
3877
12:24
with whom we are compared.
184
732417
1690
12:26
It takes being stupid to cooperate, then.
185
734757
2334
12:29
And people are not stupid;
they don't cooperate.
they don't cooperate.
186
737551
2730
12:32
You know, clarity, accountability,
measurement were OK
measurement were OK
187
740738
5140
12:37
when the world was simpler.
188
745902
2416
12:40
But business has become much more complex.
189
748929
3024
12:43
With my teams, we have measured
190
751977
2031
12:46
the evolution of complexity in business.
191
754032
3024
12:49
It is much more demanding today
to attract and retain customers,
to attract and retain customers,
192
757080
5603
12:54
to build advantage on a global scale,
193
762707
3311
12:58
to create value.
194
766042
1459
13:00
And the more business gets complex,
195
768691
2757
13:03
the more, in the name of clarity,
accountability, measurement
accountability, measurement
196
771472
5301
13:08
we multiply structures,
processes, systems.
processes, systems.
197
776797
3664
13:13
You know, this drive for clarity
and accountability triggers
and accountability triggers
198
781083
4809
13:17
a counterproductive multiplication
of interfaces, middle offices,
of interfaces, middle offices,
199
785916
5355
13:23
coordinators that do not only
mobilize people and resources,
mobilize people and resources,
200
791295
5037
13:28
but that also add obstacles.
201
796356
2309
13:31
And the more complicated the organization,
202
799276
4570
13:35
the more difficult it is to understand
what is really happening.
what is really happening.
203
803870
3653
13:39
So we need summaries, proxies, reports,
204
807547
5420
13:44
key performance indicators, metrics.
205
812991
3300
13:48
So people put their energy
in what can get measured,
in what can get measured,
206
816315
4712
13:53
at the expense of cooperation.
207
821051
2095
13:55
And as performance deteriorates,
208
823170
2532
13:57
we add even more structure,
process, systems.
process, systems.
209
825726
3129
14:00
People spend their time in meetings,
210
828879
2832
14:03
writing reports they have
to do, undo and redo.
to do, undo and redo.
211
831735
4126
14:08
Based on our analysis,
teams in these organizations
teams in these organizations
212
836289
3422
14:11
spend between 40 and 80 percent
of their time wasting their time,
of their time wasting their time,
213
839735
6171
14:17
but working harder and harder,
longer and longer,
longer and longer,
214
845930
3993
14:21
on less and less value-adding activities.
215
849947
2943
14:26
This is what is killing productivity,
216
854242
2310
14:28
what makes people suffer at work.
217
856576
2198
14:31
Our organizations are wasting
human intelligence.
human intelligence.
218
859226
4537
14:35
They have turned against human efforts.
219
863787
3648
14:40
When people don't cooperate,
220
868673
2890
14:43
don't blame their mindsets,
their mentalities, their personality --
their mentalities, their personality --
221
871587
4395
14:48
look at the work situations.
222
876006
2151
14:51
Is it really in their personal interest
to cooperate or not,
to cooperate or not,
223
879125
4249
14:55
if, when they cooperate,
they are individually worse off?
they are individually worse off?
224
883398
3985
14:59
Why would they cooperate?
225
887914
1619
15:01
When we blame personalities
226
889922
3592
15:05
instead of the clarity,
the accountability, the measurement,
the accountability, the measurement,
227
893538
6158
15:11
we add injustice to ineffectiveness.
228
899720
3658
15:17
We need to create organizations
229
905654
1913
15:19
in which it becomes individually useful
for people to cooperate.
for people to cooperate.
230
907591
4314
15:24
Remove the interfaces,
the middle offices --
the middle offices --
231
912807
4795
15:29
all these complicated
coordination structures.
coordination structures.
232
917626
3058
15:33
Don't look for clarity; go for fuzziness.
233
921573
4380
15:37
Fuzziness overlaps.
234
925977
2015
15:41
Remove most of the quantitative metrics
to assess performance.
to assess performance.
235
929244
4480
15:46
Speed the "what."
236
934200
1532
15:48
Look at cooperation, the "how."
237
936414
2817
15:51
How did you pass the baton?
238
939255
1601
15:52
Did you throw it,
or did you pass it effectively?
or did you pass it effectively?
239
940880
3562
15:58
Am I putting my energy
in what can get measured --
in what can get measured --
240
946569
6058
16:04
my legs, my speed --
or in passing the baton?
or in passing the baton?
241
952651
4135
16:08
You, as leaders, as managers,
242
956810
4343
16:13
are you making it individually useful
for people to cooperate?
for people to cooperate?
243
961177
5552
16:20
The future of our organizations,
244
968205
3138
16:23
our companies, our societies
245
971367
3793
16:27
hinges on your answer to these questions.
246
975184
5093
16:33
Thank you.
247
981035
1181
16:34
(Applause)
248
982240
3485
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Yves Morieux - ConsultantBCG's Yves Morieux researches how corporations can adapt to a modern and complex business landscape.
Why you should listen
Yves Morieux thinks deeply about what makes organizations work effectively. A senior partner in BCG’s Washington D.C. office and director of the BCG Institute for Organization, Morieux considers how overarching changes in structure can improve motivation for all who work there. His calls his approach "Smart Simplicity." Using six key rules, it encourages employees to cooperate in order to solve long-term problems. It isn’t just about reducing costs and increasing profit -- it’s about maximizing engagement through all levels of a company. Morieux has been featured in articles on organizational evolution in Harvard Business Review, The Economist, The Wall Street Journal, Fast Company and Le Monde.
Yves Morieux | Speaker | TED.com